Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?
NEW YORK — Gotham FC did its best to make the most of its relocated semifinal.
Unfortunately for the reigning NWSL champions, Kansas City stole the show.
On a chilly fall evening on Randall’s Island, the Kansas City Current defeated Gotham 2–1 with an 89th-minute game-winner to book a ticket to the NWSL title game in Washington.
The Current will face the hometown Washington Spirit, which beat the Utah Royals on Saturday.
Facing poor pitch conditions, Gotham ultimately decided to move the match from its usual home stadium in New Jersey to the 5,000-seat Icahn Stadium on New York City parkland in the East River.
Gotham is a tenant of MLS club New York Red Bulls at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, N.J., and a combination of rugby matches and soccer games tore up the pitch over the past few weeks. The NWSL had previously fined Gotham $10,000 for pitch conditions for the final game of the regular season, and players and coaches blasted playing conditions after the Nov. 8. quarterfinal.
With a Red Bulls friendly against Mexican side Club América scheduled for Saturday night—during which a fight broke out—Gotham decided to move to Icahn, which has a pitch donated by its future landlord, MLS’s New York City FC.
On Sunday, Gotham organized ferries, buses, and watch parties for the fans, chartering boats and covering bar tabs.
After the games, Gotham star Midge Purce said club owners have “done absolutely everything they could possibly do to make the best situation for us.”
Purce, who called the field at Sports Illustrated Stadium “inexcusable,” said the pitch at Icahn had “no effect on performance” on Sunday.
“I think it was the right decision to come here, I think the pitch in the other stadium was unfortunately unplayable,” Gotham coach Juan Carlos Amorós said Sunday evening. He said the quality of the playing surface at Icahn was “unbelievable.”
‘KC Baby!’
The Current came to New York for a semifinal defender Izzy Rodriguez called “personal” after being upset by Gotham in the quarterfinal last year. After the win, Current goalscorer Croix Bethune said the game was personal both “individually and as a unit.”
The team arrived a day later than intended. Originally scheduled to come in on Friday, the team didn’t make it until Saturday due to Friday’s nationwide flight grounding.
Fans faced a similar dilemma, with several choosing to drive the roughly 1,200 miles instead.
Current season ticket holder Maria Jimenez and her boyfriend told Front Office Sports they arrived at the airport Friday afternoon as flights were getting disrupted and decided to get on the road. Jimenez said they slept a few hours at a rest stop and arrived at their hotel in New Jersey around 9 p.m. on Saturday.
“A lot of coffee, a lot of Red Bulls,” Jimenez said.
To help fans get to Randall’s Island, Gotham chartered two ferries from Manhattan. Fans boarded the boats in midtown, filed into benches inside the cabin, and rode about 20 minutes up the east side of Manhattan.
Gotham season ticket holder Barb Chubb took the ferry with her husband after the pair was too late to catch one of Gotham’s chartered buses for fans from New Jersey.
“It’s just a beautiful afternoon, the sky blue, all the buildings that I’ve never seen from this angle,” Chubb told FOS. “It’s just amazing, and to think that Gotham did this for us, I’m so excited.”
While some enjoyed the small fan festival Gotham organized outside the stadium, most hopped in line; by the match’s 3:00 p.m. scheduled kickoff, many fans were still waiting.
The match started about 20 minutes late, though, as the South Carolina–USC women’s basketball game on ABC ran long. Fans were still trickling in as the match began, filling most of the grandstand.
The temperature was about 50 degrees around kickoff, and while the field was covered in sunlight—causing some visibility issues—most of the grandstand was shaded and cool.
The second half was colder after the sun went down. Gotham and its fans both found more life, and the home team got an equalizer with a Current own goal.
As the clock climbed toward the 90th minute, one Kansas City fan proclaimed that they couldn’t feel their toes. Moments later, Current forward Haley Hopkins delivered the game-winning goal in the 89th minute.
After the match, Current players celebrated with the contingent of teal in the stands, screaming, “KC baby!”

‘This league deserves better’
Gotham was not alone in its stadium scramble.
At the start of the playoffs, the top-three seeded NWSL teams—Gotham, the San Diego Wave, and the Washington Spirit—all had events scheduled at their home venues for Saturday.
After the Spirit won, they announced a double-header at Audi Field with the semifinal and a previously scheduled Division III college football game. The Spirit and Secretaries Cup were played with both soccer and football lines drawn on the field, with a roughly 90-minute turnaround between final whistle of the NWSL game and the opening of the gates for football.
Gotham coach Amorós said the college football lines for the Spirit’s game, coupled with Gotham not being able to play at Sports Illustrated—where it only lost once this season—made for “a sad weekend.”
“This league deserves better,” Amorós said. “The two arguably best teams, most consistent, having to deal with these situations.”
The NWSL’s stadium mess, coupled with similar issues during the WNBA Finals, have highlighted a broader problem in women’s sports for teams that are tenants at the home stadium of a men’s team.
It’s an issue that, ironically, Gotham’s opponent will never face.
The Current are the only NWSL team that currently owns its own stadium, which it opened in 2024. Denver and Boston are building their own venues scheduled to open in 2028.
Richard Harper—a Current fan known as the Teal Man for covering his face in teal paint and his beard in red glitter—told FOS he wants to see more teams get their own venues. “I feel like if I can have it, why not everybody else?” he said.
“It allows you to build your own culture instead of just trying to borrow somebody else’s place and fill it with your culture,” Harper told FOS. “Being able to build it from the ground up as it were is really what I think the NWSL needs now. We’ve got the viewership, we’ve got want, now we just need the stadiums.”
Download the FOS App
The business of sports, in your pocket.
Scan the QR code to get the app now.