Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?
One of the attributes that makes Jim Nantz one of the best to ever do it is his ability to get the most out of his analyst partners over the years. Just ask J.J. Watt.
With just 10 regular-season games under their belt, CBS Sports’s No. 1 NFL broadcast team of Nantz, Watt, and sideline reporter Tracy Wolfson has already become one of the best watches on NFL TV. The chemistry in the booth between Nantz, five-time national sportscaster of the year, and Watt, the three-time AP Defensive Player of the Year, keeps improving.
Witness the “Peanut Punch” incident where Nantz nearly broke his wrist trying to knock a football out of Watt’s iron grip (Nantz told Pat McAfee that a former U.S. president and Bills QB Josh Allen texted to see if he was OK).
CBS only named the 37-year-old Watt as Tony Romo’s interim replacement on July 31. But obviously CBS Sports president David Berson likes what he sees from the 2017 Walton Payton Man of the Year. On Oct. 22, Berson handed Watt a multiyear contract extension, promoting the former Texans superstar to the network’s lead NFL team on a full-time basis.
When I chatted with Watt at CBS’s NFL media day in August, he was effusive about getting to work with sports TV veterans Nantz and Wolfson. The charismatic young TV star knows he’s in good hands.
The 67-year-old Nantz has served as CBS Sports’s No. 1 NFL announcer since 2004, calling seven Super Bowls along the way. He’s hosted CBS’s Masters coverage since 1989. Lest we forget, Nantz served as the network’s lead NCAA tournament announcer from 1991 to 2023 before stepping down to spend more time with his young family. The youngest person ever honored by both the Pro Football and Naismith Memorial Basketball Halls of Fame, Nantz has also won four Emmy Awards since joining CBS in 1985.
The play-by-play announcer is famous for on-air calls, such as “The Bear has come out of hibernation” during Jack Nicklaus’s Masters charge in 1986 and his “Hello, friends” on-air greeting. But Nantz doesn’t get enough credit, in my book, for making so many of his broadcast partners better on the air.
Over his career, Nantz estimates he’s worked with a Who’s Who of 50-plus analysts, ranging from Watt, Romo, and Phil Simms on football to Trevor Immelman, Nick Faldo, and the late Ken Venturi on golf, and Bill Raftery and the late Billy Packer on March Madness. But the last few months have been an emotional roller coaster for Nantz. With CBS in crisis, he had to bond with Watt on the fly while still trying to support Romo, who unceremoniously parted ways with the network following an OWI arrest this summer.
In conversation, Nantz is a master raconteur, spinning stories about his later experiences with the great Jim McKay of ABC Sports (whom he calls the “Pavarotti” of sportscasting) and his beloved father’s battle with Alzheimer’s, which he chronicled in the New York Times best-selling memoir, “Always by My Side.”
During our one-on-one interview, Nantz went deep on the future with Watt, what he thinks happens with Romo, and how he accidentally broke the news of Dan Hicks’s sudden death to Jack Nicklaus. Nantz, however, is not commenting on the Troy Aikman–Joe Buck soap opera, citing his friendship with both of ESPN’s Monday Night Football announcers.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Front Office Sports: I’m impressed by the early chemistry between you and J.J., especially since you only had a month to prepare. Talk about what you’re seeing from your new broadcast partner.
Jim Nantz: It is growing. I think it’s been very good from the very beginning. I’m so excited about it. I’ve been extremely impressed by the way J.J. conducts himself. When we talk about how we get ready for games, we hit people over the head about all the preparation that goes into it. I’m not sure that’s relatable to people who aren’t inside the business. I just can tell you briefly, from being on the inside, that he’s taken it to a level I’ve truly never seen before. It matches up, though, with who he is. He’s ready for anything. He’s not going to let anything surprise him. He fully has dissected every scenario and possibility in his head. He’s been a joy. There’s a lot of joyfulness, let’s just put it that way, in that booth right now.
