• Loading stock data...
Wednesday, September 17, 2025

Perfect Storm: St. John’s Biggest Fans Can’t Bet on the School

St. John’s is one of the major storylines of the NCAA men’s basketball tournament, but in the No. 1 sports betting market, the Red Storm are strictly off-limits. The reason dates back years.

Mar 15, 2025; New York, NY, USA; St. John's Red Storm guard RJ Luis Jr. (12) after hitting a three-point basket against the Creighton Bluejays in the second half at Madison Square Garden.
Robert Deutsch-/Imagn Images
Exclusive

The Eagles Play Christmas Day for NFL on Netflix

The father-son duo will call the Christmas Day doubleheader again.
Read Now
September 16, 2025 |

This year’s men’s March Madness is dominated in historic fashion by the SEC, but the story of the tournament in many ways is the resurgence of St. John’s, a long-downtrodden program that has dramatically returned to national prominence under coach Rick Pitino and billionaire booster Mike Repole.

Red Storm fans and backers in the school’s home state of New York, however, cannot bet on (or against) St. John’s in the tournament—a situation stemming from an existing prohibition on any sports betting on in-state colleges.

Sports betting across much of the U.S. continues to surge, and March Madness wagering this year is expected to reach $3.2 billion—a level more than double the $1.39 billion in activity surrounding last month’s Super Bowl LIX, a one-day event compared to the tournament’s nearly three-week run. The March Madness betting activity, however, will need to coexist with rules in 15 states that prohibit, at least to some agree, wagers on in-state colleges. 

A similar situation emerged three years ago, when New Jersey–based Saint Peter’s unexpectedly advanced to the Elite Eight as a No. 15 seed. The in-state prohibitions, however, are now reaching arguably their most dramatic collision with St. John’s beginning March Madness as the No. 2 seed in the West region, the No. 7 favorite to win the national championship, and one of the top candidates to disrupt the SEC dominance. 

The bans are also particularly salient given New York is the No. 1 state in the country for sports betting, while Illinois (No. 2) sent two schools to the tournament, and the fast-rising Virginia market sent three. 

Mar 15, 2025; New York, NY, USA; St. John's Red Storm forward Zuby Ejiofor (24) hoists the championship trophy after defeating the Creighton Bluejays to win the Big East Tournament at Madison Square Garden
Brad Penner/Imagn Images

“We now have something of a patchwork landscape that’s evolved around the country,” James Kilsby, an analyst for Vixio, a betting regulatory provider, tells Front Office Sports. “While the matter is quite settled in some states, we’ve seen changes in some other areas, and some states are now finding greater nuance.”


The roots of the current situation, in many ways, lie in New Jersey and predate the landmark 2018 U.S. Supreme Court decision allowing individual states to set their own rules. 

In 2011—years before the advent of NIL (name, image, and likeness) rights in college sports—New Jersey approved a nonbinding constitutional amendment that would permit sports gambling but prohibit wagers on in-state college sports. The state legislature then codified that into law the following year. Several sports leagues then sued to enjoin the New Jersey law, crucially helping set the stage for the U.S. Supreme Court ruling six years later. 

The New Jersey move had two primary aims: to help create an initial legal framework for sports betting, and also to protect college athletes who state leaders saw as particularly vulnerable to the downsides of the industry and temptations from bad actors. 

There’s plenty of local history on that latter point, as back in 1951, a massive point-shaving scandal involved CCNY and several other area schools. The widespread fallout included numerous arrests and bans from professional play, coach firings, suspensions, or downgrades of athletic programs, and it ultimately threatened the very existence of college basketball. 

Within that protective mindset, though, New Jersey remained keenly interested in legal sports betting, and after the Supreme Court ruling, became a key early state to approve mobile sports betting.

Saint Peter's KC Ndefo (left) and Jaylen Murray leave the court after the Peacocks' 67-64 win against Purdue to advance to the Elite Eight in the NCAA tournament at the Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia, March 25, 2022.

Ncaa Basketball Ncaa Tournament Saint Peter S Vs Purdue In Sweet 16 Saint Peter S At Purdue
William Bretzger/Imagn Images

As 38 states and the District of Columbia now have legal sports betting, many of them used New Jersey’s laws as a template to create their own—particularly in New York, which began mobile sports betting in 2022 after seeing its immediate neighbor initially claim national industry supremacy. 

“New Jersey has definitely been the most influential when it comes to setting the table for regulations in this area,” Kilsby says. “And we’ve seen this strategy around in-state colleges adopted elsewhere where it’s helped ensure a smooth passage of the broader sports betting legislation.”

Major sportsbooks such as FanDuel and DraftKings, for their part, have called betting bans on in-state colleges “artificial barriers,” but generally have not lobbied heavily in this area. Instead, the operators have often preferred to focus their political energies on bigger-picture issues such as opening up entire new states.

There are some notable carveouts now, though, including in Connecticut and Massachusetts, which have similar bans on in-state colleges that are suspended for tournaments such as March Madness.


