• Loading stock data...
Friday, May 16, 2025
Law

Could Jon Gruden’s Work With Saints Impact NFL Lawsuit?

  • Gruden visited New Orleans Saints practices as his lawsuit remains on hold pending an NFL appeal.
  • The NFL argued again in a filing this week that the lawsuit should be compelled to arbitration.
Jon Gruden
Kelley L Cox-USA TODAY Sports

Jon Gruden’s appearance at New Orleans Saints practices a couple weeks could factor into future legal arguments in his lawsuit against the NFL. 

In the latest filing by the NFL as part of its appeal related to Gruden’s lawsuit against the league, those emails allow NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell to declare the exchanges to trigger the “conduct detrimental” language laid out in the NFL Constitution and Bylaws. 

And, in turn, the NFL argued that the case should be compelled to arbitration in the reply brief filed in Nevada State Supreme Court on Tuesday. 

“[Gruden] entered his record-setting employment agreement with full knowledge of the Commissioner’s role in the NFL and express approval that he may oversee any future arbitration,”  Maximilien D. Fetaz, one of the NFL’s lawyers, wrote in the brief. 

That raises a couple questions: If the leaked racist, misogynistic, and homophobic emails were enough to trigger the resignation of Gruden as head coach of the Las Vegas Raiders in October 2021, why was there no apparent punishment of Gruden by the NFL? And could the NFL have even punish Gruden since those emails were sent between 2011 and 2018 when he was working at ESPN as an NFL analyst?

“The NFL did not attach a declaration from Commissioner Goodell, or any evidence supporting their theory that the conduct alleged in the complaint was deemed conduct detrimental to the best interests of the NFL or professional football,” Gruden’s attorney, Adam Hosmer-Henner, wrote in an April brief. 

District Court Judge Nancy Allf wrote in the October ruling that the NFL is challenging that the NFL “did not produce any evidence showing that Commissioner Goodell was of the opinion that the instant dispute constituted conduct detrimental to the best interests of the NFL or professional football or any evidence showing that Commissioner Goodell had made such a decision or issued such an opinion.”

Minus any disciplinary action against Gruden, there doesn’t appear to be anything that would bar him from coaching for or consulting with NFL teams — outside the blowback on the team over the leaked emails.

A message left with an NFL spokesperson was not returned.  

“Obviously, Jon’s a guy that has a lot of experience with (quarterback) Derek (Carr), and Derek has had his most success under Jon Gruden,” Saints head coach Dennis Allen said per ESPN. “…You ask everybody that was involved, and they thought it was really beneficial for our football team.”

Conversely, Gruden working with an NFL team could actually aid the NFL if a jury finds in favor of Gruden. In the original complaint filed in November 2021, Gruden claimed the leaked emails resulted in “significant injuries to his reputation that will affect his future employment prospects and endorsement opportunities.”

Attorney Dan Lust said if the case gets to a verdict and Gruden prevails, his work with an NFL team could work in the league’s favor.

“Gruden’s involvement with the Saints seems to shows that his reputation isn’t so damaged that he’s unable to work alongside or with other NFL teams,” said Lust, co-host of the Conduct Detrimental podcast.

Gruden’s legal team alleged the NFL pressured the Raiders to fire Gruden after the first batch of leaked emails that included a racist trope directed at NFLPA Executive Director DeMaurice Smith. 

When the Raiders didn’t fire Gruden, the lawsuit alleged the NFL “followed through with this threat by leaking another batch of documents.” The were scooped as part of the NFL’s first outside investigation of the Washington Commanders. 

The NFL has long denied it was the source of the leaks, although there was no denial in the league’s Nevada State Supreme Court filing on May 30. 

The NFL filed its notice of appeal in October to challenge Allf’s ruling that Gruden’s case could remain in her court and not part of the NFL’s arbitration process. 

Allf also previously denied the NFL’s motion to dismiss the case. 

