The ownership transition of the Padres, recently thought to be a straightforward process, is now anything but, and threatens to heavily alter the team’s immediate future.
Two weeks after John Seidler, the older brother of late Padres owner Peter Seidler, was set to become the team’s new designated control executive, Peter’s widow, Sheel, has filed a lawsuit that, among several other claims, alleges two other brothers-in-law have wrongly “schemed to solidify their control of the Padres” and have “falsely cast themselves as Peter’s true heirs.”
The 97-page action against two other Seidler brothers, Matt and Bob—filed in probate court in Travis County, Texas—alleges multiple breaches of fiduciary duty, fraud, and gross negligence, as well as racism against Sheel Seidler, who is of Indian descent. In particular, she alleges several members of the extended Seidler family engaged “in multiple racist, profane, and hateful communications directed at” her because of her ethnicity.
“For example, in a message on Oct. 15, 2024, the same day Matt unceremoniously told Sheel that she lacked ‘the experience, skills, and financial acumen necessary’ to be named Padres control person, [Bob’s wife] Alecia (copying Bob) sent an email that perfectly encapsulated the Seidler family’s view of Sheel: ‘Do you really think this family would work for your f***ing purple ass? You are delusional!’” the lawsuit reads in part.
Matt and Bob Seidler are the named defendants, as they are the executor and former executor, respectively, of the estate of Peter, who died in November 2023. Sheel claims it was Peter’s dying wish for her to take over the club, and eventually their three children.
In a subsequent social-media statement, Sheel called the lawsuit “a very last resort.”
“I do not wish to litigate this matter in public, but rest assured I will do what it takes to protect my children, Peter’s legacy, and this remarkable ball club,” she said. “I look forward to a quick resolution so that we can—together—continue the work ahead.”
The Seider trust said Sheel’s action and the claims within it are “entirely without merit.”
“In 2020, in connection with Peter’s appointment as [Padres] control person, Sheel agreed in a sworn document that she had no right to be or designate the control person, and that she would not interfere with the designated control person,” the trust said in a statement.
Team Questions
The dispute—though somewhat common to several other family disputes over the years in pro team ownership—arrives at an already delicate time for the Padres.
A defining note of Peter Seidler’s ownership was the Padres’ push to boost payroll and challenge the Dodgers, winners of 11 of the last 12 National League West division titles and the 2024 World Series champions. In 2023, Peter Seidler’s final season, San Diego’s payroll reached $282.8 million, the third highest in MLB and more than twice the level of 2019—the last full season before he took control of the club in late 2020.
After his death, however, the club’s spending dropped precipitously to $184.9 million in 2024, MLB’s 15th highest. During this transition period, the team also traded away Juan Soto, who played one season with the Yankees before signing a record-setting $765 million deal with the Mets. Despite the cuts, the Padres reached the NL Division Series, falling to the Dodgers in five games.
In the lawsuit, Sheel Seidler suggests a potentially more dire outcome for the franchise under John.
“Matt’s efforts to promote his brother John as control person and to block Sheel may well be part of his efforts to sell, and perhaps relocate, the team, over Sheel’s strident objections,” the lawsuit reads in part.
