• Loading stock data...
Wednesday, April 2, 2025
Nominations Are Open for Front Office Sports Honors! Submit Now

Stage Set For Federal Labor Decision on College Athlete Employment Status

  • On Wednesday, a hearing concluded in the potentially historic case regarding the Dartmouth men’s basketball team’s attempt to unionize.
  • The next step: The NLRB’s regional director will issue a written decision.
A hearing concluded in the NLRB hearing over when Dartmouth men's basketball players can unionize.
Doug Austin/Dartmouth Athletics

On Wednesday, a hearing concluded in the potentially historic case regarding the Dartmouth men’s basketball team’s attempt to unionize through the National Labor Relations Board. The petition for unionization, supported by the Service Employees International Union, was first filed in September.

During four days of testimony, lawyers for both athletes and the school argued whether the players could be considered employees of their school — and therefore whether the NCAA’s entire amateurism model is void. 

If the athletes are ultimately allowed to form a union, they’ll set a new legal precedent for schools nationwide. 

In the coming weeks, the NLRB’s regional director will issue a written decision about whether athletes can go forward with a union election.

If allowed to hold a union election, athletes will likely cast their ballots at some point before Dec. 25, attorneys agreed. But both sides will have the attempt to file an appeal — meaning the issue may not be decided for months.

The Dartmouth lawyers used multiple witnesses — all of whom were Dartmouth employees, and at least one of whom was a current athletics department employee — to establish that college athletes are not professionals. 

As an Ivy League school, Dartmouth operates somewhat differently than other Division I schools: Ivy League schools offer more restrictions on eligibility and do not offer athletic scholarships. They also make much less revenue than more visible Division I programs. 

Dartmouth’s lawyers attempted to use this distinction to show that Dartmouth’s men’s basketball players are not treated like university employees, even if other D-I athletes may be.

Dartmouth’s witnesses spoke about ways athletes are considered “students” first — like how they’re expected to prioritize attending class over practice — and how amateur club sports are similar to varsity athletics. 

During a rebuttal at the end of the trial, Dartmouth’s lawyers also attempted to redirect any blame about the “amateurism” designation the Ivy League and NCAA by showing that Dartmouth simply enforces rules imposed upon it by those entities.

The athletes’ lawyer focused almost his entire case on the testimony of current men’s basketball player Cade Haskins. 

Haskins described the realities of playing at the Division I level: that athletes’ schedules are completely controlled by coaches while on the road; that they spend at least 20 hours a week on their sport; and that they’re required to attend fundraising events for the athletic department and sign away their name, image, and likeness rights for the school to use in several instances. 

He also addressed the athletic department’s claim that athletes prioritize going to class over games.

“In reality, is that what happens?” the players’ lawyer asked him.

He replied, simply: “No.”

During cross-examination, the athletes’ lawyer was able to get multiple school officials to concede that it is possible for a student to also be an employee of the university. A particularly strong example: team managers, who are students paid to work in the athletic department.

Dartmouth men’s basketball players are more likely to succeed in their effort in this current climate, where the NLRB’s general counsel has stated publicly that she believes many college athletes should be employees.

They are also building on a case where Northwestern football players attempted to unionize in 2014. The NLRB ultimately declined to rule on the case on a technicality — not because it found the players to be amateurs.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Yankees RSN, Comcast Reach Deal After FCC Pressure

The deal keeps the regional sports network on an expanded basic tier.
Mar 30, 2025; Atlanta, GA, USA; Auburn Tigers forward Johni Broome (4), left, guard Tahaad Pettiford (0) and head coach Bruce Pearl celebrate with teammates after winning the South Regional final of the 2025 NCAA tournament against the Michigan State Spartans at State Farm Arena.

SEC Earns Record $70M in Men’s March Madness Units

The NCAA distributes payouts based on participation and prowess in the tournament.

Featured Today

Mar 26, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Los Angeles Lakers forward LeBron James (23) in the first half Indiana Pacers at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.

The Creator Behind the LeBron ‘Glazing’ Trend Sweeping TikTok

FOS spoke to TikTok user OkaySpade who made the original song.
Seattle Kraken
April 1, 2025

Samantha Holloway Is Seattle’s NHL Present—and Hopeful NBA Future

Samantha Holloway is steering the Kraken and hoping to revive pro hoops.
Brehanna Daniels
March 31, 2025

NASCAR Pit Crew Member Brehanna Daniels Didn’t Know She’d Be a Trailblazer

The first Black female tire changer didn’t know she’d be a trailblazer.
Columbia, SC - February 16, 2025 - Colonial Life Arena: Rebecca Lobo and Ryan Ruocco during a regular season game.
March 30, 2025

Inside Ryan Ruocco’s Rapid Rise to ESPN’s Top Voice of Women’s Hoops

The top voice became “quickly addicted” to calling the women’s game.
Mar 22, 2025; Providence, RI, USA; McNeese State Cowboys manager Amir Khan before a second round men’s NCAA Tournament game against the Purdue Boilermakers at Amica Mutual Pavilion
April 1, 2025

Inside the 24-Hour NIL March Madness Deals

Some of the most viral partnerships come together overnight.
April 1, 2025

Women’s Elite Eight Ratings Down 53%, Still Top Pre–Caitlin Clark Years

UConn wasn’t in the most-watched game for the first time.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
Paige Bueckers
March 31, 2025

Paige Bueckers Extends College Career Another Week

Bueckers advancing is a win for UConn, the Big East, and ESPN.
Olivia Miles
March 31, 2025

Top WNBA Draft Prospect Opts For Transfer Portal Instead

Olivia Miles had been projected as a top-2 pick.
Trae Young
March 31, 2025

Trae Young Is Latest NBA Star to Take On 7-Figure College Job

Young is the latest NBA star to join the college arms race. 
March 30, 2025

Missing Madness: All No. 1 Seeds in Men’s Final Four, First Time..

The results show the impact of NIL and the transfer portal.