• Loading stock data...
Tuesday, July 1, 2025

Pivotal Moment for Three Cases Over NCAA Athlete Compensation

  • The NCAA is fighting to preserve amateurism in multiple arenas, from the courts to Congress.
  • It is in the midst of a pivotal two-week stretch for at least three major cases over athlete compensation and employment status.
The NCAA is facing a pivotal moment in three court cases over amateurism.
Charlie Nye/Indianapolis Star

College basketball season tipped off on Monday, with teams across the country going head to head. 

But the NCAA is facing several, much bigger battles off the hardwood: court cases over athlete employment status and compensation rules. 

The NCAA is fighting to preserve amateurism in multiple arenas, from the courts to Congress — where it is trying to get a law passed to stop these cases. But so far, it’s been unsuccessful.

As a result, it is in the midst of a pivotal stretch for at least three major cases over athlete compensation and employment status.

House v. NCAA

On Nov. 3, Judge Claudia Wilken issued a much-anticipated ruling in the federal antitrust case House v. NCAA, granting three proposed classes.

The decision puts the NCAA on the hook for more than $4 billion in combined damages for the proposed classes, according to previous court documents. 

The federal antitrust lawsuit, filed in 2020 in California, is seeking damages for athletes who didn’t benefit from NIL rules because they played before the NCAA enacted them. 

It’s also arguing that the definition of NIL should be much more broad: Broadcast deals, game promotions, and school apparel contracts would be considered part of NIL because athletes are featured in them. 

The classes include:

  • Any Division I athlete who has currently benefited from NIL deals, but who also played before rules were changed on July 1, 2021 and therefore lost out on potential NIL revenue.
  • Any Power 5 scholarship men’s basketball or football player that played after June 15, 2016 who could have made money from broadcast contracts or video games portraying their likenesses.
  • Any Power 5 scholarship women’s basketball player who played after June 15, 2016 who could have made money from broadcast contracts portraying their likenesses.

The case isn’t set to go to trial until 2025. The ultimate ruling could force the NCAA to change its compensation rules to allow for revenue sharing between athletes and athletic departments — and even go bankrupt.

NLRB Case Against USC, Pac-12, and NCAA

On Tuesday, the Los Angeles region of the NLRB will begin virtual pre-trial hearings for a case first filed in 2022 by an athlete advocacy group called the National College Players Association against USC, the Pac-12, and NCAA. The case is an “unfair labor charge” over the misclassification of athletes.”

While official in-person hearings won’t begin until December, USC’s lawyers have said in court documents that they intend to get the case dismissed during pre-trial hearings. (USC filed a formal motion to dismiss, but the NLRB responded saying it would ignore the motion because it was filed after the requisite deadline.)

If the NCPA wins, all Division I basketball and FBS football players would have to be reclassified as employees. 

It’s unclear how long the case would take to be settled, given that either side would likely appeal after the trial ends in February. But NLRB general counsel Jennifer Abruzzo signaled her support for athletes’ side in a 2021 memo.

The NLRB could even claim public school athletes are subject to its ruling even though it only has jurisdiction over the private sector. That’s because of the “joint-employer doctrine,” which suggests that multiple organizations can be employers of the same group of people at the same time. 

If all conferences and the NCAA have similar relationships to their football and basketball players, the rule could apply. The NLRB recently issued a new definition for its joint-employer doctrine, which could bode well for athletes in this case. 

Matt Bewley et al v. NCAA

On Nov. 1, twin recruits of the Chicago State men’s basketball team, Matt and Ryan Bewley, filed a lawsuit in Illinois federal court last week against the NCAA over their denied eligibility after having played for Overtime Elite.

A hearing is set for Nov. 14 to get a temporary restraining order prohibiting the NCAA from keeping them on the bench. 

In 2020, the sports media company Overtime established a men’s high school professional basketball team called Overtime Elite, which allowed players aged 16-18 to play as well as receive schooling, the ability to profit off NIL deals, and a salary. It also offered players who wanted to play NCAA basketball the option to receive scholarships, rather than salaries. 

The NCAA, however, denied their eligibility despite Overtime’s careful attempt at keeping them within NCAA amateurism rules. 

The NCAA’s decision was based on three factors, according to court documents: Players received compensation that “exceeded actual and necessary expenses,” they played on a team that was considered professional, and they played against athletes who considered them professionals. (Court documents noted that other athletes who had played on Overtime Elite have been granted eligibility to play NCAA basketball.)

