• Loading stock data...
Thursday, October 16, 2025

Parties in House v. NCAA Settlement Submit Solution to Roster Limits Issue

The proposed solution could resolve a monthslong debate across the college sports industry over the roster limits, paving the way for the judge to rubber-stamp the settlement.

Jan 6, 2024; Tempe, Arizona, United States; Arizona State Sun Devil Emma Gehlert competes in the 200 yard medley relay against Grand Canyon University at Mona Plummer Aquatic Complex in Tempe on Jan. 6, 2024.
Imagn Images

On Wednesday, parties in the House v. NCAA class action submitted another draft of the settlement proposal to ensure no athletes would lose out on previously promised roster spots due to new roster limits that would be imposed by the settlement.

Northern District of California judge Claudia Wilken had previously said she wouldn’t approve the settlement otherwise.

The brief, co-signed by plaintiff attorneys and the NCAA and power conferences, would allow schools to offer players back their roster spots that have been rescinded in anticipation of the settlement. That includes current athletes whose roster spots were eliminated ahead of the new restrictions imposed by the settlement, as well as future athletes in the class of 2025-26 who were promised spots originally and then lost them. The settlement also addresses athletes who hit the transfer portal as a result of these limits, saying they can either stay in the transfer portal or go back to their original school.

The caveat, though, is that schools are not required to offer these reinstatements—they’re optional. In briefs submitted by both plaintiff attorneys and those for the NCAA, lawyers argued that roster spots have never been guaranteed for any NCAA athlete, so allowing schools the option to reinstate players, but not forcing it, was in line with previous rules before the settlement was introduced. 

“The bottom line is that all current or incoming 2025-26 Division I student-athletes who were removed or told they would be removed as a result of NCAA or conference roster limits can compete for a roster spot at their schools or other schools without counting against the roster limit, for the duration of their NCAA eligibility.”

If it accommodates Judge Wilken’s demands, it could resolve a monthslong debate in the college sports industry over roster limits and pave the way for Wilken to finally approve the settlement. (Wilken said in that same filing in April that she found no outstanding issues with other portions of the agreement.)

The settlement would offer $2.8 billion in damages for athletes who couldn’t capitalize on NIL (name, image, and likeness) earnings between 2016-2021, and allow D-I schools to share up to $20.5 million each with players. But it also imposed new restrictions, including implementing new limits to rosters as a compromise for eliminating limits on how many scholarships teams could offer. As a result, however, both current and prospective athletes have lost roster spots in anticipation of the new policy.

After the settlement got preliminary approval in October, hundreds of athletes, parents, and other industry experts began filing objections with the court about lost roster spots. During the final approval hearing on April 7, Wilken endorsed a solution: any settlement should grandfather in the players who had already received roster spot offers before the agreement was publicized, and phase in roster limits slowly. 

The two sides had originally declined to do so, but Wilken made a subsequent ruling stating that she was inclined not to approve the settlement unless “no members of the Injunctive Relief Settlement Class who have or had a roster spot will lose it as a result of the immediate implementation of the settlement agreement.” 

The solution, outlined in a four-page brief accompanied by a new draft of the settlement, would work something like this: Any athlete who falls into the category of being “assured” a roster spot in the 2025-26 academic year, or who was on the 2024-25 roster but has since lost their spot for 2025-26, would be called a “designated student-athlete.” Each D-I school that opts into the settlement will have to submit a list of “designated student-athletes” within 30 days of final approval. Class counsel can enforce submitting these lists if needed.

Schools won’t be forced to offer roster spots back, however. Lawyers argued that was in keeping with the status quo, as players could get cut from teams for other reasons besides the settlement. “While Defendants insisted that the changes to the Settlement Agreement recognize that individual schools and their athletics departments retain discretion to independently determine which athletes will be on their rosters, that has always been the case; and it remains unchanged whether or not there are roster limits,” the brief says. “The revisions to the Settlement Agreement ensure that class members who have or would have lost roster spots or promised roster spots as a result of the new roster limits will be in the same position as they would have been in if roster limits were never implemented, i.e., roster limits do not apply to them.”

