• Loading stock data...
Friday, June 6, 2025

NIL Contract Buyouts Are More Common, but Can They Be Enforced?

In the pros, as well as with college coaches, buyouts are paid by the team or school the player transfers to. But in the NIL era, they work differently.

Dec 27, 2024; Memphis, TN, USA; Arkansas Razorbacks defensive back Miguel Mitchell (16) returns an interception during the forth quarter against the Texas Tech Red Raiders at Simmons Bank Liberty Stadium.
Petre Thomas-Imagn Images

On Tuesday, Arkansas quarterback Madden Iamaleava—the brother of new UCLA quarterback Nico Iamaleava—entered the transfer portal, presumably to join his brother in Westwood. 

Hours later, Arkansas athletic director Hunter Yuracheck released a statement expressing his “support” for NIL collective Arkansas Edge’s “pursuit to enforce their rights under any agreement violated by our student-athletes moving forward.” 

The statement was taken by many as a thinly veiled threat to Madden, who arrived in Fayetteville just a few months ago after decommitting from UCLA himself. He hadn’t played a down of regular-season football with Arkansas but had inked an NIL contract with Arkansas Edge.

In some ways, the speculation was correct: Madden is one of several athletes who have violated the terms of Arkansas Edge contracts by transferring before his contract was set to expire, prompting the collective to try to enforce a “buyout” clause, a source familiar with the situation tells Front Office Sports. The collective has since issued two demand letters to players to pay buyouts, the source said—though the source declined to confirm that Madden was one of them.

Arkansas isn’t the only collective seeking redress. Multiple sources told FOS that collectives are increasingly trying to recoup revenue from players who are utilizing new NCAA rules, which let athletes transfer as many times as they wish without penalty. “Buyouts are fairly common, especially with high-value athletes,” Russell White, president of The Collective Association, tells FOS. “They are now being included in more agreements.”

The key question is whether buyouts are  enforceable.

In the pros, as well as with college coaches, buyouts are paid by the team or school the player transfers to. But in the NIL era, they work differently. 

Usually, a collective will include a buyout clause requiring the player to either pay or return a certain amount of money to the collective if the player violates the terms of the agreement—usually if they leave schools before the lifetime of the contract ends, and therefore can’t complete all the requisite NIL activities. At Arkansas, for example, deals span one year, and buyouts require players to pay an amount equal to 50% of the remaining earnings through the lifetime of the contract, the source says. 

The enforceability of the contract, however, depends partially on the language of the deal, sports lawyers tell FOS. Attorney Darren Heitner, who represents dozens of college athletes, says that buyouts framed as “penalties” are often less enforceable legally than buyouts framed as “damages.”

“I’m not willing to generalize and state that all buyouts are unenforceable,” Heitner says. “However, on the rare occasion that there has been a claim for repayment for one of my clients, that has been my conclusion based on the language of the agreement at issue as well as the specific facts of the situation at hand.”

Attorney Mit Winter notes that the price of requested damages could matter, too. “The collective would need to be able to tell a court or an arbitrator that by no longer being able to use the athlete’s NIL rights, it will be damaged in some non-speculative amount. That could be hard for some collectives to do.”

Heitner says none of his clients have had to pay buyouts to date. Winter says that, to his knowledge, “not that many” collectives have been able to successfully collect buyouts. 

But success is in the eyes of the beholder. The source familiar with the Arkansas situation says collectives don’t always receive the full amount, but the buyout clause itself brings players and their representation to the table to negotiate some restitution. (While there have been disputes across the industry, White says, most have been resolved behind closed doors.) 

The next step for the industry: to see how a buyout clause fares in court. 

For now, one thing is clear: Collectives are no longer accepting being left high and dry in the era of unrestricted free agency.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

August 31, 2024; Columbus, Ohio, USA; The Goodyear blimp flies over Ohio Stadium during the first half of Saturday’s NCAA Division I football game between the Akron Zips and the Ohio State Buckeyes.