It’s two people who are playing off of one another and watching a game together. Again, I’ve been doing this for 41 years. So comparisons are never a good thing. So I don’t want anyone to ever think I’m making a comment that someone else didn’t do. Are you saying that Tony Romo wasn’t this way? Are you saying Billy Packer wasn’t this way? I mean they all had their own way of approaching and getting ready for a broadcast. I have had wonderful friendships and relationships with all the people I’ve ever worked with. But getting to know J.J. has been such a joy.
FOS: Speaking of joy, you had a funny moment with the “Peanut Punch.” How’s the wrist, Jim?
JN: It’s fine. That was a dumb thing for me to do. But I’m glad people liked it. I am getting asked about that to this day—and it’s been a month. The truth is: I’m probably too old to be trying to knock a ball out of J.J. Watt’s grasp. I mean, no one was going to knock that ball out, I don’t care who it was. But he told me just to give a good go and he had that thing suction-cupped against his enormous biceps. You saw it, I gave it everything I had. All of a sudden I felt the shooting pain go right from my wrist to my elbow and then into my shoulder. I thought, “Man my whole right side, it’s just kind of gone limp.” I made the remark on the air, “I think I just broke my wrist.” But it went away. It faded as the game went on.
I still thought I’m probably going to wake up with a big lump around my arm or elbow or something. But there were no signs, man. I showed some amazing powers of recovery and it didn’t stop me. I thought I wouldn’t be able to put my boards together by hand next week. But we’re all good. No issues. I said let’s just stay away from coming back to the booth and doing any more demonstrations that are that physical. I don’t need to have you demonstrate the horse collar tackle on me the next time we’re on camera.
FOS: But it was good TV, no?
JN: It was good TV. It was typical—we just let it flow. It happened. We laughed about it. And I’m glad we did it. I took one for the team.
FOS: After calling three straight Chiefs games, you have Giants-Jaguars this Sunday. Talk about your preparation process with J.J. and Tracy.
JN: It’s different for me. Take today. There’s already a text stream with several of us: Tracy, [lead game producer] Jim Rikhoff. Seven of us maybe. I mean that thing is active. Like all day. It’s alive—and a lot of it is coming from J.J. Content, big thoughts, things that don’t involve our game. The Cowboys turned over the play-calling duties [Wednesday] for their defense. Brought Mike Pettine, the former Cleveland head coach, to be the plat-caller for the defense over Christian Parker.
Anyway, we don’t have a Cowboys game. That’s nowhere on our schedule at the moment. There might be one in late December but it’s not an urgent thing for us to be delving into as we get set for Jacksonville and the Giants this weekend. But we’re in discussions about it. Our little core group. We’re texting about it. …It’s not a nuisance. It’s like football fans getting together and just having a chat. Spitballing about scenarios. It doesn’t sound like a whole lot but on a daily basis it adds up. Of course, eventually it pertains to our own game. We’re all sharing thoughts.
J.J. is very open about what he’s seeing and thinking and by the time we get to kickoff on Sunday, we in many ways have been in a discussion about football and the game broadcast is just a continuum. It’s different. It’s made football more fun. It’s just really been a joyful first half of the season… I think the chemistry is so good. I’m just feeling it with every segment. The games go fast. For some reason, they feel faster than ever before. I think that’s a testament to how much fun I’m having with it.
FOS: Let me ask you about Berson moving quickly to name J.J. as Romo’s permanent replacement. Did that sidestep the palace intrigue now engulfing ESPN, where Joe Buck got a new contract, but Troy Aikman’s a lame duck twisting in the wind?
JN: I’m happy that they made that call as a permanent call. I think the viewing audience sees J.J. as someone who has a lot of talent. And a lot of passion. Power and passion together is a pretty powerful punch—speaking of punches. Just a great team guy. So I’m thrilled that David put that to rest when he did. I mean why play this out? You’ve got a guy you know is exceptional at his craft. And is only going to get better. I don’t know how that can be. I think he’s absolutely at the top of it, already. But if there’s ever anyone who’s going to find one new wrinkle, one new way. He’s always asking, “What can I do to be better?” He’s not going to let his guard down.
FOS: J.J.’s only in his 30s. Yet he’s a No. 1 NFL color commentator in his second season calling games. And you, J.J., and Tracy are poised to call Super Bowl LXII in 2028. What do you think J.J.’s career upside is?
