Sunday, April 12, 2026

Yankees Dragging Feet On $200M-Plus Aaron Judge Extension

  • The three-time All-Star will be a free agent following 2022 season.
  • The sides are $4 million apart in arbitration figures.
Nathan Ray Seebeck-USA TODAY Sports

Aaron Judge set an Opening Day deadline for a contract extension with the Yankees.

Even with Thursday’s first game against the Red Sox postponed until Friday (12:05 p.m. ET), it doesn’t appear the sides will reach an agreement in time.

For a team that seems perpetually in win-now mode, the Yankees are playing a dangerous game not locking up the face of the franchise.

  • If the 29-year-old doesn’t sign a long-term deal, he’ll head to midseason arbitration to determine a one-year contract. 
  • Judge filed for $21M, while the Yankees countered with $17M, per MLB.com.
  • He received a $1.8M signing bonus as the No. 32 pick in 2013 and since signed six consecutive one-year deals, including one for $10.2M in 2021.
  • He’s a three-time All-Star who finished fourth in 2021 AL MVP voting after slashing .287/.373/.544 with 39 HRs and 98 RBI.

Judge likely wants a six- or seven-year extension north of $200M, which would pass Derek Jeter’s 10-year, $189M deal from 2001 as the Bronx Bombers’ largest. 

The Yankees are never too shy to spend big: They have the third-highest payroll ($240.3M), with ace Gerrit Cole earning $36M per season, MLB’s second-highest AAV (Max Scherzer, $43.3M). 

In the midst of a 12-year title drought, New York should make Judge as comfortable as possible — as soon as possible.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Pirates Break From Frugal Past With Record $140M Konnor Griffin Deal

The low-budget club signs the rookie phenom to a historic contract.

MLB’s Rookie Stars Are Delivering Big Value on Small Contracts

A fertile crop of first-year players is making an immediate impact.

Three MLB Teams Move Games to Avoid Cold Weather

The Guardians, White Sox, and Mets are moving night games.

Red Sox Skid, Liverpool Unrest Puts FSG Under Mounting Pressure

Fans of two Fenway Sports Group–owned teams are growing restless.

Featured Today

Matthew Schaefer/Front Office Sports

Matthew Schaefer Has the Hockey World in His Thrall

The teenage Islanders defenseman cannon-balled into the NHL.
April 9, 2026

College Athletes Are Ignoring NCAA Gambling Bans

“We were going to bet regardless,” says one former D-I athlete.
April 8, 2026

Why Did FIFA Do a Deal With an Obscure Prediction Market?

The product is scheduled to launch on Thursday.
Mar 28, 2026; Houston, TX, USA; Illinois Fighting Illini forward David Mirkovic (0) and center Tomislav Ivisic (13) react in the second half against the Iowa Hawkeyes during an Elite Eight game of the South Regional of the men's 2026 NCAA Tournament at Toyota Center.
April 4, 2026

Loopholes Enable Int’l College Basketball Players to Cash In

Schools have scrambled to find a way to compensate international players.

WNBA Free Agency Tracker: Welcome to the Million-Dollar Era

The supermax deal is worth $1.4 million per year.
exclusive
April 9, 2026

Sky, Sparks Close to Ariel Atkins–Rickea Jackson Trade

Atkins can sign a deal with the Sparks worth $1.19 million.
April 10, 2026

Pile of Famous Athletes Quietly Invested in Kalshi Months Ago

WNBA stars Diana Taurasi and Breanna Stewart are among the group.
Sponsored

From Gold Medalist to Business Founder

Allyson Felix on investing in women’s sports and what comes next for track & LA28.
Apr 9, 2025; Dallas, Texas, USA; Los Angeles Lakers guard Austin Reaves (15) walks on to the court before the game between the Dallas Mavericks and the Los Angeles Lakers during the first quarter at the American Airlines Center
April 8, 2026

Mavericks Tell Lakers ‘No Error’ in Austin Reaves MRI

The Lakers coach accused Dallas’s medical staff of scanning “the wrong area.”
Apr 14, 2024; Augusta, Georgia, USA; Tiger Woods reacts to his putt on the 16th green during the final round of the Masters Tournament.
April 7, 2026

Masters Stars Feel Unprecedented Absence of Tiger and Phil

This is the first Masters since 1994 without both Woods and Mickelson.
April 7, 2026

Can the Dream Capitalize on Angel Reese’s Popularity?

Reese’s trade from Chicago to Atlanta is making an impact.
April 6, 2026

Patrick Reed: Golf Apparel Free Agency ‘Been Fun’ After LIV Exit

The 2018 Masters champion is starting to sign new deals.