• Loading stock data...
Monday, February 26, 2024

NFL Argues Merits of Jon Gruden’s Lawsuit in Nevada’s Highest Court

  • NFL makes one final push to get Gruden’s case compelled to arbitration at Nevada Supreme Court appeals hearing.
  • Gruden sued the NFL in October 2021 after leaked emails led to his abrupt resignation as head coach of the Raiders.
Jon Gruden
Rudy Jaquez-KTNV

The NFL’s two-year quest to shift former Las Vegas Raiders coach Jon Gruden’s lawsuit to arbitration came to a pivotal point on Wednesday. 

In a hearing in front of a three-judge panel of the Nevada Supreme Court that spanned about a half-hour, outside league attorney Kannon Shanmugam argued that Gruden’s legal arguments “lack merit”—and that the civil case should be compelled to the league’s arbitration process overseen by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell. Gruden’s lawyer, Adam Hosmer-Henner, countered that Gruden’s 10-year, $100 million contract lacked “a valid and enforceable” language that prevented Gruden’s lawsuit from moving forward. 

To this point, the NFL had lost both its bids to either get Gruden’s lawsuit dismissed or moved into the league’s arbitration system, which—unlike the courts—is shrouded in secrecy and forbids parties from discussing the proceedings. District Court Judge Nancy Allf denied the NFL’s arbitration motion on Oct. 17, 2022. The NFL signaled it would appeal a day later, and the case had stagnated before Wednesday’s hearing. 

It’s expected to take several weeks for Justices Elissa F. Cadish, Kristina Pickering, and Linda M. Bell to reach a verdict on the NFL’s appeal. 

“This is one of those rare arguments where I’m not sure who’s going to come away as the victor,” sports law attorney Daniel Wallach told Front Office Sports. “The justices peppered both sides with questions on some legitimate vulnerabilities in each side’s arguments.”

Gruden, who attended the hearing, sued the NFL in October 2021, days after he resigned as head coach of the Raiders after the racist, misogynistic, and homophobic emails became public. Gruden alleged that the NFL was the source of the emails from the account of then-Washington Commanders executive Bruce Allen, correspondence gathered by the league’s first outside investigation into numerous allegations of a toxic workplace that existed within the team. 

“Former Raiders coach Jon Gruden brings unsubstantiated claims against the NFL and its commissioner, claiming that they are somehow responsible for his resignation after the publication of … emails that he wrote and broadly circulated, emails that are too vile to read out in open court,” Shanmugam said during the hearing. “When Gruden entered into his contract with the Raiders—the richest coaching contract in NFL history—he agreed to two broad arbitration provisions that cover all disputes arising out of his employment agreement or involving conduct detrimental to the league.”

The fallout once the cache of emails was published led to Gruden’s resignation and restarted inquiries into the Commanders and owner Dan Snyder. The NFL launched a second probe, and Congress and others began investigating Snyder,  threatening his grasp of the franchise before he agreed to sell it for a record $6.05 billion last year. 

Gruden settled with the Raiders in the weeks after his resignation. The lawsuit seeks the balance of Gruden’s contract, which is unknown since the settlement amount has not been made public. 

Hosmer-Henner argued that Judge Allf “made a factual finding” that Gruden was not provided with the NFL Constitution and Bylaws when he signed his deal with the Raiders in January 2018. That contract, Hosmer-Henner said, was negotiated between the team and Gruden’s agent (Bob Lamonte), and “there’s nothing in the record indicating that he had counsel present when he signed it or that it was explained” the arbitration provision to him. 

“There is not a presumption in favor of arbitration, and there is not a valid and enforceable contract,” Hosmer-Henner said. “This court is being asked to reverse Judge Allf on the basis that there was a buried paragraph in a 450-page document that [Gruden] never saw, couldn’t negotiate, and had no opportunity to modify while the NFL preserved the unilateral ability to change that.”

There’s nothing preventing Gruden from being hired to coach in the NFL, but outside owners and front offices are hesitant to hire him given the views expressed in those emails. The emails were exchanged between 2010 and 2018 while Gruden was still ESPN’s Monday Night Football in-booth analyst. 

Gruden wasn’t ousted after a league investigation. Goodell didn’t officially find Gruden to be in violation of the “conduct detrimental” provision in Section 8.3 of the NFL Constitution—a point made at the appeals hearing. 

“That arbitrator is limited to the decision of whether it is the opinion of the commissioner that [there was] conduct is detrimental to the league,” Hosmer-Henner said. “That clause has never been enforced in a situation like this, and nor can it be enforced because it’s fully illusory and one-sided.

“It would allow…the commissioner to determine that a private divorce proceeding involved conduct detrimental, and thus was referred to arbitration, that a sexual harassment charge against a member of the league involved conduct detrimental was going to be subject to arbitration.”

