Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?
MLB is still firmly headed toward a likely lockout next month of the MLB Players Association, but a Friday bargaining session produced some progress regarding baseball’s amateur entry systems.
The union is again resisting a full-scale international draft that owners have sought for more than two decades. Players, however, did offer to implement “a series of measures designed to prevent clubs from making predatory pre-agreements with young international players.”
Those provisions would seek to create additional structures and penalty provisions surrounding international amateur signings. The union move on international amateurs also aims to address a complex and often-corrupt system where handshake deals are commonly struck with players below the minimum signing age of 16 and trainers command massive portions of signing bonuses.
“Our proposals would help build upon baseball’s advances as an international game, while safeguarding the interests of young athletes who are the future of our sport,” said MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer.
The union is also proposing increases in the international signing bonus pools that MLB teams have, and greater latitude for teams to trade available pool space. The current pool system is designed for amateur players coming from outside of the U.S., Canada, and Puerto Rico, and heavily involves baseball-rich countries such as the Dominican Republic, Venezuela, and Panama.
In response, the league said it is dropping a prior proposal to restrict U.S.-born players from entering the domestic draft before reaching age 20. That offer from June, made as part of a larger overhaul of the draft that club owners want, received immediate and widespread criticism, including from the union. It also counters the many Baseball Hall of Famers and MLB all-stars who began their big-league careers as teenagers.
Management, however, remains fervent in its desire for an international draft.
“In recognition of the feedback we received from the MLBPA on our domestic amateur proposal, we made a concession today by withdrawing our proposal on high school eligibility and proposed to maintain the current entry rules on domestic amateurs,” said MLB spokesman Glen Caplin. “On the international system, we continue to believe it is long past time to reform the system in ways that would address longstanding challenges and benefit future players.”
Elephant in the Room
Even with this incremental progress on the amateur entry matters, players and owners remain starkly divided on a hard salary cap and floor.
The cap-and-floor system, recently modified to target a 2028 start, is the centerpiece of management’s bargaining platform. MLB commissioner Rob Manfred said Wednesday that there will be “no compromise” on this front, and the cap is also the foundation of sought-after changes to local media and player compensation.
The union, conversely, sees a cap as an erosion of contract covenants and overall pay, is just as firm in its resistance, and calls the cap something that “artificially suppresses player salaries, player movement, and player guarantees.”
Even with that, the ongoing negotiation between the two sides leaves a faint glimmer of hope that a deal can ultimately be reached.
Download the FOS App
The business of sports, in your pocket.
Scan the QR code to get the app now.