• Loading stock data...
Thursday, October 10, 2024
The Best Employers in Sports survey is now open! Take the survey

Federal Judge Temporarily Strikes Down NCAA Transfer Restrictions

  • Seven state attorneys general have argued that the NCAA’s restrictions on eligibility after an athlete transfers a second time violate federal antitrust laws.
  • A federal judge in West Virginia put a temporary stop to the rule that a player must sit out for one year.
RaeQuan Battle NCAA
Bob Donnan-USA TODAY Sports

On Wednesday, a federal judge in West Virginia ruled to temporarily prohibit the NCAA from enforcing restrictions on second-time transfers for two weeks.

The lawsuit, State of Ohio et al v. NCAA, was filed last Thursday. Seven state attorneys general have alleged that the NCAA’s remaining restrictions on athlete eligibility after transferring a second time violate federal antitrust law.

The NCAA is also prohibited from enforcing its “Rule of Restitution,” according to the decision. That rule states that if a court grants eligibility to an athlete and later reverses that decision, the NCAA has the power to vacate records or wins that the team or athlete accomplished while they were playing.

The ruling technically only applies to athletes within the jurisdiction of the court: the northern district of West Virginia, Kennyhertz Perry sports attorney Mit Winter pointed out. However, the NCAA said in a statement that it will not enforce its transfer rule at least for the next 14 days. It also won’t penalize players if the ruling is reversed.

Athletes won’t lose a year of future eligibility if they play a couple games and then lose eligibility again after the next ruling on Dec. 27, the spokesperson told Front Office Sports on Wednesday. But on Thursday, the NCAA changed its tune, saying it was still discussing the impact on future years of eligibility.

The case was largely inspired by the story of West Virginia basketball player RaeQuan Battle, whose eligibility waiver was denied by the NCAA after he transferred from a program where his coach abruptly left. Battle, as well as Miami of Ohio quarterback Maddox Kopp and Cincinnati basketball player Jamille Reynolds, testified during the hearing, which lasted more than two-and-a-half hours Wednesday. 

Northern District of West Virginia Judge John P. Bailey clarified he did not have time to address Battle’s specific situation. “The only thing I’m saying is that you can’t make a player sit out a year,” Bailey said.

Athletes’ testimony, which covered everything from name, image, and likeness issues to mental health, seemed to place a specific emphasis on the fact that coaches can leave their positions at a school at any time, and as many times they want, without repercussions. Players, however, are only allowed to transfer once without restriction. 

Wednesday’s decision is not a permanent strikedown of NCAA rules. The next hearing, which will be for a preliminary injunction to keep this rule in effect until the case goes to trial or is settled, will be Dec. 27.

Editor’s Note: This story has been updated with additional information.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Cam Newton Joins ‘First Take,’ Where His Opinions Should Fit Right In

ESPN has hired the 2015 NFL MVP as a contributor to “First Take.”
Sep 13, 2024; New York, New York, USA; United States men's national team head coach Mauricio Pochettino poses for a photo with chief executive officer and secretary general JT Batson, sporting director Matt Crocker, president Cindy Parlow Cone, and MLS commissioner Don Garber after a press conference introducing him as the new head coach for the United States men's national team at Warner Bros. Discovery Hudson Center.

U.S. Soccer, Flush With Cash, Lays Off Dozens

The nonprofit federation is expecting nine figures in revenue this fiscal year.
Nike

Nike Has Lost Some Mojo. But Not Its Market Share

Nike is in recovery mode but still enjoys a dominant slice of the market.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Patriots Hit Rock Bottom; WNBA Finals Begin

0:00

Featured Today

Duante' Abercrombie News Ch.4 interview

Tennessee State’s Ambitious Plan to Launch an HBCU Hockey Program

TSU has big plans, but the university is facing an existential dilemma.
October 8, 2024

Ryan Smith Sees Salt Lake City As Next Vegas-Like Sports Town

Utah Hockey Club’s owner says all the pieces are falling into place.
October 8, 2024

How the WWE’s Farm Circuit Became a Primetime Draw

NXT produces generational talent—and it occupies a new prime-time network slot.
A DraftKings sign
October 7, 2024

A DraftKings Exec Left for Fanatics. Then the Bitter Legal Battle Began

Mike Hermalyn has been sidelined at Fanatics for nine months now.

Why CFB Super-League Proposals Are Likely Doomed

Could a college football super league work one day in the future?
Sep 6, 2024; Dallas, Texas, USA; Big 12 Commissioner Brett Yormark before the game between the Southern Methodist Mustangs and the Brigham Young Cougars at Gerald J. Ford Stadium.
October 8, 2024

Big 12’s Brett Yormark Doesn’t ‘Wake Up Thinking’ About SEC, Big Ten

Big 12’s commissioner says he isn’t concerned about reports of a Big Ten–SEC scheduling alliance.
October 9, 2024

Duke Men’s Basketball GM Explains How She’d Avoid UNLV NIL Disaster

Rachel Baker was one of the first hires as a college GM.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
October 7, 2024

Vandy Trying to Cash In on Upset

Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia is looking for new NIL deals.
The NCAA logo on a football field
October 7, 2024

Landmark House Settlement to Pay College Athletes Gets Preliminary Approval From Judge

The deal in House v. NCAA previously appeared to be in jeopardy.
October 6, 2024

Vandy, Arkansas Fined After Upsets

The two schools’ fanbases ran onto the fields after games ended.
OSU QB Terrelle Pryor
October 4, 2024

Terrelle Pryor Sues Ohio State As Group of Athletes Seeking NIL Back-Pay Grows

Reggie Bush, Michigan players, and NC State’s basketball team sued this year.