• Loading stock data...
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
Law

The NFL Is Confident It Can Overturn the Sunday Ticket Verdict

  • Legal experts tell ‘FOS’ the NFL may have a path forward to overturn the ruling.
  • Particularly compelling may be their argument surrounding damages calculation.
Oct 2, 2021; Miami Gardens, FL, USA; NFL commissioner Roger Goddell speaks during the Don Shula Celebration of Life at Hard Rock Stadium.
Commissioner Roger Goodell (Jasen Vinlove-USA TODAY Sports)
MLB's Dream World Series

What the Dream Matchup Means for MLB

MLB is getting its two biggest markets facing off in the World Series.
Watch Now
October 25, 2024 | Video

Ambush. Fiasco. Pile of dung. Nonsense.

These are some of the words and phrases to describe the $4.7 billion jury verdict against the NFL in the Sunday Ticket case—parlance used by not just the NFL but also sports law experts interviewed by Front Office Sports. Earlier this month, jurors agreed with the plaintiffs that the league broke antitrust law by colluding to keep the out-of-market package priced artificially high and with a take-every-game-or-none approach.

Several of these legal experts believe the league has a decent chance to get the verdict overturned, a new trial ordered, or damages reduced by the presiding judge—even before the case arrives at the appellate court level. The judge scheduled a July 31 hearing to consider the NFL’s motion for him to change the verdict. 

“It does sound like there was a fiasco that went on in this courtroom that the judge allowed. There are all sorts of mistakes and things that happened that don’t seem O.K.,” says Mark Levinstein, a sports antitrust attorney with Washington, D.C.–based firm Williams & Connolly, tells FOS. He cites the significant procedural errors the NFL alleges occurred during the trial as well as the league’s assertion that the jury’s damages award is based on a misunderstanding of the evidence. “The judge isn’t going to want this to go to the court of appeals with a jury verdict that clearly was nonsense.”

Chris Deubert, a sports attorney with Constangy, Brooks, Smith & Prophete, believes “the NFL was right to say the jury’s award has to be reasonably connected to the evidence. And it [isn’t]. They have a pretty strong argument that that’s not the case here. That they, the jury, sort of made something up.” This is among the arguments the NFL made in its post-verdict motion July 3, which asks the judge to overturn the decision or order a new trial. 

As judges typically respect jury verdicts, the league’s full slate of contentions about legal errors and jury mistakes must be significant. The process of the losing side asking for the judge to alter the decision is often just a formality to check off before the case can be legally appealed. That may not be what’s happening here.

As part of its everything-but-the-kitchen-sink approach in its first post-verdict motion earlier this month, the NFL argued there were numerous errors in legal procedure, to even the seating of a juror who should have been rejected because he paid for a family member’s Sunday Ticket subscription. The league also argued that the plaintiffs violated legal protocol by waiting until the trial to raise the issue of price-fixing, timing the league says was an “ambush.”

But the argument the NFL has about the damages calculations is what has really caught the attention of legal experts. Many predict the judge, whom during the trial criticized the plaintiffs’ handling of the case, may act after the July 31 hearing before the case gets to an appeals court.

The plaintiffs had asked for $7 billion in damages, but the jurors rejected that calculation and came up with their own. While no juror has said how they got to $4.7 billion—a figure that would be tripled under antitrust law—the NFL makes what Levinstein calls a very “compelling” argument that it was based on a faulty conclusion.

The average list price for Sunday Ticket the jury had to work with was $294, and testimony during the trial pegged the actual average price paid was $102.74 (DirecTV was well known for heavily discounting Sunday Ticket and giving it away for free to lure subscribers). The NFL alleges that the jury took this $192 difference and multiplied it by the number of both residential- and commercial-class subscribers. “The results replicate the jury’s damages awards perfectly for the residential class, and within two cents for the commercial class,” the NFL said in its motion.

The plaintiffs have not yet filed a response to the NFL, and its lead lawyer did not reply to FOS’s request for comment, so it’s unclear of their take on how the jury arrived at the damages. But if the NFL is right, the jury may have confused the $102.74 figure for what consumers should have paid instead of the $294 listed price. The amount also would not apply to restaurants and bars, which pay far more for Sunday Ticket, though the jury seems to have used the same calculation here as well.

Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

“The NFL, I think, quite compellingly explains that doesn’t really make sense, because it’s not an overcharge,” Deubert says of the jury purportedly using the $192 figure—the difference between the listed price and the far lower average real price consumers paid—to calculate damages. “There would have had to have been evidence that shows that the class members should have only been charged, you know, $50 or $65 and were actually paying $294. But that does not seem to be the evidence.”

There in fact was some evidence of this because plaintiffs’ attorneys introduced at trial an NFL email showing ESPN in 2018 wanted to bid on the package and charge only $70 a month. Still, the plaintiffs’ $7 billion damages model was not based on that offer, but on a scenario in which teams distributed their own out-of-market games. According to the NFL’s motion, the plaintiffs’ expert report concluded this paradigm “​​results in Sunday Ticket being free to all class members during the class period.”

