Wednesday, August 19, 2026

Crafting an Instagram Stories First-Frame Strategy

Instagram

Since exploding onto the scene just over two years ago, Instagram Stories has become the new digital darling of the sports industry.

Whether being used to showcase lineups, game highlights, or behind-the-scenes content, the evolution of stories and their role within the app has led to over 400 million users consuming content in the feature every day.

According to a recent study from social analytics company Delmondo that examined four categories — brands, media, entertainment, and sports — it was sports that had the highest completion rate of any of the industries measured at 75 percent.

Considering sports are a passion point for many, the fact that the industry leads the way isn’t the most surprising.

So, if followers of sports-related accounts — which reach, on average, 10 percent of their followers — are consuming three quarters or more of teams’ and leagues’ stories, what are professionals doing to make sure their story gets watched?

“Whether it’s for a client or our internal platform, MKTG’s strategy for the first frame in Instagram Stories is to create an eye-popping multimedia asset that immediately sparks emotion from the consumer.” – Jonah Ballow, VP of Digital at MKTG.

While there is no one-size-fits-all strategy, the general consensus among those who offered perspective was that brands have to catch their audience’s attention, and catch it quickly.

“In our benchmark study, we found that, on average, more people exit on the first and last frame than any other part of your story,” said Nick Cicero, CEO of Delmondo. “If you are not capturing the attention of people in the first two-to-three seconds of your story, a large percentage of people will exit or swipe away from your story.”

With completion rate staying somewhat stable after the second and third frame, making sure brands can get a consumer to them is the most challenging aspect. To relate it to something more tangible like driving, the hardest part about operating a manual car is getting it into first gear; after that its relatively smooth sailing. The same can be said for Instagram Stories.

How then, does one go about crafting a first frame that will compel people to click further into the story?

For Morgyn Seigfried, associate athletics director for digital strategy and production at Temple University, grabbing the attention of viewers is about enticing them as soon as possible.

“It’s like when someone takes an Instagram story of themselves singing in a car. Are you going to listen to the whole thing? No, unless it’s Beyonce or something. But if your friend posts a story that says ‘big news,’ are you going to click to the next post? Absolutely. It’s the same for brands. Don’t post just to post. Entice people. Give fans a look at content they are exclusively seeing on your story, and be intentional about it.”

Instagram

If you’re not enticing people on the first slide, depending on what type of content you have created, it’s OK to guide them to your desired destination as well.

Whether it’s a powerful image or even a graphic that points viewers in the right direction, Shahbaz Khan, senior manager of digital content for the Minnesota Timberwolves, always wants to make sure his most vibrant content is what appears first.

“Our goal is to ensure our strongest graphic leads off and if it’s a multi-swipe story, that we’ve got imagery that naturally leads into the next post. We tend to include arrow animations when graphics don’t have an obvious and natural tie into the next slide.”

Outside of people watching stories for their content, much of their time spent viewing can be out of sheer boredom, something that Eric Ginsberg, VP of digital at Cohn & Wolfe, sees as an opportunity for the teams and brands that get it right.

“Users are viewing for entertainment, but also just to curb boredom. Decisions to tap forward are made in a split-second. We focus on the first frame having dynamic movement and color to disrupt the consistency of the prior stories to keep a consumer paying attention longer and to prevent the instant tap forward. A big, bold first frame matters.”

[mc4wp_form id=”8260″]

With those under the age of 25 spending more than 32 minutes a day and those age 25 and older spending more than 24 minutes a day on Instagram according to the platform, cutting through the clutter of what likely amounts to hundreds of posts and story frames is not easy.

At BYU, Tyson Hutchins and the social team in the athletic department make sure that they are driving home the narrative of their story from the beginning.  

“With storytelling being our goal, we always try to dive into the narrative within the first frame. By taking the time to prioritize the first frames of a story, we’ve seen a dramatic increase in how our followers interact with our stories.”

Instagram

For massive media companies like ESPN, making sure that the feature is telling stories is key to the overall success of the content it produces.

To make sure the user feels as if they are actually following a theme and or narrative, Ryan Spoon, SVP of social content and digital video at ESPN, always looks to create a great first frame, but then follow up with frames that build off of what was presented at the beginning of the story.

“The user should not be surprised or feel disconnected from that first introduction as they traverse through the various frames. Stories will almost certainly have different aesthetics and presentations, but they should have a consistent arch and narrative, and the first frame is obviously a key element of that.”

