• Loading stock data...
Saturday, May 31, 2025

Trio of Athlete Objections Filed Against House v. NCAA Settlement Proposal

  • Objectors range from women’s rowers to power conference football players.
  • It’s unclear how successful they’ll be in altering the settlement.
Nov 17, 2023; Charlottesville, VA, USA; The NCAA logo on a banner at the NCAA cross country championships course at Panorama Farms.
Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

The first athlete objections to the House v. NCAA proposal have been filed, less than a month after the 300-page document—that would pave the way for revenue-sharing—was submitted to the court. A trio of objections argued a wide range of grievances, from gender equity to antitrust issues. 

House v. NCAA, first filed in 2020, argues that athletes deserve damages for losing out on NIL (name, image, and likeness) opportunities before 2021, and that the definition of NIL should be expanded. It addresses a range of athlete compensation issues, allowing power conference schools to share up to $22 million with players, as well as pay $2.8 billion in damages in conjunction with the NCAA. But it also sets multiple restrictions, like a cap on revenue-sharing and an approval process for NIL deals of more than $600. The NCAA has said it hopes Congress will codify an approved settlement, as well as protect the NCAA from having to make any future reforms. 

So far, no athletes have objected to the general concepts of back-damages and revenue-sharing, but have taken issue with many of the specifics. 

Lawyers representing Ivy League athletes Grace Kirk and Tamenang Choh filed the first objection Thursday afternoon with a narrow grievance. Choh and Kirk’s lawyers argue that the settlement in the House case includes language that would force them to relinquish their claims against Ivy League schools in a separate ongoing lawsuit if they want to be members of the House plaintiff class. The two athletes, along with a proposed plaintiff class, are suing Ivy League schools for refusing to offer athletic scholarships.

On Friday, lawyers representing plaintiffs in Fontenot v. NCAA, an antitrust case over the NCAA’s general compensation limits, and Cornelio v. NCAA, a lawsuit filed last week over partial scholarships, objected to the House damage claims and the revenue-sharing proposal. The lawyers argued that the settlement doesn’t consider damages related to their lawsuits, which could far exceed the $2.8 billion allotted as damages in the House settlement. They also argue it includes unfair restrictions. They believe that because so many different groups of athletes could be part of the settlement, they should receive their own representation.

Their remedy: Either appoint the Fontenot lawyers to represent certain athletes in the settlement negotiations, or “carve out” these claims from the settlement altogether. “The parties used this NIL case to try to write a collective bargaining agreement, but without any of labor law’s protections,” the lawyers wrote. “Indeed, the current settlement allows the NCAA to check multiple items off its litigation wish list, while creating a byzantine system to insulate it from future lawsuits.”

Also on Friday, lawyers for six current and former Division I female rowers from Yale, George Washington, Texas, and Oregon State filed the third objection to the settlement on the grounds it gives female athletes “the short end of the stick.”

It suggests the damages—based mostly on potential NIL earnings—severely undervalue women’s sports athletes. Of the $2.8 billion, “a male football player may receive hundreds of thousands of dollars, while a female swimmer might receive $125 or less,” the objection estimated. It laments the fact there are no damages for lost scholarships, arguing women’s sports athletes have been disproportionately affected by the NCAA’s scholarship limits.

Like the Fontenot and Cornelio athletes, the six rowers also argue the cap on revenue-sharing and NIL payment restrictions violate antitrust law. The rowers even suggest the settlement is an attempt to prevent athletes from being deemed employees (though plaintiff lawyers and the NCAA/power conferences have noted the settlement doesn’t directly address the employment question).

It’s unclear how much merit district court judge Claudia Wilken will give these claims. Given the timeline she’s approved, Wilken has signaled she’s at least interested in hearing out the athletes’ grievances, Boise State law professor Sam Ehrlich noted. (She has already denied a request to object by Houston Christian University, a D-I school in the Southland Conference. But the school’s burden to enter an objection is higher than athletes’ because it’s not a plaintiff or defendant, according to Ehrlich.)

There could be more athlete objections at later stages in the proceedings. A hearing for preliminary approval will take place Sept. 5. Then, starting in October, athletes will start to receive formal notices. Beginning Jan. 14, 2025, there will be a 105-day period in which athletes would object to the settlement before Judge Wilken considers the settlement for final approval.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

PSG and the City of Paris Can Join European Soccer’s Elite

What a maiden Champions League title would mean for the French club.
Mar 24, 2024; Los Angeles, California, USA; Detailed view of the basketball sneakers worn by Los Angeles Clippers guard Terance Mann (14) against the Philadelphia 76ers at Crypto.com Arena.

Skechers Sued Over Allegedly Sketchy Go-Private Deal

The footwear giant agreed to be acquired by 3G Capital for $9.4 billion.

Featured Today

How the Champions League Anthem Took on a Life of Its Own

The composer didn’t know he wrote a timeless hit three decades ago.
May 25, 2025

How Rolex Paved the Way for Luxury’s Love Affair With Tennis

“It’s almost impossible to think about tennis without thinking about Rolex.”
Mar 23, 2025; Miami, FL, USA; Alexandra Eala (PHI) reacts after winning a point against Madison Keys (USA)(not pictured) on day six of the Miami Open at Hard Rock Stadium.
May 24, 2025

Alex Eala Is Defying Her Country’s Odds to Make French Open History

The Philippines native has overcome a unique set of financial odds.
May 24, 2025

Indiana Is the Center of the Basketball Universe—Thanks to Both Pro Teams

The Fever and Pacers are thriving at the same time.
Mar 28, 2025; Atlanta, GA, USA; Mississippi Rebels forward Jaemyn Brakefield (4) rebounds over Michigan State Spartans center Carson Cooper (15) and Mississippi Rebels guard Matthew Murrell (11) in the second half of a South Regional semifinal of the 2025 NCAA tournament at State Farm Arena.

SEC Increases Court Storming Fine to $500K—With Caveat

The SEC used to fine schools $500,000 as a third-time offense.
May 29, 2025

Former Seton Hall Baseball Player Sues Over Sexualized Hazing

The student says the coach knew about the hazing and failed to act.
May 29, 2025

Brett Yormark: Big 12 Puts Private Equity and Naming Rights on Pause

Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark is shifting his conference’s strategy.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

In Episode 7 of Portfolio Players, go inside the boardroom with Avenue Capital CEO and former Milwaukee Bucks co-owner Marc Lasry on Giannis’s future, women’s sports, and upstart leagues like TGL and Unrivaled. 
May 29, 2025

Brian Kelly Pushes for SEC–Big Ten Alliance. Would It Widen the Gap?

A deal, if completed, would further strengthen college football’s two titans.
Mar 16, 2025; Fort Worth, TX, USA; UAB Blazers forward Yaxel Lendeborg (3) drives to the basket as Memphis Tigers forward Nicholas Jourdain (2) defends during the first half at Dickies Arena.
May 28, 2025

Prospects Picking College Over NBA Draft at Record Rate

The 2025 NBA draft has its lowest number of early entrants since 2015.
Tennessee pitcher Brayden Krenzel (34) pitches during a NCAA baseball game between the Tennessee Volunteers and Vanderbilt Commodores at Lindsey Nelson Stadium on May 11, 2025.
May 27, 2025

SEC Stranglehold on College Baseball Continues

SEC schools will host eight of the 16 regionals set to start this weekend.
May 22, 2025

Can Golf Emulate the College World Series Model?

Carlsbad, Calif., is hosting the event through 2028.