Wednesday, September 16, 2026

The Making Of A Cinderella Team

March Madness is upon us! The greatest 2 and ½ week, single elimination, tournament begins today with 64 hopeful men’s college basketball programs. While teams are seeded 1 through 16 in four quadrants, each squad posses unique challenges and optimism on their road to the Final Four in San Antonio, TX.

What kind of DNA is composed to make a Cinderella team? First, they must be a lower seed. If the university is ranked 8th through 16th the odds are mightily stacked against them. Since 2000, only 50 men’s basketball teams seeded No. 8 or lower have made the Sweet 16.

In 2013 for example, the 15th seed Eagles from Florida Golf Coast University entered the tournament for the first time. They knocked off the No. 2 ranked Georgetown Hoyas, following that up besting the 7 seed, San Diego State Aztecs.

This was the first time a 15 seed had reached the Sweet 16. While “Dunk City” was an aberration, each year highly respected teams falter in the early rounds.

Another outlier comes from the Duke Blue Devils. One of the most decorated programs in all of college basketball, Coach K and his teams have been stung by Cinderella’s in recent years in between title runs. Look no further then 2012 and 2014 when Lehigh and Mercer won (as 15 and 14 seeds) respectively.

Each year a trend continues as well, with the infamous 12 defeating a 5 matchup. This time around, pundits are eyeing New Mexico State to top Clemson in a similar fashion.

No school outside of the power 5 conferences (ACC, Big 12, Big Ten, Pac-12, and SEC) has won the national title, but who is to say it won’t happen eventually?

Dave Holcomb of Cox Media Group believes a few schools will be susceptible this year.

“There isn’t one singular thing an underdog team must have to become a Cinderella, but I think one advantage the mid-major teams have when they do meet the blue blood programs is experience.”

Not necessarily NCAA Tournament experience, but teams (Butler and Wichita State) that went to the Final Four and other mid-major programs that advanced to the Sweet 16 usually have upperclassmen. Veteran leadership doesn’t necessarily trump talented one-and-dones, but it can give teams from smaller conferences an edge.

“To that point, Loyola Chicago is my Cinderella pick to make the Sweet 16. They create mismatches across the floor and could take advantage of the youth from both Miami and Tennessee (a potential second-round matchup). Miami will also be without arguably its best player in freshman guard Bruce Brown,” said Holcomb.

Covering the Big West Tournament last week in Anaheim, CA, it’s hard not to believe in a team like the 15th seeded Cal State Fullerton Titans. The experienced team won three games in successive nights; ousting rivals Long Beach State, No. 1 seeded UC Davis, and highly touted UC Irvine, who made the big dance two years prior.

Kyle Allman Jr. and Khalil Ahmad excelled, catapulting Cal State Fullerton into the NCAA Tournament. The guards, both juniors, combined to hit 12 of 18 shots in the second half and gave the Titans the Big West Tournament title in a wild 71-55 win over UC Irvine’s Anteaters at the Honda Center.

This was Fullerton’s first conference title since 2008, a decade since their last NCAA Tournament appearance.

https://twitter.com/BigWestMBB/status/972733119693336576

“I knew I had to play well,’’ said Allman. They gave me the jumper and I took it.”

Allman, the tournament MVP, scored 26 points on 8-of-16 shooting with four 3-pointers and Ahmad notched 23 points on 21 shots.

“They picked the right time to play their best game,” Fullerton coach Dedrique Taylor said after cutting down the nets. “They were completely unselfish. It’s a sense of validation and accomplishment, for the coaches, the kids, the administration and anyone else in the program.”

The Titans became the eighth different school in as many years to win the conference tournament. Two new schools, UC San Diego and CSU Bakersfield join the Big West next season.

https://twitter.com/BigWestMBB/status/972760698278223872

The 20 wins are the most for Fullerton since the 2011-12 team won 21. It’s been a significant turnaround for a program that was hit with NCAA penalties after the 2012 season and went into rebuild mode under Taylor. The Titans lost 20 or more games his first three seasons, and then went 17-15 in 2017.

“This is so surreal,” said Taylor. “There have been times this season when we’ve been inconsistent, but I think everything we went through added up to what we did tonight. I tell the guys if you play as hard as you can, this is the result.”