Why the Goodyear Blimp Is at Every Major Sports Event

The airship wasn’t built to cover sports. Now it’s a regular presence.
NiJaree Canady

Stacked Texas Tech NIL Roster Now a Win Away From Softball Title

The Red Raiders have a winning formula with NIL and recruiting.
ESPN has not let NBA Countdown “marinate” as talent changes too frequently, ex-host Michelle Beadle tells FOS.
breaking

SiriusXM Parts Ways With Michelle Beadle, Cody Decker

Beadle, Decker exit three months before Stephen A. Smith takes their slot.
Tony Clark

Everything You Need to Know About the MLBPA-OneTeam FBI Investigation

Money from lucrative group licensing deals is under federal scrutiny.

Featured Today

May 27, 2015; Paris, France; Mirjana Lucic-Baroni (CRO) knocks the clay off her shoe during her match against Simona Halep (ROU) on day four of the French Open at Roland Garros

Roland-Garros’s Iconic Red-Clay Surface Is a Precise Alchemy

The exact science behind maintaining the French Open’s red clay.
Alex Jensen introductory press conference on Monday, March 17, 2025.
June 3, 2025

Alex Jensen Started Utah Utes HC Job While Still Coaching the Mavs

How Jensen began building an NCAA program while patrolling the Dallas sideline.
May 31, 2025

PSG and the City of Paris Can Join European Soccer’s Elite

What a maiden Champions League title would mean for the French club.
May 30, 2025

How the Champions League Anthem Took on a Life of Its Own

The composer didn’t know he wrote a timeless hit three decades ago.

Ohio State’s Ryan Day Pushes for Big Ten Priority in CFP Format

Ohio State’s head coach wants the Big Ten to have four automatic bids.
Parker
June 4, 2025

Women’s College World Series Is Tight but Lucrative Earning Window for Softball..

Brands are navigating the brief but popular annual softball showcase.
Mar 30, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Tennessee Volunteers guard Zakai Zeigler (5) shoots the ball against the Houston Cougars in the first half during the Midwest Regional final of the 2025 NCAA tournament at Lucas Oil Stadium.
June 4, 2025

Trump’s DOJ Files Brief in Zeigler NCAA Eligibility Case

Zakai Zeigler is asking to play for Tennessee’s basketball team a fifth year.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

In Episode 7 of Portfolio Players, go inside the boardroom with Avenue Capital CEO and former Milwaukee Bucks co-owner Marc Lasry on Giannis’s future, women’s sports, and upstart leagues like TGL and Unrivaled. 
Jun 2, 2025; Oklahoma City, OK, USA; Texas Tech Red Raiders players celebrate after defeating the Oklahoma Sooners 3-2 and advance to the finals against Texas in the NCAA Softball Women's College World Series semifinal game at Devon Park.
June 4, 2025

How Texas Tech Put Together Its First-Ever Women’s College World Series Run

AD Kirby Hocutt speaks with FOS about the Red Raiders’ winning formula.
NCAA Hockey
June 4, 2025

Gavin McKenna’s College Decision Could Shake Up Hockey Forever

The balance of power could shift from Canada to U.S. colleges.
Jan 19, 2025; Atlanta, GA, USA; The College Football Playoff National Championship trophy at a press conference at The Westin Peachtree Plaza, Savannah Ballroom.
June 3, 2025

As 2025 CFB Season Nears, 2026 Playoff Format Still a Mystery

College Football Playoff leaders are divided on its future.
Mar 22, 2025; Birmingham AL, USA; LSU gymnast Livvy Dunne stretches with teammates before Session 2 of the SEC Gymnastics Tournament at Legacy Arena in Birmingham, Alabama.
June 2, 2025

House Settlement Is Supposed to Take Effect in July. It’s Still Not..

College sports awaits which athlete compensation rules will govern the 2025 season.