The main thrust of the plaintiffs’ argument is first that the antitrust exemption conferred on the NFL’s CBS and Fox deals by the Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961 does not extend to Sunday Ticket. And to please those two networks, which viewed Sunday Ticket as a competitor, the NFL worked to keep the price of the out-of-market package high while limiting the subscriber base, while the 32 teams colluded by agreeing not to sell their own out-of-market TV rights.

So, while the NFL will surely hammer at the calculation behind the jury damages figure, the league has these other broader issues it will raise on appeal when the case gets to the 9th Circuit, and possibly the Supreme Court. When the high court declined to hear the NFL’s petition in 2020 to throw out the litigation, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote in a side opinion that “the NFL and its member teams operate as a joint venture. Antitrust law likely does not require that the NFL and its member teams compete against each other with respect to television rights.”

He also wrote that the plaintiffs may not have standing because they bought Sunday Ticket from DirecTV, not the NFL.

The league doesn’t want to win by procedural and jury mistakes, Levinstein says. “They want to win on the Kavanaugh method.” 

Could the NFL settle?

Irwin Kishner, a sports attorney with New York–based firm Herrick Feinstein, says he is surprised the NFL did not settle before trial and expects the league ultimately will. He disagrees with Levinstein and Deubert that the judge in the case would alter the verdict, calling such instances rare (though he still describes the damages as “staggering”).

Levinstein, however, says, “I don’t know what the judge thinks. But the judge also has to understand this is going to the court of appeals and might go to the Supreme Court. So he may not want to send them a pile of dung.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

U.S. Firm Makes $310M Bet on Soccer by Forming Superagency

The U.S.-based investment company makes a significant play in international soccer.

Big Ten, SEC Dominate; Alabama Ranks 11th As CFP Picture Sharpens

The final rankings before conference championship games are out.

Amazon’s NFL Black Friday Game Ratings Up 41% From 2023

Amazon Prime Video’s Chiefs-Raiders broadcast averaged 13.51 million viewers.
James Dolan

James Dolan’s MSG Sports Declares War on Bootleg T-Shirt Vendors

The Knicks and Rangers are suing counterfeit merchandise vendors outside of MSG.

Featured Today

Dec 18, 2022; Lusail, Qatar; FIFA president Gianni Infantino claps during the awards ceremony after the 2022 World Cup final between Argentina and France at Lusail Stadium.

FIFA Wants More Matches. Resistance Is Growing Inside the Global Soccer World

Resentment and frustration over expanded schedules is nearing a breaking point.
November 30, 2024

U.S. Investors Are Gunning for England’s Small Soccer Clubs

Is another Hollywood-like success story possible among the U.K.’s smallest clubs?
Nov 1, 2024; Boise, Idaho, USA; Boise State Broncos running back Ashton Jeanty (2) leads the team onto the field prior to the first quarter against the San Diego State Aztecs at Albertsons Stadium.
November 29, 2024

Schools Are Scrambling to Prepare for the NCAA Revenue-Sharing Era

In the post–House v. NCAA world, “everyone’s kind of on their own.”
Nov 4, 2024; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Recording artist Taylor Swift arrives prior to a game between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Kansas City Chiefs at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium.
November 29, 2024

The PWHL Could Be Inviting a Date With Taylor Swift’s Legal Team

The Toronto Sceptres may have opened a Pandora’s box of trademark issues.
Mar 12, 2024; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Los Angeles Dodgers designated hitter Shohei Ohtani talks with translator Ippei Mizuhara in the dugout against the San Francisco Giants during a spring training baseball game at Camelback Ranch-Glendale.

Shohei Ohtani Seeks Baseball Cards From Interpreter in Federal Case

Ohtani’s former translator is expected to be sentenced for bank and tax fraud.
NFL QB Baker Mayfield
November 26, 2024

Baker Mayfield Sues Father’s Company for $12 Million

The suit says money transfers happened “without authorization.”
Tyreek Hill
November 26, 2024

Tyreek Hill Still Plans to Sue Miami-Dade Police After Charges Dropped, Lawyer..

The officers who arrested him in September did not appear in court. 
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
November 22, 2024

Logan Paul and Leo Messi’s Drink Companies Are Suing Each Other

Prime says Messi’s drink is copying its design.
Jul 8, 2021; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Phoenix Suns owner Robert Sarver reacts during the second half in game two of the 2021 NBA Finals at Phoenix Suns Arena. Mandatory Credit:
November 14, 2024

Former Suns Employee Sues Team Over Wrongful Termination, Retaliation

Andrea Trischan was the team’s former DEI program manager.
November 8, 2024

Michael Jordan’s Team Loses Bid for Temporary Injunction Against NASCAR

The teams can still compete, but will miss out on certain guarantees.
Brett Favre and Donald Trump
November 7, 2024

What Donald Trump’s Win Means for Welfare Probe, Brett Favre

Favre spoke at Trump’s rally last week in Green Bay, Wis.