The case suggests that even if athletes did somehow accidentally violate NCAA eligibility rules, those rules themselves violate antitrust law. Illinois state senator Kam Buckner put out a statement on Monday suggesting the NCAA’s treatment of the Bewley brothers is also in conflict with Illinois’ state NIL law.

The case could ultimately force the NCAA to change those rules altogether, in addition to granting the twins eligibility.

Other Cases Moving Slowly

Two other cases could also force the NCAA to recognize athletes as employees. 

A case in Pennsylvania federal court, Johnson v. NCAA, is awaiting an interim ruling. A unionization petition filed by Dartmouth men’s basketball players with the local NLRB is also awaiting a ruling after a hearing last month.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Ohio State

Collectives Funnel $20 Million to College Athletes on Last Day Before Revenue..

Collectives frontloaded payments just before the revenue sharing era begins July 1.

College Sports Revenue-Sharing Underway As More Changes Loom

July 1 marks the first day schools can directly pay players.
Nov 23, 2024; Tempe, Arizona, USA; Brigham Young Cougars quarterback Jake Retzlaff (12) against the Arizona State Sun Devils at Mountain America Stadium.

Rape Suit Against QB Retzlaff Dismissed, but He’s Still Leaving BYU

Retzlaff admitted to “consensual” sex, violating BYU’s strict honor code.

Pac-12 Hits Football Membership Threshold With Texas State Entry

The school is paying $5 million to leave the Sun Belt Conference.

Featured Today

The Battle Over Wimbledon’s Ambitious Expansion Plan

A classic NIMBY standoff on one of the most hallowed grounds in sports.
Seattle Rough & Tumble
June 28, 2025

Women’s Sports Bars Are on the Rise. Survival Isn’t Guaranteed

Some women’s sports bars are cashing in. Others are clawing for funding.
June 27, 2025

Shitposters Have Taken the Reins of Pro Sports’ Official Voices

Meet the social media pros turning sports teams into internet trolls.
Jun 17, 2025; Sunrise, Florida, USA; Florida Panthers center Sam Reinhart (13) hoists the Stanley Cup after winning game six of the 2025 Stanley Cup Final against the Edmonton Oilers at Amerant Bank Arena
June 26, 2025

Stanley Cup’s International Summer Tour: Rules, Repairs, and Raucousness

No pro trophy tour compares to the NHL’s three-month global victory lap.

Big Ten Commish Still Pushes for 4 Auto CFP Bids in 16-Team..

The conference wants four guaranteed spots in the Playoff.
June 26, 2025

Pac-12 Rebuild Nears Completion With 2026 Texas State Addition

The Sun Belt school is likely joining the Pac-12 in 2026.
Mar 23, 2025; Raleigh, NC, USA; Baylor Bears guard Jeremy Roach (3) reacts after a play during the first half against the Duke Blue Devils in the second round of the NCAA Tournament at Lenovo Center.
June 26, 2025

Power Four Put Finishing Touches on How Revenue Sharing Era Will Work

The agreement stipulates that schools can’t sue to challenge any terms of the settlement.
Sponsored

Hottest Matchups Following NFL Schedule Release

The NFL released the 2025 regular-season schedule, and anticipation is already building in the ticket marketplace with four months to go.
Sep 16, 2023; Stanford, California, USA; Sacramento State Hornets running back Elijah Tau-Tolliver (25) celebrates after a touchdown during the fourth quarter against the Stanford Cardinal at Stanford Stadium.
June 25, 2025

Sacramento State ‘Full Steam Ahead’ for FBS Despite Not Receiving NCAA Waiver

The Hornets launched a public campaign to join the FBS last fall.
Jun 7, 2025; Chapel Hill, NC, USA; North Carolina infielder Jackson Van De Brake (6) and outfielder Carter French (18) celebrate an out during the first inning of the Super Regionals game against Arizona in Chapel Hill, North Carolina.
June 25, 2025

Most Power Conference Sports Won’t See Revenue-Sharing Dollars

But there is a silver lining for Olympic sports: more scholarships.
June 23, 2025

Colleges Are Raising Student Fees to Pay for Athlete Revenue-Sharing

Schools are preparing to pay student athletes up to $20.5 million annually.
Dec 27, 2024; San Diego, CA, USA; The Washington State Cougars ban perform during the second half at the Holiday Bowl at Snapdragon Stadium. Mandatory Credit:
June 23, 2025

Pac-12 Announces CBS As ‘Anchor’ in New Media-Rights Deal

The league may announce expansion before finalizing the rest of the package.