JN: He’s 37 years old. He wears well. It’s the one thing I think is a little underrated maybe when trying to determine who the common fan likes and doesn’t like. It’s highly underrated. Maybe they don’t even know how to express it. In other words, is this person likable? Do I enjoy sharing three hours with him? That’s important. It goes beyond the Xs and Os…
I’m not privy to Q ratings. But I would bet J.J.’s Q ratings are off the charts. That’s something that I’ve really strove for my whole career: Being able to have this likeability quotient with my partners. The people feel like it’s a shared experience with them at home. We may be calling it from afar in a booth, in some stadium on the other side of the country, but we feel like we’re in our living room. We like them being in our living room. People today get all caught up in calls and analysis. What did you call at the finish of a game? Like the three hours boiled down to “A trio in Rio” (Nantz’s call in Brazil this September when the Ravens booted a walk-off field goal to beat the Cowboys).
It’s so much more than that. It’s three hours of doing the dance with your teammates. The orchestration of 300 people being a part of this symphony and everybody having an important role and it all coming together in videos and graphics and support materials, and the audio being crisp and just right, and just the perfect mix on the ambient presentation. Is the crowd represented enough at a perfect level? All of these things go into it. But a lot of times people want to say, ’You know what about that seven-second call?’ It’s so dumbing it down. On the air, give me people I want to hang out with. Who do I like? Are they likable? I don’t know how you would quantify that other than maybe a Q rating.
FOS: What do you say to critics who don’t like your work so far with J.J.? Or your previous on-air partnership with Romo?
JN: I don’t say anything. I really don’t. I’m happy. I’m very happy. It’s a big world out there and there’s a lot of voices. I’m talking now about social media. There’s so many voices who can weigh in on what they like and what they don’t like. I think I answered your question about J.J. being taken off the board and being locked down.
FOS: You did. I agree it was a savvy move by Berson. Let the other NFL partners deal with the announcer musical chairs circus.
JN: It was a brilliant move. Smart move. He knew he was his guy and let’s not monkey around with it anymore. He’s our guy, period, and we’re fortunate to have him.
FOS: Romo recently appeared on Pat McAfee’s show. He looked happy, healthy. Will he be back?
JN: I have gone on the record on this saying I totally expect him to be back. I think you know that I can speak the way I’m speaking about J.J and mean it—and at the same time I can tell you how much I love Tony. You can have both things in my world. You understand that, right? I love Tony. The emotional rollercoaster of all of this. I think this was your original question, maybe even when we started getting into it. How did you adapt on such a short notice? It’s been an emotional time.
I had nine years with Tony and it was a partnership built on friendship, a real friendship, and I really care about him and, you know, it’s my job though to continue to do what CBS has contracted and asked me to do. And that is to try to put on the best game broadcast I can. I had to isolate my time rapidly, right on the eve of the season, to try to get to know a new partner. And to get comfortable and conversational, which we have achieved. We’ve achieved it, I think, rapidly, and I still feel like it’s getting better and better every week.
At the same time, there’s that side of you that’s feeling for your partner who is not returning to the booth. Until the middle of the summer, I never had any idea anything like that would happen. I thought Tony and I would be together for years. We did it for nine years. I’m not second-guessing any decision here. I’m just telling you, I stay in my lane. I was asked to go put on the best show possible, to bring our No. 1 broadcast team to a really good place as fast as I can, and to do everything I could to make J.J. enjoy the experience with new teammates, new team, higher profile games, more expectations. Make all of that work as seamlessly as quickly as possible.
FOS: I’ve always thought Romo brought star power.
JN: On the Tony front, you ask me if I think he’ll work again. I’ve said all along I truly believe Tony will work again. I don’t have any insight as to where that’s going to go. But he has talent. It’s undeniable.
No two people are really the same. You don’t want everybody to be the exact same. His style, his approach, is a reflection of his personality just as J.J.’s is. They’re not the same. People are different. Tony’s style of communicating and broadcasting it’s unique. He brings a huge star quotient to the booth. I’m not sure if he’ll be in the booth or the studio when his career resumes. I think he would be excellent in the studio as well. But he’s a young man. He’s still just 46. He loves being around the game. We all know that when a game gets going, and his excitability starts bubbling up and pouring through the broadcast, it’s amazing to watch and stand next to.
