• Loading stock data...
Monday, June 23, 2025

The Problems With Lane Kiffin’s NIL ‘Salary Cap’ Idea

  • Ole Miss coach Lane Kiffin suggested salary caps to limit NIL payments like “what happens in professional sports.”
  • Kiffin’s idea isn’t just a misrepresentation of the realities in pro sports — it’s potentially illegal.
Dale Zanine-USA TODAY Sports

At SEC Media Days, Ole Miss coach Lane Kiffin suggested a potential solution to the complaint that NIL has created an unfair advantage for schools in football recruiting: a team-wide “salary cap” on NIL funds managed by the coach — à la professional sports leagues.

In his defense, Kiffin admitted he didn’t have a fleshed-out plan, but there are serious issues with his suggestion — even beyond the fact that it’s based on a problem that NIL didn’t create  (the disparity in college football resources existed before NIL).

The idea itself suggests using NIL as an athlete’s salary — the No.1 thing the NCAA is trying to prevent. 

What’s more, a salary cap in college sports, as it currently stands, might not even be legal.

Kiffin’s idea doesn’t actually represent how pro sports work, as attorney Darren Heitner pointed out on Twitter. The professional equivalent of NIL deals are pro athletes’ off-field endeavors, from businesses to endorsements — and there’s no limit to how much an athlete can make on those activities in any law or league rulebook.

The idea would also imply that NIL payments are salaries for playing on a particular team — which is completely antithetical to what the NCAA wanted them to be. Regardless of whether one is in favor of paying athletes salaries, NIL is supposed to be separate. 

There could be major legal fallout if the NCAA — or any school or conference — tries to limit the amount of money an athlete can make through NIL. 

The Alston decision, while not specifically dealing with NIL, suggested that the governing body has less power to set compensation limits than it previously thought. If it tries to set strict rules, it could be found in violation of antitrust law.

And as attorney Marc Edelman noted, salary caps are only legal in other sports because they have the agreement of a union. NCAA athletes currently don’t even have an official collective bargaining unit. 

Ironically, a more helpful solution would be legalizing paying college athletes salaries and deeming them employees, as attorney Mit Winter suggested

Athletes could form a union and collectively bargain, a governing body could set compensation limits for equity between teams, and NIL payments would no longer necessarily be a requisite for recruitment. 

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Mar 15, 2025; Fort Worth, TX, USA; UAB Blazers forward Yaxel Lendeborg (3) dribbles the ball upcourt against the North Texas Mean Green during the first half at Dickies Arena

NIL Is Shrinking the Pool of NBA Draft Entrants

Agents are now advising many players to stay in school.
Wisconsin cornerback Xavier Lucas (6) is shown during the first quarter of their game against South Dakota Saturday, September 7 , 2024 at Camp Randall Stadium in Madison, Wisconsin.

Wisconsin Sues Miami for ‘Tampering’ With Football Transfer

Xavier Lucas signed NIL deals in Madison before transferring to Miami.
Mar 30, 2025; Spokane, WA, USA; LSU Lady Tigers guard Flau'Jae Johnson (4) shoots against UCLA Bruins center Lauren Betts (51) during the second half of a Elite 8 NCAA Tournament basketball game at Spokane Arena.

Louisiana Sports Betting Set to Aid LSU and Other State Schools

Louisiana lawmakers have been creative in finding state money for NIL.
Jun 14, 2025; Omaha, Neb, USA; LSU Tigers starting pitcher Kade Anderson (32) pitches against the Arkansas Razorbacks during the seventh inning at Charles Schwab Field.

How College Athlete Buyouts Could Work in the Revenue-Sharing Era

The buyouts could put both players and schools at a disadvantage.

Featured Today

Apr 24, 2025; Green Bay, WI, USA; Penn State Nittany Lions defensive end Abdul Carter on the red carpet before the 2025 NFL Draft at Lambeau Field

‘More Is More’: The Elite Luxury Jewelers Decking Out Athletes

Meet the elite group of luxury designers crafting the biggest statement pieces.
Dec 5, 2024; Miami, FL, USA; FIFA president Gianni Infantino presents the FIFA Club World Cup trophy during the Club Word Cup draw at Telemundo Studios.
June 15, 2025

Revamped Club World Cup Is FIFA’s Billion-Dollar Gamble

The revamped soccer event debuts amid controversy.
Jun 10, 2025; Nashville, Tennessee, USA; United States head coach Mauricio Pochettino stands during the anthem against the Switzerland during the first at Geodis Park
June 14, 2025

Gold Cup Is Complicated for USMNT—but U.S. Soccer Has Its Eyes on..

Uncertain tournament success isn’t fazing forward-looking U.S. soccer.
Jan 24, 2017; Davidson, NC, USA; The Davidson Wildcats student section cheers during the first half against the Duquesne Dukes at McKillop Court at John M. Belk Arena. Davidson defeated Duquesne 74-60.
June 6, 2025

Every College Wants a Flashy Basketball GM Hire Right Now

The role is more important than ever, and the definition is ever-evolving.

Colleges Are Raising Student Fees to Pay for Athlete Revenue-Sharing

Schools are preparing to pay student athletes up to $20.5 million annually.
June 19, 2025

Omaha Delivers Again: LSU, Coastal Carolina Set for CWS Showdown

LSU and Coastal Carolina begin their three-game series Saturday.
Dec 27, 2024; San Diego, CA, USA; The Washington State Cougars ban perform during the second half at the Holiday Bowl at Snapdragon Stadium. Mandatory Credit:
June 23, 2025

Pac-12 Announces CBS As ‘Anchor’ in New Media-Rights Deal

The league may announce expansion before finalizing the rest of the package.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Ted Leonsis unpacks basketball’s global rise, media rights, and portfolio ownership.
Washington's Ben Gorsage, right, and Orland Park Sandburg's Mateo Ramiro-Garcia tangle at the start of the Class 3A state 800-meter run Saturday, May 31, 2025 at Eastern Illinois University in Charleston. Gorsage took third place, followed by Ramiro-Garcia in fourth.
June 19, 2025

Dozens of Olympic Sports Have Been Cut in Wake of House v...

Tennis, track and field, and swimming and diving appear heavily impacted.
Jun 16, 2025; Omaha, Neb, USA; Arkansas Razorbacks starting pitcher Gage Wood (14) celebrates completing a no hitter against the Murray State Racers at Charles Schwab Field.
June 17, 2025

College World Series Enters Cinderella Era

A series of upsets gives the fast-growing event a new look this year.
Texas' Sam Hurley watches the announcement of the competitors in the high jump at the 2023 NCAA outdoor track and field championships, June 9, 2023 at Mike A. Myers Stadium in Austin, Texas.
June 16, 2025

Revenue-Sharing Model Could Boost Programs in Football’s Shadow

“We’re not getting paid the millions of dollars that football is.”
UT
June 12, 2025

Zakai Zeigler Denied Injunction for Fifth Year at Tennessee

The former Tennessee guard sued the NCAA over potential lost NIL earnings.