Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?
PALM BEACH GARDENS, Fla. — A top executive for TGL and WTGL is pushing back against the notion that the simulator technology used for the virtual golf leagues isn’t up to par.
“It’s invalid,” Andrew Macaulay, chief technology officer of the leagues’ parent company TMRW Sports, told Front Office Sports on Monday when asked about the perception ahead of the third match of WTGL’s inaugural season.
Michelle Wie West created a viral moment in WTGL’s first match on Nov. 8 when she vehemently disagreed with how a 98-yard wedge shot she hit was picked up by the simulator. “That wasn’t a spinny shot,” she said twice to her teammates after the ball landed near the pin and spun back to the bottom of the green. “That was a low shot.”
Macaulay said there were no technical errors with Wie West’s shot. “It was accurate,” he said. “She hit the shot. We talked to her afterwards—all the data was good.” In her post-match press conference, Wie West was less heated when asked about the tech overall. “I thought it was pretty accurate,” she said. “Obviously it’s different, right? It’s different from green grass golf. It’s different. But it’s as good as it can be. It’s definitely a learning curve.”
All TGL and WTGL matches are played at the 1,500-seat SoFi Center in South Florida. Players hit tee and approach shots into a 64-foot-tall screen, and simulator technology shows where the ball ends up in the virtual holes. Chipping and putting are done at a real-life short game area inside the arena.
During TGL’s first two seasons, there were other instances of the men’s golfers also appearing confused about how their shot was read by the simulator—particularly shorter wedge shots like Wie West’s. Many within the golf media have picked up on this, leading to some criticism online that the technology being used isn’t good enough.
While some players haven’t been able to hide their facial reactions in real-time, they rarely publicly criticise the tech. “It’s never spirited afterwards,” Macaulay said. “A few occasions where somebody wanted to check the numbers, and we go through it. It’s always like, ‘Oh, okay.’ We’ll show them video of the swing as well, if necessary, and they’re like, ‘Okay.’”
Depth perception could be one explanation for why some players hit errant shots they wouldn’t typically on a green grass course. The main tee box is 35 yards away from the giant simulator screen, and the front tee box is just 21 yards away. When Season 1 began, shots under 130 yards were hit from the front tee box, but after a few matches, it switched to only shots under 70 yards, as players preferred to mostly hit from the back tee box. Wedge shots will often fly over the screen, but Macaulay said a ball is not required to hit the screen in order to get an accurate read.
Macaulay leads a team of about 20 tech-focused employees, about 12 of whom are typically on-site for matches. They tested 34 different types of golf balls that can be used during competition. There has been just one instance of a shot having to be replayed due to tech issues—in Season 1 when the simulator picked up a divot instead of the ball during one of Tommy Fleetwood’s shots.
Tech Talk
TGL and WTGL are in the midst of multiyear deals with two primary tech providers: Full Swing for the simulator and gameplay, and Toptracer for ball-tracing. When players hit shots, the ball is read by six Full Swing sensors behind them and eight Toptracer cameras on the roof above them.
Tiger Woods, cofounder of TMRW Sports alongside Rory McIlroy, is an investor in Full Swing, which often gets the brunt of criticism when the simulator tech is perceived to be acting up. But it’s the combination of Full Swing and Toptracer tech that produces the final product in virtual TGL and WTGL holes.
“It actually takes a hybrid version of all that to make it as accurate as we could possibly make it in the game,” Macaulay said. Golf Channel parent company Versant bought Full Swing for $530 million this year, and Woods remained an investor.
“All tech has a margin of error,” Macaulay said. “And I’m super happy with how close ours is to the ground truth.”
After Tuesday’s Motor City Golf Club–Boston Common Golf match, Megan Khang said she thought that extra adrenaline from the arena atmosphere led to her hitting the ball farther than normal, but felt confident in the simulator tech. “I think the more you play here at SoFi, the more you get used to it,” she said. “The numbers are super accurate.”
WTGL’s inaugural season runs through Dec. 23, and TGL’s third season begins Dec. 27, with a seventh expansion franchise and expanded roster sizes (five players per team) with a league roster of 35 players. ESPN holds TGL’s media rights and splits WTGL’s rights with Ion.
Download the FOS App
The business of sports, in your pocket.
Scan the QR code to get the app now.