Several states have since had opportunities to revisit their bans on betting on in-state colleges, and have declined to change their rules. Most notably, voters in New Jersey soundly defeated in 2021 a proposed amendment to the state constitution to allow betting on in-state schools. The measure would have opened up bets for residents on schools such as Rutgers and Seton Hall—and notably would have allowed activity around Saint Peter’s subsequent Cinderella run—but voters rejected the proposal by 14 points.

Meanwhile, state officials and the NCAA are even more wary about the rise of prop bets. These wagers have quickly become a critical part of the overall sports betting market. Even in states where betting on in-state college sports is allowed, though, prop bets are frequently prohibited on in-stage colleges. 

The NCAA, for its part, has been seeking a national-level ban on prop bets for college sports, beginning a full-scale lobbying effort last year to create a unified framework. There is a fair amount of agreement on the issue among state-level regulators, but the issue has not yet received a significant amount of attention at the federal level. Several major states, most notably New York, continue to offer their support in this area. 

“As regulators of the largest sports-betting market in the United States,” wrote New York State Gaming Commission chair Brian O’Dwyer last year in a letter to NCAA president Charlie Baker,

“we continue to believe that the prohibition of college proposition betting on student-athletes is appropriate.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Feb 17, 2024; Indianapolis, IN, USA; NBA Commissioner Adam Silver talks to media during a press conference before NBA All Star Saturday Night at Lucas Oil Stadium.

Adam Silver Doesn’t Want NBA Europe to Be a ‘Top-Heavy League’ 

Silver said he doesn’t want the prospective league to be like European soccer.

Adam Silver Walks Back Claim He’d Never Heard of Aspiration

Adam Silver spoke at the Front Office Sports Tuned In summit.

Amazon Sports Chief Says NBA, WNBA Coverage Should Be Celebratory

“There’s too much weird negativity out there,” Jay Marine told FOS.
Charles Barkley

TNT Sports CEO Responds to Charles Barkley Saying Company ‘Just Sucks’

Barkley recently criticized TNT’s handling of “Inside the NBA.”

Featured Today

Premier Lacrosse League

‘The Circus Is Coming to Town’: Why Upstart Leagues Start on Tour

In their ambitious plans, a traveling schedule is only temporary.
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA - APRIL 19: A detailed view of the MLB Debut patch on the jersey of Patrick Monteverde #44 of the Miami Marlins prior to game against the Philadelphia Phillies at Citizens Bank Park on April 19, 2025 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
September 13, 2025

The Tiny Jersey Patch at the Center of the MLB Rookie Card..

Autographed cards containing a piece of baseball history have upended the market.
September 11, 2025

Eagles-Chiefs Super Bowl Rematch Could Set More NFL Ratings Records

Fox will nationally televise Sunday afternoon’s matchup.
September 10, 2025

ESPN’s ‘MNF’ Ratings Up 8% As NFL Surges to Strong Start

ESPN posts its second-best Week 1 “Monday Night Football” audience.

FanDuel, Jaguars Reach $5M Deal Over Employee Theft

A Jaguars employee stole $20 million and gambled much of it with FanDuel.
Sep 4, 2025; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Eagles cornerback Adoree' Jackson (8) tackles Dallas Cowboys wide receiver CeeDee Lamb (88) during the third quarter of the game at Lincoln Financial Field.
September 5, 2025

Kalshi’s $27M NFL Opener Runs Into Tribal Challenge

California Tribes want Kalshi forced to implement geofencing.
Sep 8, 2025; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) rushes the ball past Minnesota Vikings safety Theo Jackson (26) during the second half at Soldier Field.
exclusive
September 10, 2025

Americans See Little Difference Between Prediction Markets and Betting

A survey found 85% of respondents believe sports event contracts are gambling.
Sponsored

How World Series Champ Dexter Fowler Became a Premier League Team Owner

Dexter Fowler discusses navigating retirement and embracing new roles as an owner & investor.
Eagles
September 4, 2025

FanDuel Paying $80K for Eagles Trains Amid Transit Funding Fight

The gambling company is giving stopgap transit funding in Philadelphia.
Sep 1, 2025; Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA; TCU Horned Frogs tight end DJ Rogers (0) catches a touchdown pass as North Carolina Tar Heels defensive back Kaleb Cost (21) defends in the fourth quarter at Kenan Stadium.
September 3, 2025

Polymarket Moves Closer to Reentering the U.S.

There’s yet more prediction markets momentum as the NFL season kicks off.
during the fourth quarter at Memorial Stadium in Clemson, S.C. Saturday, August 31, 2025.
September 2, 2025

Underdog Bets on Prediction Markets With Crypto.com Deal

Sports event contracts will be offered in 16 states.
Rob Bonta
August 29, 2025

Users Sue Daily Fantasy Companies After California Calls Them Illegal

Underdog Sports and Boom Fantasy were separately sued.