Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?
The MLB Players Association says MLB is attempting to suppress player compensation with a proposed salary cap system. The league, conversely, argues it is seeking to restructure how players are paid.
While the union and league battle over the future of baseball’s economics and are barreling toward a management lockout, a lesser-known element also lies at the heart of MLB’s vision of the future. Team owners want to change the current separation between player compensation and their on-field value.
According to MLB research presented this week to reporters, players with six years or fewer of major league service and not eligible for free agency delivered 71% of the league’s aggregate on-field value, as measured by wins over replacement (WAR). That group, however, received just 31% of the total compensation.
The group of players with more than six years of major league service, conversely, delivered 29% of the collective WAR, but received 69% of the total pay. Skewing that figure, of course, are record-setting deals such as Juan Soto’s $765 million pact with the Mets and Shohei Ohtani’s $700 million contract with the Dodgers.
“That mismatch is not great,” said MLB EVP of baseball operations Morgan Sword. “It’s not great for labor relations. It’s not great for fans. And it’s not great as a logical matter, that the players who are actually creating the wins are not the ones being paid [the most].”
Structural Divides
A core part of this divergence lies in MLB’s current reserve system. As of now, big-league players achieve salary arbitration eligibility after three full years of service, and free agency can happen only after six full years, when the average MLB career lasts roughly five and a half years. By definition, that tilts some of the sport’s aggregate WAR to younger, pre-arbitration and pre-free agency stars such as the Yankees’ Cam Schlittler and the Brewers’ Jacob Misiorowski, this year’s Cy Young Award winners.
“The small-market clubs that are at a gigantic payroll disadvantage rely on that zero-to-6 [years of service time] group to field competitive teams,” Sword said. “Without the benefits of the reserve system, it is almost impossible for teams with lower revenues to be competitive. But once you fix the payroll disparity problem and bring clubs more in line with each other, it opens up the ability for us to do a lot more for these younger players.”
MLB’s labor proposal regarding the reserve system seeks to change that by raising the league’s minimum salary from the current $780,000 to $1 million for all players with at least two years of service time. Owners have also offered to allow free agency after five years of service for players who have reached their 30th birthday, as well as an openness to increased compensation for arbitration-eligible players. Some of those potential shifts are in line with changes sought by the players.
Management’s position on these fronts, however, is explicitly tied to a hard salary cap and floor it is seeking. Team owners insist they will not sign a new labor agreement without one, vowing “no compromise” on that issue, while the union is just as firm in its opposition to a cap.
Additionally, the league’s position on the reserve system calls for dramatic cuts to free agent contract size and length within a salary cap, achieved in part through a reconstruction of local media rights. The management proposal calls for a five-year $202 million limit on free-agent deals involving players switching teams, and an upper threshold of six years and $265 million for those staying with their existing teams.
That would make impossible future deals resembling Ohtani’s and Soto’s, or even the many others that exceeded the sought-after limits. It also helps explain why a record-setting contract for free-agent pitcher Tarik Skubal is expected before the current labor deal expires Dec. 1.
The union has long blasted management’s vision regarding the reserve system and a cap-based structure as a zero-sum game that pits player against player and reduces overall compensation for players.
“It’s not about teams not having hope,” MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer said during the World Series. “It’s about their desire to have a system that artificially suppresses player salaries, player movement, and player guarantees.”
Download the FOS App
The business of sports, in your pocket.
Scan the QR code to get the app now.