CSU Fullerton now travels to Detroit as a heavy underdog to face the No. 2 seed Purdue Boilermakers. Can they shock the world and slide on Cinderella’s slipper? This is what March Madness is all about.

Watch the tournament unfold starting today with games airing nationally on TBS, CBS, TNT, and truTV.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Sign up for
The Memo Newsletter

Get the biggest stories and best analysis on the business of sports delivered to your inbox twice every weekday and twice on weekends.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Lane Kiffin’s Roster Decision Reverberates Across Baton Rouge

The legal battle over eligibility was ever-present in Death Valley on Saturday.

One Clemson Football Player’s Fight for Eligibility—and a ‘Second Chance’

Tristan Smith will suit up for the Tigers against LSU this Saturday.
Dec 20, 2025; Oxford, MS, USA; Mississippi Rebels tight end Dae'Quan Wright (8) runs after the catch against the Tulane Green Wave during the first half of a game at Vaught-Hemingway Stadium

The Week That Broke College Football: Everything to Know

Football has been turned upside down as NFL players try to return.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

A Conversation with Ndamukong Suh & Jay Williams on the Business of Life After Sports

0:00

Featured Today

Oct 4, 2025; Tempe, AZ, USA; General action during the first period of the game between the Arizona State Sun Devils and the Penn State Nittany Lions at Mullett Arena

How Military-Style Workouts in College Sports Get Dangerous

For elite athletes, high-intensity training can be “very appealing.”
September 6, 2026

Is Carolyn Tisch Blodgett the Future Face of Giants Ownership?

Amid changes at top of Giants ownership, eyes are on Tisch Blodgett.
September 4, 2026

Wild Transfer Window Shows How Premier League Towers Over Soccer

Spending in England vastly outstripped the rest of Europe.
September 3, 2026

Teams Are Spending Millions to Build Luxury Locker Rooms

It’s a recruiting pitch, a retention tool, and a seven-figure line item.
September 1, 2026

High School Football Sidelines Are Clogged With Content Creators

Administrators call these amateur newcomers the “pajama paparazzi.”
Jay Williams Asset Class Front Office Sports
Exclusive

Jay Williams: ‘We All Participated’ in Cash Payments Before NIL

Williams said the payments came in “duffel bags” during the playful exchange.
September 15, 2026

Senators Stage Effort to Pass the Protect College Sports Act

An opposition coalition has formed to block the bill.
Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning (16) looks to throw over Ohio State Buckeyes linebacker Payton Pierce (26) during the NCAA football game at Darrell K Royal–Texas Memorial Stadium in Austin, Texas on Sept. 12, 2026. Texas won 24-23.
September 16, 2026

CFB Viewership Off to Hot Start After Texas–Ohio State Thriller

ABC averaged nearly 14 million viewers Saturday night.
Sponsored

Drew Weatherford’s Bet on the Youth Sports Economy

Drew Weatherford discusses investing across the youth, college and professional levels.
Nov 28, 2025; Austin, Texas, USA; Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning warms up before a game against the Texas A&M Aggies at Darrell K Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Scott Wachter-Imagn Images
September 15, 2026

Arch Manning Apologizes to Holly Rowe for Joking About AI Video

Rowe says that she accepted Manning’s apology.
Sep 12, 2026; Baton Rouge, Louisiana, USA; LSU Tigers head coach Lane Kiffin reacts to an intercept by Louisiana Tech Bulldogs during the first half at Tiger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Stephen Lew-Imagn Images
September 15, 2026

Oxford Bulking Up Police Presence for Lane Kiffin’s Return

Ole Miss coach Pete Golding asked fans to be rowdy but respectful.
Ohio State Buckeyes safety Jaylen McClain (8) reacts to a missed interception during the NCAA football game against the Texas Longhorns at Darrell K Royal–Texas Memorial Stadium in Austin, Texas on Sept. 12, 2026. Texas won 24-23.
September 14, 2026

How the 12-Team CFP Is Treating Ohio State and Oregon Differently

Meanwhile, Oklahoma’s and Oregon’s playoff odds took significant hits.
September 13, 2026

Texas Tops AP Poll As SEC Asserts Early Dominance Over Big Ten

The Longhorns topped the latest poll after their dramatic comeback win.