• Loading stock data...
Sunday, January 26, 2025

How College Football Entered an Unprecedented Era of Parity

College football’s version of unrestricted free agency has led to a new-look Playoff field. It was created by a pair of lawsuits—and isn’t likely to change soon.

Indiana's Elijah Sarratt (13) celebrates a touchdown during the Indiana versus Purdue football game at Memorial Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 30, 2024.
Rich Janzaruk/Imagn Images

How the NFL (and Netflix) Stole Christmas From the NBA

The NFL and Netflix are elbowing onto the NBA’s turf.
Read Now
December 26, 2024 |

Just in time for the expanded College Football Playoff format, the sport has experienced an unprecedented amount of parity. Boise State, SMU, and Indiana have all become unlikely powerhouses this season, making their first appearances. Meanwhile, bluebloods have been pushed out—the Alabama Crimson Tide won’t appear in the Playoff for only the third time in the CFP era. Neither will the Michigan Wolverines, the reigning national champions.

College football’s shake-up can be largely attributed to new NIL (name, image, and likeness) deals and transfer portal rules. This year, for the first time, players were allowed to transfer as many times as they want without penalty, as well as negotiate NIL deals in advance and sign de facto pay-for-play contracts. Teams showed they can entice recruits with big NIL checks—but that success is also possible with a “moneyball” approach.

Despite the NCAA’s attempts to control player earnings and movements, the era of “unrestricted free agency” has arrived. The environment was created by two lawsuits—and it’s not likely to change unless the NCAA can win in court or Congress.


In December 2023, seven state attorneys general filed a lawsuit against the NCAA, arguing its remaining transfer portal restrictions—that players can transfer only once without having to sit out—violated federal antitrust law. A federal judge agreed to temporarily enjoin these restrictions, and the NCAA ultimately agreed to permanently change its rules.

The AGs weren’t done. In January, the Tennessee and Virginia state attorneys general filed a different federal antitrust lawsuit against the NCAA over NIL restrictions. A judge agreed in February, granting a preliminary injunction preventing the NCAA from enforcing any NIL rules until the case is settled (the injunction is still in place, as the case is ongoing). Among other things, that meant the NCAA couldn’t punish athletes, schools, and NIL collectives from conversing and negotiating before an athlete enrolled at a particular college. 

By the time the 2024 college football season kicked off in August, teams had a gargantuan pool of transfers to choose from and were allowed to entice them with flashy deals.

The system has created an opportunity for fans, donors, and boosters to bankroll entire new rosters in a way they never could before. The top collectives in the power conference are operating with budgets of between $15 million and $25 million, one industry source tells Front Office Sports. But others have less than $6 million. 

A common misconception is that the more money a team has, the better athletes they could recruit.

“The main, biggest thing in NIL roster management is how you spend that money—not the amount of money,” Russell White, the president of The Collective Association, tells FOS. White calls it the “moneyball” approach: sifting through the transfer portal for Group of 5 players, or “underutilized” power conference players, to fit your team’s specific needs. “If you do that … you see results.” 

Collectives don’t disclose how much money they make, but White pointed to Indiana as an example of a program that used the portal to completely redo its roster. Last season, the Hoosiers were 3–9, ranked last in the Big Ten East. The program went through a major rebuild under coach Curt Cignetti—and this year, the team notched 11 wins, earned a top-10 ranking, and will appear in the 12-team Playoff. 


The parity is, overall, good for the sport, industry sources say. One media-rights expert noted that ratings for postseason games with underdog teams may not be as high as those featuring bluebloods. But the intangible metrics, like social media buzz and storytelling around those teams and games, is likely healthy for retaining fan bases long-term.

But will it last?

If many coaches had their way, it wouldn’t. Despite the recruiting benefits, coaches have lamented the difficulty in re-recruiting their entire roster every year. In some ways, they’re right: It’s an unprecedented situation in sports—none of the major pro leagues in the U.S. allow for unfettered free agency. But they’re allowed to restrict the movement and salaries of their players because they have forged collective bargaining agreements with players’ unions—something the NCAA refuses to allow.

The NCAA has, instead, vowed that congressional intervention could override the court decisions creating this environment, and has spent millions of dollars on a sophisticated lobbying campaign to get lawmakers to act. It’s also using a landmark settlement in the House v. NCAA case to gain more control over the influence of NIL collectives. 

But neither a federal law nor the settlement is guaranteed. So until there’s a major legal update, this new normal will continue. The current number of FBS football players reportedly in the transfer portal: more than 1,200.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Dec 7, 2024; Atlanta, GA, USA; Georgia Bulldogs quarterback Carson Beck (15) reacts during the second half in the 2024 SEC Championship game at Mercedes-Benz Stadium
opinion

In the NIL Era, You Can Help Your School Buy a Quarterback

How the wild new normal sets college sports apart from the pros.

Vanderbilt Has Racked Up $850,000 in Fines for Court Storming This School..

Vandy’s head coach said he’s fine with the fines for now.
PWHL arena

PWHL’s Sophomore Year Booms in Canada, Has Room to Grow in U.S.

Attendance is up 30% from last year, the league says.
USC football

USC Poaches Notre Dame Football GM Chad Bowden With $1 Million Salary

The GM position has taken on outsized importance in college sports.

Featured Today

Once Abandoned, Portland Is Regaining Its Place in the WNBA

The next WNBA team is springing up in a once-deserted market.
October 17, 2011; East Rutherford, NJ, USA; New York Jets fan fireman Ed during the first half against the Miami Dolphins at the New Meadowlands Stadium.
January 24, 2025

Superfandom Is a Lifestyle, Business—and Thorn in Some Teams’ Sides

Rabid fandom has perks—sometimes to the frustration of teams and leagues.
Jeremiah Smith
January 22, 2025

Ohio State’s Title Isn’t As Simple As $20 Million in NIL

Three lessons from the Buckeyes’ title beyond “pay the best players.”
January 22, 2025

Can Upstart Sports Leagues Beat the Grim Start-Up Odds?

Investors think they can buck the massive failure rate of new enterprises.

CFP Title Game Draws 22 Million Viewers, Down 12% From Last Year

Ohio State defeated Notre Dame in Monday’s title game.
Ohio State Buckeyes celebrate their 34-23 win over Notre Dame Fighting Irish to win the College Football Playoff National Championship at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta on January 20, 2025.
January 21, 2025

Why College Football Playoff Championship Game Must Be on Monday

It’d be a bad idea for the CFP to compete with the NFL.
January 21, 2025

CFP Aftermath: What’s Next for Ryan Day and Marcus Freeman?

Ohio State defeated Notre Dame in the title game Monday.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
Ryan Day
January 21, 2025

Million-Dollar Bonuses to $2 Hot Dogs: The Big Money of Ohio State’s..

Ryan Day landed a seven-figure bonus for winning it all Monday night.
January 21, 2025

Amateurism Dilemma on Full Display at the College Football Playoff

The sport has never looked or operated more like a pro league.
January 20, 2025

Ohio State’s $20M NIL Roster Just Won the National Championship

It’s believed to be one of the highest payrolls in CFB.
January 19, 2025

CFP Title Game and Inauguration Falling on Same Day for First Time

The CFP executive director called it a “big day for the country.”