• Loading stock data...
Monday, October 27, 2025
Want a chance to win $250 and free FOS gear? Take our quick reader survey. Take the survey here

Question of NCAA Athletes as Employees Comes Under Focus

  • Oral arguments will be heard in a federal class action case called Johnson v. NCAA on Wednesday.
  • Judges will consider whether athletes can be considered university employees.
The NCAA is attempting to throw out employment case.
Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

On Wednesday, the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals will consider a challenge to the core of the NCAA’s entire business model.

Oral arguments will be heard in a federal class action case called Johnson v. NCAA, in which a group of athletes is suing several schools and the NCAA alleging they should be considered university employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act, and therefore are entitled to minimum wage and other U.S. labor protections.

This hearing is a pivotal moment in the case, which could ultimately lead to the NCAA’s demise.

Lawyers for the NCAA and schools have attempted to get the case dismissed on the grounds that athletes should be classified as amateurs, and not employees. Wednesday’s arguments will address this question specifically — a rare type of appeal called an “interlocutory appeal,” which reviews a decision made by a lower court judge in the middle of a case, rather than the final verdict.

The appeals court will likely not issue a verdict for at least a few months, Boise State sports law professor Sam Ehrlich told Front Office Sports. 

A win for the athletes would mean that the case would go back down to the district court to proceed to the discovery phase. 

“This obviously would be the worst-case scenario for the NCAA,” Ehrlich said. It legitimizes the possibility of athletes being employees under federal law, and it opens up the governing body to have to make private documents public during discovery.

But athletes wouldn’t become employees right away. The case would have to reach a final verdict.

Another scenario: The appeals court could issue a narrow agreement, Ehrlich noted, stating that only some of the athletes in the plaintiff class qualify — for example, drawing a line between revenue and non-revenue sports.

A win for the NCAA, however, would lead to the case being dismissed.

Legal experts have told FOS that overturning an interlocutory appeal is no easy feat — sort of like overturning a call on the NFL field. The status quo usually stands.

A component of the Supreme Court’s ruling in NCAA v. Alston invited further legal challenges to the NCAA’s business model on the grounds that they violate the Sherman Antitrust Act. 

“The NCAA’s business model would be flatly illegal in almost any other industry in America,” Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote in his concurring opinion.

But in the past, other federal courts, like the Ninth Circuit in California, have agreed that college athletes aren’t employees.

The NCAA Puts the Future of Amateurism In Congress’ Hands

The NCAA punted on recommendations for regulating NIL.
January 4, 2023

Either way, expect the NCAA to not rest until it gets a favorable verdict — including appealing the case all the way up to the Supreme Court.

The NCAA did not respond to a request for comment. A lawyer for the plaintiffs did not have a comment to provide in advance of the arguments.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Oct 11, 2025; Tallahassee, Florida, USA; Florida State Seminoles head coach Mike Norvell after losing the game to the Pittsburgh Panthers at Doak S. Campbell Stadium.

CFB’s Chaotic (and Pricey) Coaching Carousel Only Getting Started

Firings have already accounted for roughly $116 million.
Oct 16, 2025; Salt Lake City, Utah, USA; Portland Trail Blazers head coach Chauncey Billups gives instructions to his team during the first half against the Utah Jazz at Delta Center.

Chauncey Billups Is Rare Pro Coach Involved in Gambling Scandal

The recent string of gambling scandals have centered on athletes.

Featured Today

September 21, 2025; Santa Clara, California, USA; NFL commissioner Roger Goodell before the game between the San Francisco 49ers and the Arizona Cardinals at Levi's Stadium

NFL Fall Meeting: 7 Big Topics Among Team Owners 

Media, facilities, and labor highlight some of the key areas of concern.
Ohio State Buckeyes running back Isaiah West (32) runs the ball in the second half at Camp Randall Stadium on Saturday, Oct. 18, 2025 in Madison, Wisconsin
October 25, 2025

NIL Has Birthed a Third-Party Cottage Industry—and It’s a Mess

There’s no limit to how much players can make from NIL deals.
Christie's
October 21, 2025

Lou Gehrig’s $4M Jersey and the Exploding Sports Memorabilia Market

An ultra-rare sports collection is about to hit the auction block.
@chef__tezz/Instagram
October 19, 2025

Inside the NFL’s Private Chef Network

Private chefs are the unsung architects of player performance.
Tigers Head Coach Brian Kelly, LSU Tigers take on the Texas A&M Aggies. October 25, 2025; Baton Rouge, Louisiana, USA; at Tiger Stadium. Saturday, Oct. 25, 2025.

College Football Coach Buyouts Are Not What They Seem

LSU will likely not have to pay Kelly the $53 million he has left on his contract.
October 26, 2025

Revenue-Sharing Era’s New Powers: Indiana, Georgia Tech, and Vandy

Indiana is the most notable, having ascended to No. 2.
October 26, 2025

LSU Ends Brian Kelly Era, $53M Buyout Negotiations Underway

The Tigers fell to 5–3 after losing to Texas A&M.
Sponsored

How HOKA is Reimagining the NIL Relationship

Fans can now follow their favorite golfers and experience every marquee moment at the Ryder Cup — thanks to innovation from T-Mobile.
October 26, 2025

Sarkisian, Kiffin Address Rumors As Coaching Carousel Spins Again

Reports are rampant about the coaches taking new jobs.
Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia (2) celebrates following the game between Vanderbilt University and Louisiana State University at FirstBank Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., Saturday, Oct. 18, 2025
exclusive
October 24, 2025

Diego Pavia Is Trying to Kill NCAA JUCO Eligibility Rules for Good

Vandy’s QB is amending his own lawsuit to encompass all NCAA athletes.
Jun 10, 2025; Eugene, OR, USA; A NCAA logo flag at the NCAA Track and Field Championships at Hayward Field.
October 23, 2025

College Athletes Can Bet on Pro Sports Starting in November

An NBA player and coach were charged Thursday in a sports betting investigation.
Tony Vitello
October 22, 2025

Tony Vitello’s Stunning MLB Jump Comes With $3M Tennessee Buyout

Vitello heads to San Francisco after winning a national championship in 2024.