• Loading stock data...
Saturday, July 20, 2024
Join us this September for Tuned In Request to Attend

State Legislatures Are In Attack Mode Against the NCAA’s NIL Rules

  • New NIL bills and laws hamstring the NCAA’s ability to enforce core NIL rules.
  • The latest bill passed on Thursday in New York is awaiting Gov. Kathy Hochul’s signature.
Mar 8, 2023; New York, NY, USA; St. John's Red Storm guard AJ Storr (2) shoots in the first half at Madison Square Garden.
Robert Deutsch-USA TODAY Sports

For the past two years, states have been crafting various name, image, and likeness laws that would give their states a competitive edge in the NIL landscape.

But there’s something different about the latest batch of bills and amendments: They’re making it illegal for the NCAA to enforce some of its own NIL rules. 

Pete Bevacqua and Jack Swarbrick

Ready For Their Closeup: Colleges Turning To Sports TV Executives

Notre Dame is the latest school to poach from television.
June 9, 2023

The main regulation legislatures are attacking is one published in 2022 NCAA documents, which says athletic department employees can’t organize or “facilitate” specific deals for athletes. If the NCAA tries to punish schools for their involvement in deals, it could be subject to litigation.

  • In May, the Oklahoma legislature passed a new NIL law prohibiting the NCAA from punishing schools for flouting certain NIL rules.
  • Yesterday, lawmakers in New York passed a similar bill that awaits Gov. Kathy Hochul’s signature. 
  • Multiple other states have bills in various stages of the legislative process, including Colorado, Missouri, Texas, and Arkansas.

The New York bill includes almost word-for-word language, the same as the Oklahoma law. “NCAA shall not prevent a college from … identifying, facilitating, enabling, or supporting opportunities for a student-athlete to earn compensation for the student-athlete name, image, and likeness.” Conferences are also prohibited from punishing schools for taking these actions. 

All schools have to abide by the law that is most superior: national law is most powerful, then state law, then private association rules. There’s no federal NIL law, so states now have power over the NCAA. 

“Regardless of what might happen with the NIL Summit in Congress or what the NCAA might do, right now your state law gives you that clear runway — which New York has never had before,” sports attorney Dan Lust, who represents NIL collectives and schools in New York, told Front Office Sports.

St. John’s provides an interesting case study for the ever-changing NIL landscape. 

In the fall of 2021, the athletic department organized an opportunity for every Red Storm athlete to sign a NIL deal with a company called FitBiomics (founded by a Red Storm alum). The deal was completely kosher at the time, as no New York State law prevented a school from facilitating a NIL deal. 

Once state legislatures realized their schools could get a leg up in NIL by being more involved in the process, they started amending or repealing their own NIL laws that prohibited school involvement.

But in 2022, the NCAA published “clarifications” to its NIL regulations, stating that schools cannot “engage in negotiations on behalf of an NIL entity or a student-athlete to secure specific NIL opportunities.” Under this policy, the NCAA could punish St. John’s for its TK deal, even though it was technically legal in New York State.

But as soon as Hochul signs the latest bill into law, St. John’s may resume organizing deals for its athletes. It’s not just legal in New York state to do so — the state authorities will attack the NCAA if the NCAA tries to sanction St. John’s for doing so. 

It’s this particular brand of control that the NCAA is hoping to regain by pestering Congress to pass a federal law. 

This week, Capitol Hill was overrun by the who’s who of college sports, from NCAA President Charlie Baker and SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey to countless athletic department officials, university presidents, and NIL collectives — all advocating for their own interest. Conveniently, Arizona State held a college sports summit in D.C. to explore the future of NIL and the industry at large.

But despite multiple bills circulating on both sides of the aisle, there’s no end in sight. For now, the states still have all the power.

Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

The Road to the Return of ‘EA Sports College Football’

This summer, the biggest development in college sports is virtual.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

‘EA Sports College Football 25’: It’s More Than a Game


Featured Today

Jan 7, 2024; Nashville, Tennessee, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Calvin Ridley (0) reacts after scoring a touchdown against the Tennessee Titans during the first half at Nissan Stadium.
July 14, 2024

Without Hard-Line Bans, Pro Athletes and Personnel Will Keep Betting on Sports

Penalties often aren’t stringent or consistent enough to deter banned behavior.
Oct 2, 2021; Miami Gardens, FL, USA; NFL commissioner Roger Goddell speaks during the Don Shula Celebration of Life at Hard Rock Stadium.
July 13, 2024

The NFL Is Confident It Can Overturn the Sunday Ticket Verdict

The league may have good reason to believe it can win.
July 8, 2024

NFLPA Report Cards Have Become the ‘Talk of the Locker Room’ Across..

NFLPA report cards have become the ‘talk of the locker room.’

Pac-12 Media Days Evolve Into a Cocktail Party at the Bellagio

The two-team ‘zombie conference’ is still hosting a football media day.
July 9, 2024

Arch Manning Will Be in EA’s ‘College Football 25’ After All

The NCAA’s most famous backup had previously opted out.
July 9, 2024

Big 12’s New Era Kicks Off: Expansion, Private Equity, and Global Ambitions

The new 16-team conference is holding media days in Las Vegas.

TopSpin 2K25 Brings the Legends of Tennis to Your Living Room

2K sports is reviving a classic with TopSpin 2K25.
July 8, 2024

Dan Hurley Finally Has New UConn Deal After Dramatic Offseason

Hurley is now the second-highest-paid coach in college basketball. 
July 7, 2024

The New College Sports Insiders Are Graphic Designers

Joe Tipton and Hayes Fawcett have become premier news-breakers on social media.
July 2, 2024

Navigating College Football’s 2024 Realignment Landscape: What’s Next?

Conferences are officially adding schools this summer.
April 13, 2024; Columbus, Ohio, USA; Ohio State Buckeyes wide receiver Emeka Egbuka (2) catches a pass for the scarlet team while defended by cornerback Jordan Hancock (7) of the grey team during the first half of the LifeSports Spring Game at Ohio Stadium on Saturday.
July 1, 2024

As NIL Turns Three, Collectives and Football Still Control the Industry

Collectives dominate NIL, and football makes up most of collective budgets.