• Loading stock data...
Thursday, April 24, 2025

‘Absolute Bulls—.’ ‘Completely Made Up.’ Don’t Believe Everything You Read About NIL Deals in the Transfer Portal

  • Many of the biggest headlines vastly overinflate numbers, experts in the field tell Front Office Sports.
  • Seven-figure contracts are much less prevalent than suggested, and there are vast differences between schools in the Power 5.
NIL Summitt
NIL Summit via USA Today Network
Cristina Daglas
Exclusive

ESPN Executive Editor Cristina Daglas Out After HR Investigation

Daglas was placed on administrative leave in January.
Read Now
April 23, 2025 |

The rumor mill for NIL collective deals is now an annual tradition in college sports, a space where stories of alleged offers to athletes in the transfer portal go viral on almost a weekly basis.

But many of the biggest headlines report vastly overinflated numbers, according to four industry experts who work for or with collectives and athletes. “You can say whatever you want, because no one knows … no one talks numbers,” one Power 5 collective operator tells Front Office Sports. “Even our athletes lie about what they make to other athletes on the team.”

Within days of the portal opening this year, on Dec. 4, a bombshell report suggested that Ohio State receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. fielded an offer around $20 million, presumably an attempt to lure him to stay with the Buckeyes an extra year instead of declaring for the NFL draft.

But none of the four experts FOS spoke to believed that figure was accurate. Even if it were, the offer would be a significant outlier in the collective market. 

“On the record: It’s absolute bulls—,” says Jason Belzer, head of Student Athlete NIL, which helps run collectives for schools across the country. 

A slightly more tempered but still jaw-dropping headline: Nebraska head coach Matt Rhule said in December that a “good quarterback” costs somewhere between $1 million and $2 million in the portal. 

“That’s just completely made up,” the Power 5 collective operator says. 

It could be the case for Rhule and the Cornhuskers, but certainly not for the vast majority of the Power 5, the same source says. So what does the overall collective market actually look like? 

One Power 5 collective operator says that even within the richest group of schools, there are three different tiers of collectives representing vastly different amounts of money for players. 

Sources agree that athletes employed by the top tier will make in the ballpark of seven figures, but one added that some athletes make this amount of money due to a combination of collective earnings and other NIL contracts.

Some companies with access to collective contracts have attempted to publish aggregate data. Belzer reported that 61 “Power 4” one-year contracts that ran through his company totaled $7.3 million, with athletes receiving an average of $120,000. Other companies, like Opendorse and INFLCR, have also released aggregate data on the collectives they engage. 

While these numbers are the closest thing in the industry to a complete picture, the data has significant limitations:

  • These companies only have access to the collectives they work with, so their data is hardly representative of the entire industry. 
  • Companies (specifically Opendorse and INFLCR) only have access to the data that their schools or collectives report
  • Due to the limitations of basic math, averages could be skewed by a huge contract outlier. 

There’s a reason the NIL industry has a stunning lack of transparency: NIL deals aren’t player salaries. In the pros, athlete salaries are made public because they’re collectively bargained—but players aren’t required to disclose endorsement contracts or other private business dealings.

“You don’t know what Aaron Rodgers makes from a State Farm Deal,” says Jim Cavale, the former CEO of INFLCR and founder of athlete advocacy organization Athletes.org. “But you do know what he makes with the Jets.”

In college athletics, the opacity can help and harm all parties. Since collectives themselves don’t know what competitors are truly offering, athletes or agents can leverage completely fabricated offers—or wind up empty-handed if they overestimate their marketplace value. 

“You can also lie as a collective,” Cavale adds. He says he has heard of multiple situations in football and basketball in which collectives have falsely promised athletes a certain amount of money if they transfer.

Without formal agreements, it’s unclear whether athletes would have legal recourse in that situation. And those outside the top tier may not have the money to hire lawyers to go after collectives.

There’s a movement, at least at the NCAA level, for real transparency. NCAA president Charlie Baker has asked Congress to pass a federal law that would require some sort of disclosure of NIL deal values, even without specific athletes’ names attached. Many frustrated coaches support that movement.

Achieving transparency could be relatively simple: The NCAA could agree to collectively bargain with athletes and create a revenue-sharing or salary agreement, experts have noted. 

“I’m for transparency, but not how it’s currently set up,” one collective operator said.

