• Loading stock data...
Saturday, August 2, 2025
Tuned In returns to NYC on September 16. Hear from the biggest names in sports media. Click here to get your spot

The House Settlement Is in Jeopardy. Here’s What It Will Take to Save It

Over the next two weeks, the NCAA and former Power 5 conferences have a decision to make: Relinquish control or risk losing billions at trial.

Mar 26, 2025; San Francisco, CA, USA; Detail view of the logo and basketballs during NCAA Tournament West Regional Practice at Chase Center. Mandatory Credit: Eakin Howard-Imagn Images

In a five-page order issued Wednesday, Northern District of California Judge Claudia Wilken dropped a bombshell: She wouldn’t approve the potentially landmark House v. NCAA settlement—which would allow schools to pay players for the first time—unless parties fixed an issue with roster limits.

Wilken set a two-week deadline, promising to reject the settlement if the parties didn’t make the changes she requested on this specific issue. In statements Wednesday night, plaintiff attorneys said they would work on the issue with defendants’ attorneys, who said their priority was still to approve the settlement.

The NCAA, along with the former Power 5 conferences, now have a decision to make: Relinquish control or risk losing billions of dollars at trial, as well as any goodwill they may have built in Congress by agreeing to change their business model with the House settlement.

Roster limits have become a main concern over the past few months, with hundreds of athletes filing objections—and several speaking at the fairness hearing on April 7. The crux of the settlement, which involves three federal cases, would offer $2.8 billion in damages to athletes who couldn’t profit off name, image, and likeness (NIL) before 2021, as well as allow D-I schools to share up to $20.5 million with all their players this year. But the settlement imposed other restrictions, one of which was a clearinghouse to scrutinize NIL collective deals, ensuring that they’re “fair-market value.” Another was roster limits: The NCAA agreed to lift any limits on the number of scholarships given to college athletes, allowing schools to offer full rides to as many players as they could afford to, so long as their teams abided by new caps on rosters. This particular provision creates its own problem because many current players have been cut in order to satisfy these new restrictions, and incoming athletes have had their roster spots rescinded.

During that hearing, Wilken appeared to endorse a solution: “grandfather” in all the current athletes on teams, as well as all future athletes who have already received roster spot offers, so that cuts would impact them. That way, roster limits could be phased in so no athletes lost an opportunity they’d already received. 

Ultimately, the parties declined to make changes, saying roster limits were reasonable restrictions in the sports world, and that the grandfathering idea would be too disruptive to teams that had already cut players in anticipation of the settlement. Wilken, however, didn’t buy it, saying that she couldn’t approve a settlement that harmed some of the members of the plaintiff class. 

Over the next 14 days, attorneys for all parties will confer, among themselves and with the designated settlement mediator, to see if they can salvage the agreement. 

The NCAA had previously indicated in court documents that it was against making exceptions to roster limits. The plaintiff attorneys haven’t made a strong public statement either way—attorney Jeff Kessler previously told Front Office Sports that the settlement doesn’t require roster limits, it only allows them. Then, on Wednesday,Plaintiff attorney Steve Berman released a statement implying the holdup was with the NCAA alone: “We will work hard to convince the NCAA and the conferences to address the court’s concerns.”

But the attorneys for the NCAA, conference, and players now aren’t the only ones involved. Wilken has “requested” that lawyers representing objectors—Steve Molo, Laura Reathaford, and the Buchalter firm—be consulted on potential solutions. ““We are very happy with today’s order from Judge Wilken regarding the phasing-in of roster limits,” Reathaford said in a statement to FOS. “The judge followed the law. We look forward to working with the parties on an amicable resolution to this problem.”

There’s still a chance the settlement could be approved within the next month, if the parties submit a new draft on time. After all, Wilken confirmed that none of the other objections— about gender equity, antitrust issues with the salary cap and NIL clearinghouse, and the rights of future athletes—would move her to reject the settlement. Wilken said if the settlement agreement “does not adversely affect class members,” she wouldn’t require another monthslong round of class member notices. If the parties can’t fix the roster limits problem, however, the case could go to trial. 

