• Loading stock data...
Friday, February 7, 2025

The House v. NCAA Settlement Looks Like a CBA. But It Isn’t

  • Several industry stakeholders tell FOS athletes aren’t adequately represented in the House v. NCAA settlement.
  • The settlement includes elements normally negotiated through only collective bargaining.
Clemson kicker Hogan Morton (47) and kicker Quinn Castner (36) warm up before kickoff with Georgia Tech Nov 11, 2023; Clemson, South Carolina, USA; at Memorial Stadium.
Ken Ruinard / USA TODAY NETWORK

The House v. NCAA settlement has been presented as a major step toward increasing college athletes’ economic rights—and many industry stakeholders agree the revenue-sharing component is a particularly huge win for players.

But the settlement goes far beyond the scope of the original lawsuit, covering issues normally negotiated through only players’ unions. Front Office Sports spoke with several industry stakeholders who say the settlement is actually attempting to be a collective bargaining agreement—despite the fact athletes don’t have a union to negotiate on their behalf. 

“This settlement is a new set of guardrails,” Jim Cavale, founder of athlete advocacy group Athletes.org, tells FOS. “And if the athletes aren’t involved in negotiating … it’s unfair. And we’re going to end up right back where we are.”

When players enter into a CBA in the pros, a professional union represents them. But in this case, lawyers for a specific set of plaintiffs are negotiating the terms of the settlement. The named plaintiffs chose their lawyers, of course, but the rest of Division I athletes—who would be impacted by the settlement in some way—did not. 

As a result, athletes are uninformed about the terms of the settlement, say lawyers and athlete advocates, and many are unaware that a settlement conversation potentially impacting them is taking place at all. Groups of players have submitted multiple objections—but most are already suing the NCAA, and therefore more informed than the average athlete.

“The athletes who it’s impacting the most had no say in it,”  Russell White, president of The Collective Association, tells FOS. “They had little to no input. Most of them don’t understand what’s in it, and what that actually means for them as a current athlete or an incoming athlete. And I think that’s a shame.”

If fewer athletes are aware of the settlement, there are fewer opportunities to challenge it. “I think that’s intentional,” Cavale says. “I think the schools don’t expect the athletes to inform themselves on this.” 

Fairness is just one issue. Without a collective bargaining process, several elements of the settlement may not withstand future legal challenges.

Take the cap on revenue sharing. The settlement uses a formula to determine the maximum amount of money a school can share with athletes (around $22 million). It’s reminiscent of a salary cap, which usually isn’t legal under antitrust law without collective bargaining. Third parties, or athletes who opt out of the deal, could challenge that ceiling in future litigation, says sports attorney Mit Winter. 

The settlement would also try to curb the power of NIL (name, image, and likeness) collectives by allowing a third party to police NIL deals that are more than $600—a restriction that doesn’t exist anywhere in U.S. pro sports, and which lawyers and collective operators expect to be challenged in court.

Plaintiff lawyers have said in court documents that the settlement isn’t a CBA, and that it could be renegotiated if players can one day form a union. They’ve also reiterated that the settlement doesn’t protect the NCAA from all types of lawsuits in the future, particularly those related to athlete employment status. 

But the NCAA, for its part, wants to turn the House settlement into a permanent governing document for D-I college sports: The organization is urging Congress to codify it into law, and add other provisions that would keep the NCAA from having to reform further. “This settlement is also a road map for college sports leaders and Congress to ensure this uniquely American institution can continue to provide unmatched opportunity for millions of students,” the five commissioners and NCAA president Charlie Baker said in a joint statement in May.

But short of a federal law, the NCAA won’t be able to skirt around negotiating with players for much longer. Sports attorney and New York Law School professor Dan Lust tells FOS: “This settlement is incapable of replacing what is a collective action by a union.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Feb 6, 2025; New Orleans, LA, USA; Recording artist Kendrick Lamar poses for a photo during a press conference for the Super Bowl LIX Halftime Show at Media Center

Kendrick Lamar’s High-Risk, High-Reward Super Bowl Halftime Show

The performance is a boon for the league—but not without complications.
Maverick Carter

Singapore, Saudi PIF Among Investors in Int’l Basketball League

The league is advised by Maverick Carter, a longtime friend of LeBron James.

Featured Today

‘Ultimate Throwback’: The Unimpeachable Cool of Hartford Whalers Gear

Nostalgia and street cred have driven a consistent frenzy for merch.
January 20, 2024; Santa Clara, CA, USA; Kristin Juszczyk, wife of San Francisco 49ers fullback Kyle Juszczyk (44), before a 2024 NFC divisional round game against the Green Bay Packers at Levi's Stadium.
February 1, 2025

The New WAGs: Sports Wives Building Business Empires

Athletes’ wives and girlfriends are bucking stereotypes and cashing in.
Feb 3, 2019; Berkeley, CA, USA; California Golden Bears mascot dances on the court during a stoppage in play in the second half against the Stanford Cardinal at Haas Pavilion.
January 31, 2025

The Toll of Bicoastal Travel on New ACC Members Cal and Stanford

Cal and Stanford face missed flights, chaotic sleep schedules, and academic demands.
January 28, 2025

It’s Starting to Pay to Be Good at Cornhole

American Cornhole League players made $7.7 million in 2024.
NCAA flag

NCAA Bans Trans Athletes From Women’s Sports After Trump Order

The move was expected after a Trump executive order.
Oregon defensive lineman Derrick Harmon pressures Oregon State wide receiver Jeremiah Noga as the Oregon State Beavers host the Oregon Ducks Saturday, Sept. 14, 2024 at Reser Stadium in Corvallis, Ore.
exclusive
February 4, 2025

ESPN, Fox, CBS All Open to Media Rights Package With Pac-12

One source characterized media rights negotiations as “productive.”
The NCAA logo on the field in the closing second of the Anderson University inaugural football game with St. Andrew's University on Spero Financial Field at Melvin and Dollie Younts Stadium at Anderson University in Anderson, S.C. Saturday, September 7, 2024. Anderson won 51-14.
February 4, 2025

At Least 250 Athletes Have Opted Out of the House v. NCAA..

At least 250 opted out of the settlement, FOS can confirm.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
Florida State Seminoles head coach Leonard Hamilton watches his team from the sideline. The Florida State Seminoles hosted the Virginia Tech Hokies for a menÕs basketball game Wednesday, Jan. 29, 2025.
February 3, 2025

FSU’s Leonard Hamilton to Step Down As NIL Lawsuit Unfolds

Six former FSU men’s basketball players sued Hamilton in December.
Oct 26, 2024; Madison, Wisconsin, USA; Wisconsin Badgers cornerback Nyzier Fourqurean (3) celebrates following a tackle during the second quarter against the Penn State Nittany Lions at Camp Randall Stadium.
January 31, 2025

Another Lawsuit Seeks to Challenge the NCAA’s Eligibility Clock

Vanderbilt QB Diego Pavia recently sued the NCAA over similar eligibility standards.
Western Oregon women's basketball players allege abuse.
January 30, 2025

Western Oregon Women’s Basketball Players File $28 Million Lawsuit Claiming Coach Abuse

Players say school officials ignored their complaints of physical abuse and bullying.
Nov 23, 2024; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Colorado linebacker LaVonta Bentley (20) during gets set at his position during the 1st quarter between the Kansas Jayhawks and the Colorado Buffaloes at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium.
January 30, 2025

House v. NCAA Objections Highlight Three Major Concerns

It’s not all smooth sailing into college sports’ revenue-sharing era.