Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?
With an expected MLB lockout just days away, the league is ramping up its public awareness push as it pursues a highly controversial salary cap and floor.
As part of a “Level the Playing Field” campaign first unveiled during the summer, MLB has released a five-minute video entitled “Baseball’s Payroll Disparity Problem Explained: The Case for a Salary Cap and Floor,” marking the latest move in a rising attempt to use public pressure and populism in an ongoing labor battle with the MLB Players Association.
In the highly produced clip, MLB EVP of baseball operations Morgan Sword lays out management’s bid to implement a hard cap and floor. Sword also reiterated a plan for team owners to pool local media revenue as part of a cap-based economic system, something the league argues would address blackouts that have been long hated by fans.
“Our thinking here is that making changes is going to set baseball up to grow for the next several decades,” Sword said. “Put simply, each generation of kids in each of our markets needs to feel like their team has a real chance to win in order to connect with that team and follow them for a lifetime. It’s hard to buy tickets or a jersey when you feel like your favorite player is going to end up in New York or L.A. one day.”
The clip is currently pinned on MLB’s X account, and has received more than 1.7 million impressions. The league has also distributed it on several other platforms, including Instagram and YouTube.
Sword’s selection to appear in the video owes in part to his direct involvement in many labor-related issues, his seniority within the league office, and his comfort and experience in front of the camera. Sword also was heavily involved in recent MLB successes with the pitch clock and ABS challenge system. The broader message of listening to fan concerns, however, is one that MLB has made for years.
“We have a responsibility to communicate directly with fans through every available channel about our efforts to address the growing disparity in payrolls between the game’s biggest and smallest markets,” MLB spokesman Glen Caplin said in a statement provided to Front Office Sports. “A salary cap and floor, as used by every other major U.S. professional sports league, would create a more level playing field and give every club a fair chance to compete.”
The league is also undeterred by Milwaukee, MLB’s smallest media market, winning the 2026 World Series with the No. 19 payroll, pointing to longer-term trends in which higher-payroll clubs tend to win more in the regular season and advance further in the postseason.
“MLB has the widest payroll gap in sports, and it’s not even close,” Sword said.
What’s Not in the Video
Not surprisingly, the clip has generated strong pushback from the union and individual players. The MLBPA has consistently rejected any calls for a salary cap, and instead is seeking to preserve the core of the current, market-based system.
Notably, the Sword video also does not mention several significant cutbacks that owners are seeking in the current labor talks—including limitations on the size and length of free-agent contracts, and new restrictions on signing bonuses and entry rules for drafted players.
“This is comically bad. They’re being very careful and selective of what they’re saying/showing and how they’re delivering it,” free-agent pitcher Jameson Taillon wrote in a social-media post. Taillon has been an active MLBPA member, and previously was on the union’s executive subcommittee.
“This is going to be ugly if they’re trying to sway fan/public support weeks before they even lock us out. At the end of the day, they want to drive down salaries and put more money in the pockets of billionaires. It’s never been about competition for them, just a nice cover up,” Taillon said.
Owners and players remain deeply divided on the core bargaining issues, and a management lockout is widely expected when the current labor deal expires on Dec. 1. At that point, all player transactions will halt, ending what has been a compressed offseason thus far.
“The results of these playoffs obviously further undermine [the owners’] argument, and why they think they want a [salary] cap,” MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer said during the World Series in response to a FOS question. “But that’s not the reason why they want it, and it’s never been the reason why they want it.
“The fact that they’re doubling down on the cap in the wake of what’s happening, and this World Series, just illustrates that it’s not about competitive balance. It’s not about teams not having hope. It’s about their desire to have a system that artificially suppresses player salaries, player movement, and player guarantees,” he said.
The Sword video also marks the latest element in what has been a highly public set of labor negotiations between MLB and the MLBPA, differing heavily from prior rounds.
Team owners, meanwhile, are having a regularly scheduled meeting in New York this week, in what will likely be their final in-person gathering before the lockout begins.
Download the FOS App
The business of sports, in your pocket.
Scan the QR code to get the app now.