The defendants added: “Attempting to guarantee roster spots would raise a host of practical and legal difficulties. Even if student-athletes were to receive a guaranteed right of return, they could be cut the next day for athletic performance or other reasons.”

Given that the proposal doesn’t require schools to reinstate roster spots, however, it’s unclear if this will be enough for Wilken. At some point in the next couple weeks, she will issue a decision about whether the proposed grandfathering solution is enough to allow the agreement to go forward.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Steelers’ Shared Stadium With Pitt Comes Under Fire for Bad Turf

The conditions at Acrisure Stadium have been subpar this season.
Tortillas

Texas Tech-Kansas Tortilla-Knife Mess Ends With $50K in Fines

Texas Tech’s tortilla tradition got both teams in trouble.
Oct 14, 2025; Birmingham, AL, USA; Arkansas Razorbacks head coach John Calipari talks with the media during SEC Media Days at Grand Bohemian Hotel.

SEC Coaches Sound Off on NIL, Revenue-Sharing: ‘Upside Down’

John Calipari doesn’t want to become “transactional.”

Texas-Oklahoma Gets 8.7M Viewers, Most-Watched CFB Game of Week 7

The Red River Rivalry was the most-watched game of the weekend.

Featured Today

May 25, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Derek Jeter walks the red carpet on Sunday, May 25, 2025, ahead of the 109th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway

The Players’ Tribune Is Still Kicking 11 Years Later

Founder Derek Jeter is still closely involved in the publication.
Las Vegas Aces center A'ja Wilson (22) celebrates with her teammates after her last second shot to take the lead 90-88 against the Phoenix Mercury in Game 3 of the WNBA Finals at Mortgage Matchup Center in Phoenix on Oct. 8, 2025.
exclusive
October 10, 2025

Standoff Over WNBA’s Future Has Dominated Finals

CBA negotiations have stolen the spotlight from the Aces’ dominant performance.
Paul Cartier
October 5, 2025

Sports Organists Are Still Thriving in the Era of Raucous Arena Music

“When they walk out and they see a real organ guy, it’s like, ‘Wow.’”
Sep 27, 2025; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Milwaukee Brewers center fielder Jackson Chourio (11) rounds the bases after hitting a home run during the sixth inning against the Cincinnati Reds at American Family Field.
October 4, 2025

Milwaukee Moneyball: Brewers Are Beating MLB’s Deeper Pockets

Milwaukee is holding its own against big-budget competitors.
Cody Campbell

Texas Tech Booster Cody Campbell Slams Conference PE Deals

Campbell said the concept goes against “all the laws of finance.”
October 13, 2025

Penn State Could Owe James Franklin Very Little of Buyout

FOS has reviewed Franklin’s 2021 contract extension.
Oct 11, 2025; Los Angeles, California, USA; USC Trojans wide receiver Makai Lemon (6) takes the ball on a kickoff return in the second half against the Michigan Wolverines at United Airlines Field at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
October 14, 2025

USC, Michigan Officials Oppose Big Ten’s Private Capital Proposal 

Officials from both schools met virtually on Tuesday.
Sponsored

How Jenny Just Is Shaping the Future of Sports Ownership

Jenny Just on bringing her investment experience to sports ownership.
Patrick Kraft
October 13, 2025

Penn State Says Adidas Had No Role in James Franklin Firing or..

Franklin is owed tens of millions of dollars.
October 13, 2025

College Football Coach Firings Nearing $100M in Contract Buyouts

Two other coaches besides James Franklin were fired Sunday.
October 12, 2025

Penn State Fires James Franklin, Will Pay Nearly $50M Buyout

The Nittany Lions lost again Saturday, falling to 3-3 this season.
Patrick Kraft
exclusive
October 11, 2025

Penn State, Adidas Deny Wrongdoing Around $300M Apparel Deal

The school and the brand publicly defended their 10-year deal Saturday.