• Loading stock data...
Tuesday, July 8, 2025

Amended House v. NCAA Settlement Proposal Does Not Adjust Roster Limits

After a final approval hearing, lawyers made some changes the judge requested. But they didn’t adjust a stipulation allowing the NCAA to impose roster limits.

Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

Attorneys for both plaintiffs and defendants in the House v. NCAA case filed yet another version of their settlement proposal on Monday—this time for final approval. They made minor adjustments to rights afforded to players who would be inducted into the settlement over the next 10 years. But they didn’t make any changes to a new rule allowing the NCAA to impose roster limits.

The filing comes after a seven-hourlong approval hearing last week, during which 10 parties raised objections to the settlement. Northern District of California Judge Claudia Wilken asked attorneys to make several changes or provide explanations to officially approve the settlement. 

The parties are eager to approve the settlement, which would allow for a system of revenue-sharing between schools and players that would begin in just a few months (in addition to offering $2.8 billion in damages to players who couldn’t profit off NIL before 2021—a much lower number than if they lost at trial). The settlement would also allow for a “clearinghouse,” run through software developed by Deloitte, with the ability to block any NIL deals from boosters or collectives that appear to be “pay-for-play.” 

Wilken’s main concern, it appeared, was with the potential legality of binding players to the settlement terms over the next 10 years. Wilken asked whether future college athletes, who at this point might just be eight or 10 years old playing recreational sports “on the blacktop,” could reasonably be expected to abide by the revenue-sharing cap and new NIL rules that extend for 10 years. To address this, the parties agreed to make a small change ensuring that future athletes could challenge the salary cap or other settlement terms if they decide to opt out of the settlement.

But both sides declined to make changes to satisfy Wilken’s other big hangup: roster limits. The settlement removes limits on scholarships for D-I teams, but imposes new roster limits. Dozens of athletes have submitted objections, saying that their roster spots have already been rescinded due to the settlement. Wilken suggested “grandfathering” in existing roster spots offered to players, with the limits going into effect for athletes who haven’t already been recruited. 

Lawyers for the defendants argued that it’s unreasonable to have sports programs operate without roster limits. “The Parties appreciate the perspective and heartfelt stories that the student-athletes who objected shared, including those shared at the hearing,” they wrote in a joint brief. “Defendants have evaluated—and discussed with numerous member institutions—the Court’s suggestion to “grandfather” in the roster limits. Defendants, however, have informed Class Counsel that those discussions revealed no practicable way to do so, because ‘grandfathering’ roster limits would cause significant disruption.”

It’s unclear if Wilken will ultimately approve the settlement, given that the lawyers didn’t make all the changes she asked for. However, she did say at the end of the hearing last week she thought the settlement was overall “good” overall. And though parties heed all her requests after the preliminary approval hearing, she still granted preliminary approval in October.

Wilken is expected to issue a final ruling within the next few weeks.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Louis, Missouri, UNITED STATES; Penn State Nittany Lions forward Nicholas DeGraves (17) celebrates with teammates after scoring a goal against the Boston University Terriers during the third period of the Frozen Four college ice hockey national semifinals at Enterprise Center

Gavin McKenna’s Penn State Commitment Cements College Hockey Supremacy

Gavin McKenna’s Penn State decision signals hockey’s rising stars now prefer NCAA.
A helmt is seen during the Texas Tech football team's spring game, Saturday, April 19, 2025, at Jones AT&T Stadium.

CFB’s Revenue-Sharing Era Muddles Future of NIL, Adds PE Questions

Athletic departments can pay college athletes a combined $20.5 million this year.
Jul 6, 2025; Houston, Texas, USA; Mexico forward Marcel Ruiz (14) heads the ball in front of United States midfielder Brenden Aaronson (11) in the second half during the 2025 Gold Cup Final at NRG Stadium.

USMNT Struggles Still Produce Big Gold Cup Ratings for Fox

The U.S. team’s recent issues culminated in a loss to Mexico.
Sports are shown on TVs behind a bar as guests enjoy the grand opening of DraftKings Sports & Social in Ohio.

California Has Declared Daily Fantasy Sports Are Illegal. Now What?

The opinion might spark a broader DFS conversation in the state.

Featured Today

American Celebs Want to Be Sports Owners. Soccer Is Where They Start

As U.S. team prices climb, investors set their sights abroad.
July 5, 2025

Baseball’s Celebrity Row: Behind MLB’s First-Pitch Ritual

Often planned, sometimes spontaneous, the ritual throw is baseball’s celebrity row.
July 4, 2025

3,000 Hot Dogs, $20K in Prizes: Behind the Nathan’s Eating Contest

Nathan’s serves up thousands of hot dogs and $20,000 in prize money.
July 3, 2025

Geoffrey Esper Can’t Catch a Break at Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest

“Hot dogs is not one of my favorite competitions of the year.”
Nov 30, 2024; Lubbock, Texas, USA; Texas Tech Red Raiders running back Tahj Brooks (28) runs the ball against West Virginia Mountaineers defensive back Anthony Wilson Jr. (12) in the second half at Jones AT&T Stadium and Cody Campbell Field.

Felix Ojo’s Agent Says Texas Tech Offered $5.1M At Start of Rev-Share..

Texas Tech secured Ojo with a seven-figure NIL commitment.
July 3, 2025

Everything You Need to Know About EA’s Return to College Basketball Video..

There hasn’t been a college basketball game in more than 15 years.
July 6, 2025

Revenue-Sharing Chaos Begins as Texas Tech Secures Five-Star OT

The Red Raiders spent more than $10 million in the winter transfer portal.
Sponsored

Hottest Matchups Following NFL Schedule Release

The NFL released the 2025 regular-season schedule, and anticipation is already building in the ticket marketplace with four months to go.
Ohio State
July 1, 2025

Collectives Funnel $20 Million to College Athletes on Last Day Before Revenue..

Collectives frontloaded payments just before the revenue sharing era begins July 1.
July 1, 2025

Big Ten Commish Still Pushes for 4 Auto CFP Bids in 16-Team..

The conference wants four guaranteed spots in the Playoff.
June 30, 2025

College Sports Revenue-Sharing Underway As More Changes Loom

July 1 marks the first day schools can directly pay players.
June 30, 2025

Pac-12 Hits Football Membership Threshold With Texas State Entry

The school is paying $5 million to leave the Sun Belt Conference.