The NCAA, meanwhile, is fighting tooth and nail—in courts and in Congress—against athlete unionization, collective bargaining, or employee status. So for now, the NIL market will remain a rumor mill, for everyone involved.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

NC State women's cross country

Judge Threatens to Reject $2.8 Billion House v. NCAA Settlement

The NCAA and power conferences could end up at trial.
Olympic rings

SafeSport Fires CEO Amid Scandal

Ju’Riese Colón was hired in 2019, two years after the agency’s founding.
Cristina Daglas
exclusive

ESPN Executive Editor Cristina Daglas Out After HR Investigation

Daglas was placed on administrative leave in January.
Jul 20, 2022; Minneapolis, MN, USA; Everton defender Nathan Patterson (3) challenged by Minnesota United forward Luis Amarilla (9) in the first half at Allianz Field.

Everton Accelerates Rebound With Addition of Texans Minority Owner

Friedkin acquired Everton in December after a prolonged sale process.

Featured Today

Apr 5, 2025; San Antonio, TX, USA; Duke Blue Devils forward Cooper Flagg (2) reacts after a three point basket against the Houston Cougars during the first half in the semifinals of the men's Final Four of the 2025 NCAA Tournament at the Alamodome.

Cooper Flagg’s Timing Is Perfect for the NBA and USA Basketball

The projected No. 1 pick just declared for the draft.
Apr 14, 2025; New York, New York, USA; Paige Bueckers is interviewed by ESPN after being selected with the number one overall pick to the Dallas Wings in the 2025 WNBA Draft at The Shed at Hudson Yards
April 21, 2025

ESPN’s WNBA Coverage Mirrors the League’s Stunning Growth

“I don’t think we stand still in our coverage of women’s sports,” says Rowe.
Mar 16, 2025; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Oklahoma City Thunder guard Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (2) celebrates with guard Isaiah Joe (11) after score in the fourth quarter against the Milwaukee Bucks at Fiserv Forum.
April 20, 2025

Unorthodox OKC: The Thunder Redefined Tanking to Become NBA’s Best

A rebuild years in the making has OKC in the driver’s seat.
Mar 13, 2020; Augusta, GA, USA; The front entrance at Augusta National Golf Club in Augusta, Ga., Friday morning. The Masters Tournament has been postponed due to coronavirus concerns.
opinion
April 20, 2025

What’s It Like to Play Augusta? A Day on the World’s Most..

Inside a round at the most exclusive club in the world.
Dec 27, 2024; Memphis, TN, USA; Arkansas Razorbacks defensive back Miguel Mitchell (16) returns an interception during the forth quarter against the Texas Tech Red Raiders at Simmons Bank Liberty Stadium.

NIL Contract Buyouts Are More Common, but Can They Be Enforced?

The Arkansas collective has issued two demand letters to players to pay buyouts.
Fordham
April 23, 2025

Fordham Hit With Rare NIL Era NCAA Sanctions

The Rams were hit with recruiting violations stemming from a Times Square photo shoot.
Flau'jae Johnson
exclusive
April 23, 2025

Flau’jae Johnson Says She Will Return to LSU

The transfer portal closed Wednesday.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

This week, Two-time Super Bowl Champion and CBS NFL analyst Logan Ryan joins us to talk the business of sports on our third installment of Portfolio Players.
Mar 20, 2025; Providence, RI, USA; McNeese State Cowboys guard Quadir Copeland (11) brings the ball up court against Clemson Tigers forward Ian Schieffelin (4) during the second half at Amica Mutual Pavilion.
April 22, 2025

Why College Players Without NCAA Eligibility Are Flooding the Transfer Portal

Athletes nationwide hope legal challenges will win them extra eligibility.
Charlie Baker
April 22, 2025

NCAA Increases Lobbying Spending in First Months of Trump

The governing body spent $450,000 on lobbying during the first quarter.
April 21, 2025

UCLA’s Joey Aguilar Transferring to Tennessee in Quarterback Swap

UCLA quarterback Joey Aguilar will trade places with Tennessee’s Nico Iamaleava.
Dec 30, 2022; Glendale AZ, USA; The College Football Playoff logo on the field at State Farm Stadium, the site of the 2022 CFP Semifinal between the TCU Horned Frogs and the Michigan Wolverines and Super Bowl 57 (LVII).
April 21, 2025

CFP Format Questions Loom Over Spring Meetings

The CFP management committee is meeting in Dallas this week.