Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?
The NFL’s celebrated 2024 draft class of quarterbacks entered the league with outsized expectations, even by NFL Draft standards. The stakes were raised considerably when six quarterbacks were chosen in the first 12 picks of that draft, setting up the class to be either historically great or memorably disappointing.
The first major financial checkpoint for measuring the progress of those six quarterbacks arrives after this season. Under the NFL’s rookie pay system, players are eligible to sign contract extensions following their third season in the league.
It will be one of the NFL’s biggest offseason storylines, perhaps only trailing the resolution of Lamar Jackson’s contract status with the Ravens. For now, agents and front office executives are debating which members of the ’24 quarterback class deserve top-of-the-market quarterback money and which don’t.
That conversation mostly is about the Bears’ Caleb Williams, the Commanders’ Jayden Daniels, and the Patriots’ Drake Maye. The Broncos’ Bo Nix has become more polarizing, amassing wins but prompting questions about his level of play. The Falcons’ Michael Penix Jr. and the Giants’ J.J. McCarthy have been slower to build their NFL résumés, in part due to injuries and to being relegated to backup status at times.
“Caleb, yes,” one agent told Front Office Sports. “Daniels and Maye have to show durability and Nix has to show [enough] talent.”
The newest data point that could factor into the upcoming contract maneuvering is the injury suffered by Maye to his right ankle during the Patriots’ loss Sunday to the Lions in Munich, reportedly feared to be a fracture that could end his season.
Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes currently is the NFL’s highest-paid player by average annual value at $63.1 million. The Cowboys’ Dak Prescott is second at $60 million per season, followed by the Bengals’ Joe Burrow, the Packers’ Jordan Love, the Jaguars’ Trevor Lawrence, the Bills’ Josh Allen, the Buccaneers’ Baker Mayfield, and the Rams’ Matthew Stafford at $55 million per season.
The NFL’s 13 highest-paid players are quarterbacks; they all have deals worth at least $51 million per season.
This season’s NFL salary cap is $301.2 million per team. So Mahomes’s $63.1 million average represents 20.9% of the cap.
The cap made a jump of $22 million per team, or 7.9%, from last season’s $279.2 million. If it makes a similar leap next season to nearly $325 million per team, a quarterback contract averaging $70 million per season would represent 21.5% of the cap–a slight but perhaps manageable increase.
Some people within the league expect Jackson, who has a deal worth $52 million annually that runs through the 2027 season, to become the NFL’s first $70 million-a-year player this offseason. Whether Williams or any of his 2024 draft-mates approaches or even surpasses that figure remains to be seen.
“None of those guys is a top-five quarterback in the league yet, to me,” an executive with one team told FOS. “Caleb Williams is the closest to that. He’s close. But it’s more about whose turn it is. They’re the next guys in line, and you have to pay the going rate.”
Players taken in the opening round of the draft sign four-year contracts with fifth-year options for their teams, under the rookie pay system that was negotiated by the NFL and the NFL Players Association. So their teams don’t necessarily have to complete extensions this offseason with the quarterbacks drafted in 2024. But if they don’t, they risk the price tag going even higher from here.
Williams, as the No. 1 pick, signed a four-year contract with the Bears worth a guaranteed $39.49 million. He is making about $4.3 million in salary and bonuses this season while counting approximately $10.7 million against the Bears’ salary cap, including the prorated amount of his original signing bonus. He is set to make about $6 million next season and count approximately $12.5 million against the cap.
The four-year deals signed by Daniels and Maye were slotted slightly lower, at $37.75 million for Daniels and $36.64 million for Maye. The luxury that teams have in constructing rosters around productive young quarterbacks on comparatively cheap, cap-friendly contracts eventually disappears once the big-money portions of expensive long-term extensions kick in. But that’s the cost of having an excellent quarterback, and teams simply must adapt.

Daniels, chosen second in ’24 after Williams was taken first, was the first of the group to become an NFL star. He took the Commanders to the NFC Championship Game as a rookie and was named the NFL’s offensive rookie of the year.
But he has struggled with injuries since, and his play has been decidedly less dazzling. He missed time last season because of a dislocated left elbow, then suffered the same injury early this season and missed two games before returning to the lineup. He is represented by his mother, Regina Jackson, who is an NFLPA-certified agent. Daniels lost the offensive coordinator, Kliff Kingsbury, who orchestrated his rookie-year success and could endure a head coaching change next, if the Commanders don’t retain Dan Quinn.
Maye, the third player to come off the board on draft night, overtook Daniels last season as the biggest standout in the draft class. He led the Patriots to a Super Bowl appearance and finished a close second to Stafford in the NFL’s MVP voting.
But things have been far tougher this season for Maye and the Patriots, who are a .500 team 10 games into their season in the aftermath of the offseason scandal involving coach Mike Vrabel. Maye suffered his injury Sunday on the same play—a sack by Lions star pass rusher Aidan Hutchinson—that led to Hutchinson suffering a torn ACL in his right knee celebrating the sack. Maye did not accompany the Patriots on their flight home Sunday from Germany but traveled back to the U.S. on Monday.
“I wouldn’t imagine him being available when we come out of the bye,” Vrabel said at a news conference Monday, with his team now on its bye week.
Nix helped the Broncos to reach the AFC Championship Game last season. But he missed that game, a loss to Maye and the Patriots, after suffering a broken ankle at the end of a playoff win over the Bills the previous weekend. The Broncos are back in Super Bowl contention this season. But Nix, while he has demonstrated a knack for winning close games, has not become an eye-catching NFL passer.
Penix, drafted by the Falcons into an awkward situation after they’d just signed Kirk Cousins to a big contract in free agency, began his rookie season as a backup and has had his development slowed by a knee injury. He has provided glimpses of brilliant play but must show he can sustain that.
McCarthy, drafted by the Vikings, failed to become a reliable NFL starter in Minnesota and was traded in September to the Giants. If he plays well in what remains of this season, that will give the Giants an intriguing offseason choice to make after they lost second-year quarterback Jaxson Dart to a knee injury suffered early this season.
All of that leaves Williams right back where he started: at the head of this class. He was taken first overall in 2024 by the Bears after being a Heisman Trophy winner at USC. He drew some pre-draft comparisons to Mahomes for his improvisational skills. He fell behind first Daniels and then Maye in his NFL development. But he has continued to improve, particularly after the Bears hired Ben Johnson as their coach prior to last season.
Williams is currently the NFL’s 14th-rated passer, putting him one spot behind Prescott and one spot ahead of Stafford. He has the Bears in a virtual three-way tie for first place in the rugged NFC North division, with a 7–2 record. He had a recent four-interception game that belied his usual avoidance of such costly mistakes. He provides spectacular plays on occasion, in Mahomes-like fashion. And he has undeniable star quality, even drawing attention when he was fined twice by the NFL for wearing cleats with logos not authorized by the league.
The Bears reached the divisional round of the NFC playoffs last season and could go further this time. Then their quarterback, who’s not represented by an NFLPA-certified agent but has a representation team led by his father Carl, could cash in.
“I think that’s the guy you pay the most,” the NFL front office executive said, suggesting that Williams is worth a deal at or near the top of a quarterback market expected to soon approach and then surpass $70 million per season.
Download the FOS App
The business of sports, in your pocket.
Scan the QR code to get the app now.