No. 11 Texas Tech softball’s transfer-laden team, which will play No. 1 Alabama in the semi-finals of the Women’s College World Series on Monday night, has been at the center of controversy during this year’s NCAA Softball tournament.
A year after the school’s NIL collective spent $1 million for star ace NiJaree Canady (who signed another seven-figure deal after the 2025 season) and fell in the WCWS finals to Texas, the Red Raiders have reloaded with even more transfer talent. They added seven new players from the portal ahead of 2026—15 of the 23 players on their current roster did not begin their careers in Lubbock.
The controversies surrounding this new transfer class started a year ago, when Texas Tech was accused of using third parties to recruit players on other rosters, but have come to a head this postseason. Florida transfer Mia Williams, and later Tennessee transfer Taylor Pannell both made headlines for disputes while facing their old teams.
“We’re doing things that maybe never [have] been before,” Texas Tech head coach Gerry Glasco said ahead of the World Series. Glasco was brought to Lubbock in 2025 and helped lead the Red Raiders to their first-ever WCWS appearance. “I’m enjoying every moment, and if softball needs me to be the villain, I’m all about it.”
‘She Said That I Made a Mistake’
Tennessee’s walk-off win against Texas Tech on Saturday sent the Volunteers into the semi-finals and the Red Raiders into the elimination bracket. Following the game, Red Raider third baseman Pannell said her former coach, Tennessee’s Karen Weekly, had words for her in the handshake line.
“She said that I made a mistake instead of saying ‘good game’,” Pannell, who spent three seasons with Tennessee, said of Weekly. “Which is kind of crazy…I just think it’s funny she’s still thinking about it, but it’s old news.”
Weekly said in her press conference that she merely said “good game” to Pannell, which she said to everyone else. Later, she called Pannell’s allegations an “outright lie.” On Sunday, ESPN aired zoomed-in footage of the interaction, with commentator Beth Mowins backing up Weekly’s claim.
However, Mowins noted that Glasco asks Pannell “did somebody say something?” and Pannell responded. ESPN declined to further comment on the matter to FOS.
According to screenshots from Softball On SI, Pannell’s father, Brandon, made numerous X posts on the alleged handshake line incident. “@KarenWeekly was right that my kid did make a mistake and that was to play for her….” he wrote.
Last year, Pannell entered the transfer portal and committed to Texas Tech shortly after Tennessee was eliminated from the WCWS. Weekly told The Athletic that there was “no question” the Red Raiders were contacting “our player” while she was still with Tennessee, and that Pannell told her she signed a “financial agreement” with them before entering the portal.
More Handshake Scrutiny
A week before Pannell became entangled in a dispute, her teammate, second baseman Mia Williams, dealt with her own. Williams’s controversy took place in Gainesville, where Texas Tech played Florida in the NCAA Super Regionals from May 22 to 24.
Williams, who spent her first two seasons with Florida, was hit by pitch five times across the three-game Supers series. Her teammates came out of the dugout after the fifth hit that occurred in Game 3, and Glasco signalled them to go back inside. Following the game, Florida did not shake hands with Texas Tech players, who formed a handshake line.
In her postgame interview, Canady noted the handshake snub, as well as Williams’s hit-by-pitch at-bats. Florida head coach Tim Walton, who was ejected mid-game for arguing about umpire calls, said he had “no idea” where the dispute between the two teams’ players came from.
“I don’t think that’s fair to the kids in both dugouts,” Walton said. “I have no idea where that pot was being stirred. There’s never been a problem ever. Kids transfer all the time.”
Williams’s father, former Gators and NBA basketball player Jason Williams, accused Walton of intentionally getting ejected to avoid shaking his daughter’s hand. Williams also said he’d only come on Florida’s campus if his daughter plays softball there again.
Texas Tech takes on Alabama in a semifinals elimination game at 7 p.m. Monday on ESPN. If it defeats the Crimson Tide, it will play a second, if-necessary game against them to decide who will play in the finals against the winner of the Texas-Tennessee semis.
