• Loading stock data...
Friday, September 20, 2024

Lessons to Learn

  • The NAIA has proven that unrestrictive NIL rules can work if done correctly.
  • There are other lessons the NCAA can learn from the NAIA’s experience, too.
Photo: NAIA/Design: Alex Brooks

After launching NIL rules in perhaps the strangest year in college sports, it appears the program was a success. And it’s also clear that unrestrictive NIL rules can work if done correctly.

What else can the NCAA learn from this? 

Looming Competition

High school athletes are even considering forgoing NCAA Division II or III for the NAIA because of its NIL rules, according to emails Mitchell has received.

It signifies just how much making money means to college athletes.

False Fears

With the change in NIL laws, the NCAA’s biggest concern has been preserving amateurism. 

The NCAA is terrified that unrestricted NIL would get in the way of athletes going to class and studying — that is, more than sports do already.

Mitchell had two responses to that. First, she noted that NIL endorsement posts are easier and quicker for college athletes to make money than many other jobs.

And second, Mitchell thinks NIL actually educates athletes on an important skill: How to grow their personal brands. She’s seen evidence that athletes are more careful about their behavior while in school now that they can profit off their NIL. They fear that an inappropriate post or broken rule could lose them endorsement opportunities. 

“My teammates are now, more than ever, cognizant of their behavior off the court because bad behavior could cost them income potential,” Mitchell said.

Fearmongering

In a Senate hearing last year, Power 5 officials and Republican lawmakers threatened that unrestricted NIL could negatively impact women’s sports. 

They implied that revenue used to fund women’s sports — from men’s basketball and football — may decrease with NIL. (The only way that would happen is if athletic departments competed with athletes for the same sponsorship dollars, and athletic departments lost.) 

If revenue decreased, officials would then cut women’s sports, they said.

They said this, of course, despite the fact that Title IX requires schools to provide equitable women’s sports opportunities no matter how much money a school makes.

Mitchell, as a women’s sports athlete, disagrees with this fearmongering. “I think that argument is very fallible. … There are more than enough donor dollars to go around.”

And either way, women’s sports athletes are now able to catch the attention of brands and make money — undoubtedly a better position than they were in before.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

The Big 12 Is Finally Getting a Conference Network

It was the only power conference without a league-specific network—until now.
Trevor Reilly
exclusive

Former Colorado Football Coach Explains Why He Went to Saudi Arabia for NIL Money

Reilly tells FOS why he went looking for NIL money in the Middle East.
Dec 1, 2023; Lynchburg, VA, USA; New Mexico State Aggies wide receiver Trent Hudson (14) celebrates a touchdown catch against the Liberty Flames during the fourth quarter at Williams Stadium.

Several Schools Are Interested in Joining the Mountain West

Sacramento State and New Mexico State are among those looking to move.

CFB’s Coast-to-Coast Clashes

The ACC’s wild travel schedule will be on display Friday and Saturday.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Behind the WNBA’s Rise

0:00

Featured Today

Crypto.com soccer advertising

The Champions League Is Back. So Is Crypto Sponsorship

Crypto investment is making its debut in the biggest European soccer competition.
New York Boulders
September 10, 2024

On the Fringes of Pro Baseball, a Tiny Independent Team’s Attempt to Create Stars

In the Frontier League, every bit helps to make it to the Show.
September 4, 2024

Northwestern’s Tiny Temporary Football Stadium Is Making Big Money

Despite 35,000 fewer fans in seats, Northwestern is bringing in more revenue.
Aug 25, 2024; Denver, Colorado, USA; Detailed view of a Denver Broncos snapping the football in the second half against the Arizona Cardinals at Empower Field at Mile High.
September 3, 2024

How NFL Streaming Will Work With Coverage Across Four Exclusive Platforms

Each week will feature at least one game exclusively on a streaming service.

How Will the ACC, Pac-12, and Group of 5 Shake Out?

Realignment outside of the Power 4 is alive and well.
September 18, 2024

Why Is Woj Leaving ESPN for a GM Role at St. Bonaventure?

The venerated NBA news-breaker returns to his alma mater in an administrative role.
Ole Miss coach Lane Kiffin on the sideline
September 18, 2024

Wake Forest Defends Million-Dollar Buyout That Infuriated Lane Kiffin: ‘Business Decision’

The Rebels blew out the Demon Deacons 40–6 on Saturday.
Sponsored

The Women Fueling The Future Of Football

In this episode of FOS Explains, fueled by Gatorade, we discuss how women are changing the landscape of the NFL and the business of football.
Sen. Jon Tester, D-Mont, arriving to the hearing where Gary Gensler, Chair, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission would testify before the COMMITTEE ON BANKING, HOUSING, AND URBAN AFFAIRS hearing on “Oversight of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.”
September 18, 2024

Political NIL Deals Open Another Window for College Athlete Paydays

Two University of Montana athletes have signed NIL deals endorsing political candidates.
September 17, 2024

Tennessee’s Ticket Fee Is Latest Move States Make to Pay College Athletes

Tennessee is planning to get a portion of that money from a 10% “talent fee” that will be added to tickets across all sports.
Springfield, Ohio police monitor the parking lot at the Premier English Evangelical Haitian Springfield, Ohio church
September 17, 2024

Springfield’s Wittenberg University Cancels Games As Threats Mount

Wittenberg Athletics announced athletic contests had been canceled because of violent threats.
Tennessee wide receiver Mike Matthews (10) runs downfield after making a catch during the NCAA College football game against Kent State on Saturday, September 14, 2024, in Knoxville, Tenn.
September 17, 2024

Tennessee Plans ‘Talent Fee’ Ticketing to Fund Athlete Revenue-Sharing

The school will implement a 10% “talent fee” on football tickets.