• Loading stock data...
Tuesday, January 21, 2025

NIL Can Be Simple

  • More than a year-and-a-half after the first NIL law passed, the NCAA still hasn’t passed NIL rules of its own.
  • Meanwhile, the NAIA passed NIL laws in October 2020, and athletes just spent their first year making money.
Photo: NAIA/Design: Alex Brooks

After a California NIL law passed in 2019, the NCAA announced it would restore its athletes’ rights to profit off their name, image, and likeness. But more than a year-and-a-half later, the governing body still hasn’t passed NIL rules.

Meanwhile, the NAIA passed NIL laws in October 2020, and athletes just spent their first year making money.

NAIA’s Blueprint

The NAIA’s rules are much looser than the NCAA’s proposal from November.

For example, they’re much less restrictive on the types of deals athletes can participate in. The NAIA allows athletes to use their school logos, or wear their jerseys, in endorsement deals. That’s something the NCAA wants to prohibit, according to its November proposal.

The NCAA’s legislation would also keep athletes from signing deals with companies that “conflict with NCAA legislation” — like “banned substances” or sports betting entities. Athletic departments, however, currently have sponsorship deals with sports betting operators.

The NAIA leaves that restriction up to individual conferences.

Perhaps the dizzying number of caveats to NCAA NIL rules is why the governing body plans to pay a third-party administrator to oversee and police its deals. The NAIA, meanwhile, only requires that athletes tell their athletic departments about their NIL plans.

The NAIA didn’t respond to FOS’ written interview requests. But athletes all over the NAIA have already successfully made money off their NIL. And, in general, the sky hasn’t fallen.

Unnecessary Complications 

The NCAA wants tight control over NIL deals. But in January, the Justice Department warned that the NCAA’s rules could violate federal antitrust law because they’re too strict, according to USA Today

So the governing body claims it can’t pass NIL laws until it receives a decision in the antitrust Supreme Court case, NCAA v. Alston

The NAIA has shown it’s possible to write NIL laws that don’t violate antitrust. The NCAA could follow suit, but it’s too concerned with NIL deals going awry — which could result in losing its grip on amateurism.

State-by-State Caveats

NAIA schools could be subject to state NIL laws that don’t specify that they refer only to NCAA athletes. In fact, the NAIA knew it would have to abide by the California law, which is why it changed its rules in the first place.

So while this year may have been simple, NAIA schools may have more specific restrictions if they’re in states where laws have extra caveats.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Grant House and about 50 former and current athletes met at the College Football Playoff to discuss organizing efforts.

Players at the CFP Championship Are Talking About Unionizing

“It’s really just about our voices being heard,” one player said.
Notre Dame Fighting Irish quarterback Riley Leonard (13) celebrates with fans after winning a game between the Indiana Hoosiers and the Notre Dame Fighting Irish in first round of the College Football Playoff on Saturday, Dec. 21, 2024, in South Bend. Notre Dame defeated Indiana 27-17.

CFP Executive Director: More On-Campus Games Are a Possibility

FBS commissioners will discuss more CFP games o campus in the future.
Notre Dame Fighting Irish quarterback Riley Leonard and running back Jeremiah Love celebrate a touchdown during the first half of a game against the Indiana Hoosiers in the first round of the College Football Playoff.

Notre Dame Found a Title-Worthy NIL Formula. Now It Has to Pivot

Its title run was buoyed by a collective that no longer exists.
Nebraska's Rebekah Allick, right, lunges to pass the ball during a Big Ten volleyball match against Penn State at Rec Hall on Friday, Nov. 29, 2024, in State College, Pa.

DOE Issues More Guidance on Title IX Application to Athlete Pay

Financial assistance, including revenue-sharing, has to be equitable.

Featured Today

Unrivaled’s Impeccable Timing Pressures WNBA to Give Players More

The league could “blow the lid off” the business of women’s sports.
Jan 17, 2025; Miami, FL, USA; Dearica Hamby (5) of the Vinyl reaches for the ball as Azura Stevens (23) of the Rose follows on the play during the second half of the Unrivaled women’s professional 3v3 basketball league at Wayfair Arena.
January 17, 2025

Inside Unrivaled’s Explosive Opening Night

The 3-on-3 league went big for its season opener in Miami.
Baseball for All founder Justine Siegal walks in front of the over 400 young players participating in her league during the opening ceremony for an organization focused on giving girls an opportunity to play baseball, at Hohokam Stadium in Mesa, Ariz. on Wednesday, July 20, 2022. Baseball For All 15 Mar 30, 2023; Miami, Florida, USA; Miami Marlins general manager Kim Ng walks on the field prior to the game against the New York Mets at loanDepot Park.
January 17, 2025

Can a Professional Women’s Baseball League Launch in Softball’s Shadow?

The biggest hurdle to the WPBL’s success may be its closest kindred.
Showboats’ Daewood Davis (2) celebrates after scoring a touchdown during the UFL game between the San Antonio Brahmas and Memphis Showboats in Simmons Liberty Bank Stadium in Simmons Bank Liberty Stadium in Memphis, Tenn., on Saturday, April 6, 2024.
January 15, 2025

The UFL Is Primed for Success—If It Can Resist Its Impulse for..

The spring football league must buck temptation if it wants to succeed.

Ohio State’s $20M NIL Roster Just Won the National Championship

It’s believed to be one of the highest payrolls in CFB.
January 19, 2025

What’s Next for the CFP? Expansion, Format Changes on the Horizon

Year 1 of the expanded College Football Playoff concludes Monday.
January 19, 2025

CFP Title Game and Inauguration Falling on Same Day for First Time

The CFP executive director called it a “big day for the country.”
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
January 19, 2025

CFP Finale: Ohio State’s Redemption vs. Notre Dame’s Independence

Ohio State and Notre Dame face off in Atlanta on Monday night.
January 18, 2025

Wisconsin Accuses Miami of Tampering in Xavier Lucas Transfer

Cornerback Xavier Lucas announced his departure without going through the transfer portal.
*** THIS IS THE FULL CROP of Fred Squillante's famous 1995 photo of Eddie George vs. Notre Dame. *** (Scanned in 10/97 for use in calendar of OSU's great football moments.) *** KEEP IN THE ARCHIVE ALONG WITH THE TIGHTER-CROPPED ONE! *** Eddie George gets away from the Notre Dame defense on a long run. OSU Buckeyes vs. Notre Dame Fighting Irish . Ohio State University college football . Game played on Sat., September 30, 1995 .
January 17, 2025

Biden’s Justice Department Asks Judge to Deny House v. NCAA Settlement

The agency filed a scathing, 11-page request Friday.
Jan 15, 2025; Long Beach, California, USA; UCLA Bruins forward Kendall Dudley (22), forward Timea Gardiner (30), guard Avary Cain (2) and forward Zania Socka-Nguemen (6) react in the second half against the Penn State Nittany Lions at the Walter Pyramid at Long Beach State.
January 16, 2025

Education Dept. Says Title IX Applies to College Athlete Revenue-Sharing

Title IX protects students from sex-based discrimination in schools.