Wednesday, November 18, 2026

NCAA’s Recent Wins May Not Be Enough to Stop Flood of Eligibility Lawsuits

The fate of NCAA eligibility rules remains unclear just weeks before the 2025 college football season kicks off.

Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia (2) carries the ball during fall practice Wednesday, July 30, 2025, in Nashville, Tenn.
The Tennessean

Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?

Add Front Office Sports on Google

Since 2024, the NCAA has been hit with 33 lawsuits challenging various aspects of its eligibility rules—with the most recent filings coming just last week.

As a result, the fate of the NCAA’s eligibility rules remains unclear just weeks before college football season starts. Across the country, federal judges don’t appear to have found common ground on whether the NCAA can legally enforce rules about when players are eligible for NCAA sports. And even bigger splits may be on the horizon.

“I’m not even sure I’d say that [the lawsuits are] trending in the right direction for the NCAA,” Boise State law professor Sam Ehrlich, who has tracked the barrage of litigation through his own website, tells Front Office Sports. “They’ve won more than they’ve lost for sure, but given how inconsistent judges have been in these cases I have to imagine the NCAA is super frustrated about all of this.”

The NCAA did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

At the beginning of the 2024-25 season, the NCAA’s rules were as follows: Players got four years of eligibility, with some exceptions including the year they “redshirt” (sitting out a season of play in order to extend eligibility) or the year of the COVID pandemic. All four years must be completed within five calendar years. Playing full seasons at non-NCAA institutions, like at the junior college level, still counted toward NCAA eligibility.

In November 2024, Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia started the flood of litigation. In a lawsuit filed in Tennessee federal court, Pavia argued that the two years he played football at junior college shouldn’t count against the NCAA’s four-year rule. Pavia also argued that he would lose out on NIL earnings if he was barred from extending his NCAA career—constituting a violation of antitrust laws. 

Within a few weeks, a federal judge in Tennessee granted a preliminary injunction allowing Pavia to suit up this fall for the Commodores. It was an early loss for the NCAA, which then issued a waiver for players like Pavia for the 2025-26 season.

But it also spurred dozens of other athletes to file cases of their own. 

Some argued against the same NCAA restriction as Pavia: that their years at junior colleges, which are not NCAA institutions, should not count against their NCAA eligibility. Others, however, challenged other aspects of the rule: NCAA football player Jett Elad, for example, challenged the rule stating all four years of play must be completed within five calendar years. His request was granted in April.

But then the NCAA’s luck turned.

In March, two different federal judges denied preliminary injunctions sought by baseball players who didn’t want the NCAA to count their years playing at the JUCO level. Georgia outfielder Dylan Goldstein lost his appeal at the end of February. The judge in Goldstein’s case, Tripp Self, was accused of having a conflict of interest given that he had worked as an NCAA official, but the case was closed after Tennessee baseball transfer Alberto Osuna also lost his bid in early March.

The most consequential, perhaps, is the case of Tennessee basketball player Zakai Zeigler, who exhausted all four years of full eligibility at the NCAA Division I level over a span of five years, and is simply arguing he should be allowed to continue to play a fifth during a six-year span. Zeigler’s motion for a preliminary injunction to be allowed to play this season was denied in June. (Zeigler will continue to seek damages over lost NIL earnings despite losing his opportunity to continue playing, however.)

The NCAA’s wins aren’t absolute, however, according to Ehrlich. “The biggest differentiating factor is whether courts are finding the rules to be ‘commercial’ or not,” he says (meaning that eligibility rules have an impact on an athlete’s ability to earn money). “If they’re not commercial in nature, there’s no antitrust applicability, so that’s a big deal for the NCAA.” At this time, Ehrlich says that among the eligibility lawsuits brought so far, there’s a six-and-six split on whether eligibility rules are commercial. The judge in Zeigler’s case, for example, found that the four season rule was commercial—and therefore could be challenged on antitrust grounds. 

In mid-July, the NCAA was able to successfully reverse a preliminary injunction granted to Wisconsin football player Nyzier Fourqurean, though the case itself is still ongoing. Ehrlich notes that the reasoning issued by the seventh circuit, which heard the appeal, likely isn’t a major ideological win for the NCAA.