I look forward to seeing the next chapter of his career and I’ll be cheering for him. And he knows that. And we do stay in touch. More texting than we are calling. I think the last time I texted him I said there’s just so many places that I go that have memories of you. He knows. I wish him well. He’ll be back. But my attention, as it should be, is on J.J. I’m loving it. I’m absolutely loving it with J.J. I feel very fortunate to be by his side.
FOS: I want to ask you about the tragic passing of Dan Hicks. I felt like you and Dan were the voices of golf for 30 years. What were your memories of Dan?
JN: He was excellent at his job. And he was even better than that when he was off the air just living his life and cultivating a very strong friendship base with people who loved and cared for him. Everyone that knew Dan thought he was just a first-class guy. He was. I wish I could say my relationship with him was super-tight and close. But we were really working at opposite times. When golf wasn’t on CBS, we’d hand it off to NBC, Dan’s watch, and NBC’s watch.
He did it so well. We were both members at Winged Foot Golf Club in Mamaroneck, New York where his services ended yesterday with a reception. He joined there just about the time I was getting ready to move from the New York area to Pebble Beach, Calif. Had that crossed over a little bit more I really think we would have been playing a lot of golf together. That would have been a lot of fun.
FOS: Where were you when you heard about Dan?
JN: I was in South Florida when the news broke on Thursday morning. I was with Jack Nicklaus. We were shooting commercials for a couple of days when all of a sudden my phone, there were texts coming by the second. I was made aware of the terrible news. I went back into the main clubhouse at the Bear’s club. I figured that Jack might have heard. Scott Tolley, his manager, was with him. Scott’s very active on social media. I figured his phone must have been in high gear as well.
So I walked up and I gave Jack a big hug and I said I was just so devastated by the news. He said, ’By what?’ Then I realized he didn’t know. So of all things, for someone I know that Dan had to admire deeply, and someone who in turn admired Dan, someone who happens to be arguably the greatest player of all time, it was left to me to tell Jack that Dan Hicks passed away. That was not an easy thing to do. Here we are five days later, and I’m still coping with it. Still numb. Trying to process. The thought that a husband and a father, and a premier broadcaster who still had many years of great work to come, that he’s taken so suddenly. It’s just so sad.
FOS: I was at NBC’s 100th birthday party the other night. His colleagues told me off-the-air Dan was the life of the party—and a great impressionist.
JN: He had a great sense of humor. You just triggered a thought for me, but one of the first times I really met Dan in person, and I was talking to him, and I thought why is he sounding different than he does on television? The more he went on I realized he was sounding like me. I said, ‘Wait a minute, what’s going on here?’ I realized he was doing his impersonation of me—directly to me—without tipping his hand. Without telling me.
The NBC crew would tell you he was a great impersonator. So it was pretty darn funny that he begins a conversation and is talking to me—as me. I got it then. Of course, I knew from then on that Dan, behind-the-scenes, wasn’t just the buttoned-up stoic, anchorman. He was a stitch.
FOS: You famously avoid social media. Why?
JN: I don’t know if it’s right or wrong. I’ve never received a tweet. I’ve never sent a tweet. I don’t have Twitter. I know Al Michaels and I are two of the last holdouts. I’m not putting down anybody who relies on that for their [info] actually. I’m smart enough to know that news travels faster that way. But I feel like I manage my news intake, in terms of the NFL and sports-related [info].
I’ve got all kinds of mechanisms to make sure I’m made aware. A research team back in New York that beats all. The amount of content that’s coming to me in waves every day. Through an email. Sometimes through texts. It’s a lot. So I’ve just elected to stay on the sidelines. Maybe I’ll change one day. But right now I’m perfectly happy the way it flows for me.
FOS: Social media can be a funhouse mirror. You have to take all the negativity with a grain of salt.
JN: That’s it. If I want to go to the funhouse, I’ll go down to the Carnival when it comes to town.