Gruden attended New Orleans Saints practices over the summer. Saints coach Dennis Allen told reporters at the time that Gruden “has a lot of experience with [quarterback] Derek [Carr]” and “thought it was really beneficial” for the team. NOLA.com reported earlier this week that Gruden attended a team meeting ahead of the Saints’ Week 17 game in Tampa, dined with Saints GM Mickey Loomis, and is under consideration for a position within the organization. 

If Judge Allf’s decision is upheld, the case will revert to the district court in Las Vegas, but Allf won’t be the one presiding—Allf announced her retirement, and her last day on the bench is on Thursday. Another judge will take over the case if the Nevada Supreme Court decides in Gruden’s favor. 

“Gruden hasn’t been able to take a single deposition and hasn’t been able to [file] a single discovery request because this case has been frozen in this battle over arbitrability for roughly two years,” Wallach said. “For the NFL, this just underscores why the arbitration clauses are so powerful because even litigating their validity ties the case up for several years.”

Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Enough for Both? White Sox, Bears Ramp Up Push for Stadium Funds

MLB club begins to escalate its ask for taxpayer dollars.
Superdome Super Bowl

Superdome Renovations to Finish in Time for Super Bowl LIX

Renovations will total $500 million and have been ongoing for years.
Michigan defensive lineman Kenneth Grant celebrates a sack on Washington quarterback Michael Penix Jr. in the second quarter during the College Football Playoff national championship game against Washington at NRG Stadium in Houston, Texas on Monday, Jan. 8, 2024.

Pay-for-Play Is Here: Federal Judge Says NCAA Cannot Enforce Any NIL Rules

The ruling effectively allows pay-for-play to go forward uninhibited.
NFL salary cap

NFL Salary Cap Sees Historic Spike Ahead of 2024 Season

Each franchise was allotted $255.4M, which is a $30M increase for each team.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

The Shady Business of Fake Sports News


Featured Today

Sham Gods: The Rapidly Growing World of Sports Impersonators on X

Fake Schefters and Wojs, fabricated trade demands, and borrowed profile pictures.
Sep 24, 2023; Oakland, California, USA; A general view of the Oakland Athletics dugout after the game against the Detroit Tigers at Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum.
February 24, 2024

Murky Future: Everything You Need to Know About the A’s Move to Las Vegas

Breaking down one of the most drawn-out, multifaceted sagas in sports.
February 18, 2024

Sabrina-Steph Wasn’t the ‘Battle of the Sexes’—But It Was Part of the Bigger War

The competition could play a factor in increasing the WNBA’s media value.
NASCAR Cup Series driver Bubba Wallace (23), in a Star Wars rebel alliance X-wing fighter pilot-inspired race suit, motions to the crowd to get louder during the driver introductions for the Cup Series Championship race at Phoenix Raceway in Avondale on Nov. 5, 2023.
February 17, 2024

Celebrity Owners, International Ambitions, and $7B Media Deals: Welcome to the New NASCAR

NASCAR boldly keeps pace with the increasingly competitive sports and entertainment world.


Powered By

Careers in Sports

Looking for a new job? Check out these featured listings and search for openings all over the world.
Finance Manager
New York, NY
Senior Technical Artist - Sports Technology
EA Sports
Orlando, FL
Assistant Manager, Affiliate Operations
Portland, OR
February 6, 2024

DraftKings Sues Ex-Exec Over ‘Secret Plan’ to Aid Fanatics

Complaint alleges new Fanatics VP “improperly” encouraged DraftKings subordinates to depart.
February 7, 2024

Fanatics Betting Exec Calls DraftKings Allegations ‘Wrong and Disappointing,’ ‘False and Fabricated’

New VIP betting chief refutes accusations of ‘secret plan’ to steal customer info.

Live Sports Are Now High-Tech Experiences

Oracle is leading the technology revolution happening in stadiums across the world.
Brett Favre
February 5, 2024

Mississippi Auditor Sues Brett Favre Over Unpaid Interest Tied to Welfare Scandal

Shad White, who has spearheaded the case against Favre in Mississippi, seeks $729,000.
Ole Miss Lane Kiffin
January 31, 2024

Federal Judge Dismisses $40M Lawsuit Against Ole Miss Football Coach Lane Kiffin

Judge cites lack of evidence of alleged discrimination.
January 31, 2024

Nike Supply Chain Woes: Police Recover $5M in Stolen Merchandise

Nike thefts continue in SoCal as police make arrest, find $5 million in product.
Brett Favre
January 30, 2024

Brett Favre’s Defamation Case Against State Auditor to Proceed

Judge denies Mississippi State Auditor Shad White’s motion to dismiss on Thursday.