In a statement Wednesday, the NCAA and power conferences said they were reviewing the order, and reiterated that their goal was still to ultimately get the settlement approved—implying they would consider a way to address the roster situation. Berman, similarly, said the plaintiffs were ready to fix the problem. 

But he added: “If we are unable to do so, then we are off to trial and we will return to fighting the NCAA in court with next steps.”

Meanwhile, college sports in general faces changes no matter what. If the settlement is ultimately approved with new changes, teams may have to reinstate roster spots for athletes they’ve already cut or whose incoming spots they’ve revoked. 

If it isn’t approved, the NCAA could still authorize revenue-sharing—and though it’s unlikely they’d want to do this without a settlement agreement, they might have to. Certain states have already passed laws requiring the NCAA to allow for revenue-sharing. NIL collectives nationwide have begun issuing NIL contracts based on the settlement terms; and athletic departments have begun hiring employees and fundraising for the revenue-sharing era, sources have confirmed to FOS. The fate of these resources and contracts without a settlement is unclear.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Coco Gauff at New York Liberty

How the New York Liberty Became the Hottest Ticket in Town

Once banished to the burbs, the Libs are now Brooklyn’s marquee attraction.
Leo Messi
exclusive

MLS Commissioner Don Garber Defends Messi Suspension

Messi was punished for skipping the MLS All-Star Game.

Commanders Seal Stadium Deal As D.C. Approves $1.1B in Funding

The NFL team’s return to its prior home receives key political support.
Feb 20, 2011; Calgary, AB, Canada; Canadian hockey fans wave a flag and display a banner before the Heritage Classic between the Montreal Canadiens and the Calgary Flames at McMahon Stadium. The Flames beat the Canadiens 4-0

Where Does Hockey Go After the Hockey Canada Verdict?

After the sexual assault trial, hockey is split over the path forward.

Featured Today

Las Vegas sign

College Sports Embracing Vegas After Years of Cold Shoulder

The Big Ten became the latest newcomer to Sin City.
2000, Jupiter, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Montreal Expos pitcher Hideki Irabu in action on the mound against the New York Mets at Roger Dean Stadium during Spring Training
July 28, 2025

Dead Sports Franchises Are Alive and Well on Twitter

The Expos, Sonics, and Whalers have active social media accounts.
Limited Hype
July 27, 2025

Sneaker Reselling Was Once Easy Money. Success Is Now Complicated

Vendors need to evolve what they’re selling and how they do it.
HAPPY GILMORE 2. BTS - (L to R) Adam Sandler as Happy Gilmore and Rory McIlroy as himself on the set of Happy Gilmore2.
July 26, 2025

‘Cool As Hell’: How ‘Happy Gilmore 2’ Hooked Golf’s Top Stars

The process was “cool as hell,” Adam Sandler tells FOS.
Stanford

John Donahoe Taking Over Stanford Sports After Rocky Nike Tenure

John Donahoe will be Stanford’s AD after a four-year stint running Nike.
Rutgers
July 28, 2025

Rutgers Finds New Athletic Director After Almost a Year

Rutgers’s previous athletic director, Pat Hobbs, resigned in August 2024.
NCAA Track
July 31, 2025

NIL Collectives Can Still Pay College Athletes, With Some Restrictions

NIL collectives will still play a pivotal role in recruiting.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
Jan 20, 2025; Atlanta, GA, USA; Notre Dame Fighting Irish tight end Mitchell Evans (88) runs the ball against the Ohio State Buckeyes in the second half in the CFP National Championship college football game at Mercedes-Benz Stadium.
July 25, 2025

‘More Bark Than Bite’: What Trump’s Executive Order Means for College Sports

“This all comes down to Congress and the courts.”
July 24, 2025

UNC’s Bill Belichick Brings His NFL Swagger to ACC Media Days

UNC is becoming one of the most interesting stories in college football.
President Donald Trump speaks during the American 250 kickoff event on July 3, 2025, at the Iowa State Fairgrouds.
July 24, 2025

Trump Signs Executive Order on College Sports Pay

The order marks Trump’s first foray into legislating college sports compensation.
July 24, 2025

ACC’s Phillips on FSU, Clemson: ‘It Can Never Be About a School..

The commissioner isn’t worried about more conference realignment.