While it may seem oversimplified, the first frame is like a book cover, existing to draw the attention of the user in amongst a myriad of other options, while holding together what should be a larger narrative inside.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Sign up for
The Memo Newsletter

Get the biggest stories and best analysis on the business of sports delivered to your inbox twice every weekday and twice on weekends.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Trendy Golf Hat Divide Is More Than a Fashion Fight

As golf has gotten trendier, so has the sport’s style.
President Donald Trump and FIFA President Gianni Infantino hold World Cup medals during the FIFA World Cup 2026 final between Argentina and Spain at New York New Jersey Stadium on Sunday, July 19, 2026, in East Rutherford, NJ.

Trump Finally Backs Infantino Amid FIFA Leadership Crisis

Trump said it’d be a “terrible mistake” if FIFA considered replacing Infantino.
Joey Spallina of the Maryland Whipsnakes

How Eye Black Became ‘War Paint’ on the Field

“You’re going into battle, doing something you only do on game days.”

Tom Brady Explains His Aggressive Push Into Trading Cards

Brady talked to FOS about his eponymous card company.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

8/19/26 – Lakers Family Feud, NFL Eyes Overseas Team, Knicks Embarrass Nets

0:00

Featured Today

FILE PHOTO: Cricket - Indian Premier League - IPL - Mumbai Indians v Chennai Super Kings - Wankhede Stadium, Mumbai, India - April 23, 2026 Mumbai Indians' Suryakumar Yadav in action

India Is Stealing Cricket’s Throne From England and Australia

India’s insatiable appetite for cricket has shifted the traditional locus of power.
WPBL
July 30, 2026

Who’s Playing Women’s Professional Baseball?

Sixty players from 11 countries are descending on Illinois for six weeks.
Tom's Watch Bar
July 17, 2026

Sports Bars Are Cashing In From Summer of Soccer

The World Cup has brought a windfall to America’s biggest sports bars.
Jun 16, 2026; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; France forward Michael Olise (11) controls the ball against Senegal during a Group I match of the 2026 FIFA World Cup at New York New Jersey Stadium
July 16, 2026

Where World Cup Stars Go to Customize Their Cleats

The world’s best players turn to a Scottish craftsman for perfect cleats.
July 10, 2026

What the World Cup Means to Erling Haaland’s Tiny Hometown

The tournament’s breakout star is from a rural Norwegian town.
Feb 4, 2026; San Francisco, CA, USA; NFL Network host Colleen Wolfe on radio row at the Super Bowl LX media center at the Moscone Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
Exclusive

NFL Media Re-arms As Andrew Siciliano, Colleen Wolfe Return

Michael Yam, Trevor Sikkema, and Brett Kollmann are also joining NFL Media.
Deion Sanders takes in the second day of Cleveland Browns training camp, July 30, 2026, in Berea, Ohio.
August 18, 2026

Colorado’s ‘Prime Effect’ Is Wearing Off

Fewer national TV broadcasts loom for Colorado following a 3–9 season.
Feb 6, 2026; San Francisco, CA, USA; Pat McAfee on the Pat McAfee Show set at the Super Bowl LX media center at the Moscone Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
August 19, 2026

Pat McAfee’s ESPN Ascent Continues With ‘Monday Night Countdown’

Jason McCourty is also joining the ‘Monday Night Countdown’ cast.
Sponsored

Saints Great Turns to Ownership

Marques Colston discusses his Champions Fund launch and finding success after football.
August 17, 2026

NBA Rips ESPN Reporting on Kawhi Leonard Investigation

ESPN says it stands by its reporting.
Kurt Warner
Exclusive
August 17, 2026

ESPN Closes In on Announce Teams for NFL Network Games

It remains “fluid” whether Jason Kelce will join some game broadcasts.
Feb 11, 2024; Paradise, Nevada, USA; CBS analyst J.J. Watt on the field before Super Bowl LVIII between the Kansas City Chiefs and the San Francisco 49ers at Allegiant Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports
August 17, 2026

J.J. Watt’s CBS Rise Could Reshape the NFL Analyst Pecking Order

Watt will serve as CBS’s top game analyst in Tony Romo’s absence.
August 16, 2026

Stephen A. Smith Vows to Fire Back at NABJ Over ‘Award’

“You had your turn, now mine is coming,” he wrote.