There’s a stay in the case pending the outcome of the NFL’s appeal. 

The case is expected to have oral arguments, which are expected to be announced by the Nevada State Supreme Court in the coming weeks and occur before the year’s end. 

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Charles Woodson

Charles Woodson Has to Take Name Off Booze for New Browns Stake

Woodson will have to tweak the promotion of Woodson’s Intercept Wines.

ESPN’s Pitaro: Eisen, Berman, Stephen A. Will Have Big NFL Roles

FOS broke the news of Berman signing an extension through his 50th anniversary.

NFL Releases 2025 Schedule With Heavy Focus on Standalone Matchups

The 2025 NFL schedule separates more games into individual broadcast slots.

Featured Today

Jun 1996; Seattle, WA USA; FILE PHOTO; Seattle Supersonics guard Gary Payton (20) lays the ball up against the Chicago Bulls during the 1996 NBA Finals at Key Arena.

5,000 Pieces of Thunder History Are Hidden in Seattle

Sonics championship banners, trophies, and retired jerseys are all in one place.
Ohio State Buckeyes safety Caleb Downs (2) returns an interception during the second half of the Cotton Bowl Classic College Football Playoff semifinal game against the Texas Longhorns at AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas on Jan. 10, 2025. Ohio State won 28-14.
May 15, 2025

House v. NCAA Settlement to Pay College Athletes: All Your Questions Answered

The yearslong lawsuit over player compensation is in the home stretch.
Hillary Trochek/Statement Threads Shop
May 14, 2025

How Custom Stanley Cup Playoffs WAGs Jackets Come Together

The process behind custom postseason jackets is meticulous—and aspirational.
Gracelyn Laudermilch
May 14, 2025

The House Settlement Has Thrown High School Athletes Into Crisis

FOS spoke to an athlete devastated by House settlement roster cuts.
Vince McMahon

Vince McMahon Could Have to Turn Over Hush Money Documents in Court

Suing shareholders want to know his “state of mind” during UFC merger.
Adam Silver
May 7, 2025

NFL Attempts to Aid NBA in Video Privacy Lawsuit

The NBA is being accused of unlawfully sharing user data with Facebook. 
May 8, 2025

Judge Bans ATP Tour From Retaliating Against Players in Major Lawsuit

Plaintiffs had sought to ban the ATP from discussing the case with players.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

In the latest Portfolio Players—our series spotlighting athlete and executive investors—Carolyn Tisch Blodgett, owner of Gotham FC & advisor to the New York Giants, breaks down how sports, brand, and capital are reshaping fandom and the business of women’s sports.
Dec 17, 2024; Las Vegas, Nevada, USA; Floyd Mayweather Jr. during the 1st quarter of the Emirates NBA Cup championship game between the Oklahoma City Thunder and Milwaukee Bucks at T-Mobile Arena.
May 2, 2025

Floyd Mayweather Jr. Hits Business Insider With $100M Defamation Suit

The suit seeks at least $100 million and a public retraction of the reporting.
UC Davis Baseball
May 2, 2025

NCAA Baseball Coaches Get Preliminary Approval in ‘Wage Fix’ Case

The baseball coaches are expected to be paid an average of roughly $33,000.
Apr 6, 2025; Tampa, FL, USA; A general overall view of the opening tipoff between UConn Huskies forward Sarah Strong (left) and South Carolina Gamecocks forward Chloe Kitts at midcourt on the Final Four logo during the national championship of the women's 2025 NCAA tournament at Amalie Arena.
April 30, 2025

House v. NCAA Settlement Has a Little-Known Federal Lobbying Provision

It would effectively muzzle plaintiff lawyers in Congressional debates.
Asinga
April 29, 2025

Teen Sprinter’s Suit Against Gatorade Dismissed In Ruling Judge Admits Is ‘Unsatisfying’ 

Issam Asinga blames Gatorade gummies for a positive drug test.