Meanwhile, the NCAA is also appealing three decisions they’ve lost: Pavia v. NCAA, Elad v. NCAA, and Braham v. NCAA—a case brought by football player Cortez Braham Jr. in May challenging the NCAA’s JUCO rule and its five-year completion rule. (The NCAA’s official appeal of Braham v. NCAA was issued last Friday.)

In order to avoid further confusion, the NCAA has to win all three of these appeals. If it doesn’t, it faces the potential for a “circuit split,” when two different appeals courts issue opposing decisions. Those splits are sometimes resolved at the Supreme Court level.
But while the NCAA battles each individual lawsuit in court, it’s also lobbying Congress for a law that would protect its ability to set and enforce eligibility rules without fear of any future litigation.

Download the FOS App

The business of sports, in your pocket.

QR code to download the app

Scan the QR code to get the app now.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Jon Rothstein CBS Sports

Jon Rothstein Doesn’t Blame NIL for College Basketball’s Empty Seats

The CBS Sports personality also discussed his $15K bar tab in Lincoln.
Oct 10, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Boston Celtics forward R.J. Luis Jr. (12) loses control of the ball against Toronto Raptors guard Chucky Hepburn (24) and forward Jonathan Mogbo (2) in the second half at Scotiabank Arena

LSU Rosters Ex-NBA Player After Protracted NCAA Eligibility Saga

RJ Luis Jr. could suit up for LSU as soon as Wednesday.
Grand Valley State hosts Ferris State in the Anchor-Bone Classic on Saturday, Oct. 17, at Lubbers Stadium in Allendale.
First at FOS

‘Big Noon Kickoff’ and ‘College GameDay’ Both Courted Ferris State

The D-II school is attracting major networks amid a record-breaking season.

ESPN Revenue Hits $4.6B As Disney Continues Cutting Jobs

The ESPN parent company is targeting $3 billion in annual savings.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

11/18/26 – Group of 6 CFP Panic, Ryan Clark Backs Romo, ‘Big Noon’ Goes D-II

0:00

Featured Today

Soccer Football - Premier League - Aston Villa v Brentford - Villa Park, Birmingham, Britain - October 10, 2026 Aston Villa's Boubacar Kamara applauds fans after the match

English Soccer Still Inundated by Gambling Ads Despite Jersey Ban

The ban on front-of-shirt gambling ads looks strict, but it’s largely cosmetic.
West Wind Mahjong
November 11, 2026

Mahjong Mania Has Come for College Sports

Bespoke retailers are cashing in with officially licensed mahjong sets.
November 6, 2026

Can MLS Capitalize on Son-Mania?

Korea and Tottenham fans alike have flocked to LAFC’s away matches.
Pickering High School North
November 4, 2026

High School Athletic Directors Say They’re Running ‘Mini Colleges’

ADs are managing a growing list of demands from athletes and parents.
October 30, 2026

How Injuries Hit Pro Marathoners in the Wallet

Staying healthy can get expensive—quickly.

Philip Rivers Will Be Among Lowest-Paid Coaches in Power 4

Rivers will earn $3.25 million in his first season.
November 16, 2026

MiLaysia Fulwiley Denies Striking Officer With Her Car After Arrest

Fulwiley is projected to be a lottery pick in the 2027 draft. 
Sep 5, 2026; Eugene, Oregon, USA; Boise State Broncos tight end Matt Wagner (88) leaps over Oregon Ducks defensive back Davon Benjamin (5) on a pass play during the second half at Autzen Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Troy Wayrynen-Imagn Images
November 16, 2026

Group of 6 Leaders Fear Scheduling Squeeze in 24-Team CFP Era

The G6 is guaranteed one spot each season in the 24-team field.
Sponsored

Tracy McGrady Is Building A Basketball Ecosystem

The NBA legend talks turning his playing career into a portfolio of sports investments.
November 15, 2026

LSU’s Playoff Hopes Gone in First Year of $91M Kiffin Era

Kiffin now has four losses in his first season.
November 14, 2026

Ole Miss–Oklahoma Moved to Sunday, Sooners AD Rips Decision

Ole Miss–Oklahoma has been rescheduled for Sunday at 1 p.m. ET.
November 13, 2026

College Football Teams Caught Up in Nationwide Flight Stoppage

Three Big Ten teams are still trying to travel to game sites.
Purdue University Northwest women's flag football
November 13, 2026

How Much Women’s College Flag Football Coaches Make

Flag coaching pay varies by more than $100,000 across NCAA divisions.