• Loading stock data...
Thursday, April 24, 2025

Lawsuit Benefits from SCOTUS’ Invitation

  • Johnson v. NCAA argues Division I NCAA athletes should be considered employees and paid minimum wage.
  • Partially thanks to the Alston decision, two motions to dismiss the case have now been thrown out.
Photo: Robert Deutsch-USA TODAY/Design: Alex Brooks

The Alston decision invited athletes to continue challenging the NCAA’s business model in court. A lawsuit called Johnson v. NCAA is the first to benefit.

First filed in 2019, the case argues Division I athletes should be considered employees and paid minimum wage. A similar case from 2016 got thrown out. But Johnson v. NCAA can go forward.

In August, a Pennsylvania judge refused a request to throw out the case by schools named as defendants. On Wednesday, that same judge refused another motion filed by the NCAA. 

That second decision was based on an analysis of athletes under the Fair Labor Standards Act, according to Boise State law professor Sam Ehrlich. But the fact that neither the NCAA nor schools could get the case thrown out was clearly aided by Alston.

  • To strike down lawsuits arguing athletes should get paid, the NCAA has used text from a decades-old Supreme Court decision that said, “In order to preserve the character and quality of the ‘product,’ athletes must not be paid…”
  • The Alston decision rejected this argument, saying that “these remarks do not suggest that courts must reflexively reject all challenges to the NCAA’s compensation restrictions.” That sets the stage for athletes to demand other forms of payment.
  • The judge in Johnson v. NCAA even cited this language in the first “motion to dismiss” rejection.

There are still many steps before the case reaches trial. But if it does, a pro-athlete ruling could spell the end of the NCAA as we know it.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Mar 16, 2025; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Oklahoma City Thunder guard Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (2) celebrates with guard Isaiah Joe (11) after score in the fourth quarter against the Milwaukee Bucks at Fiserv Forum.

Unorthodox OKC: The Thunder Redefined Tanking to Become NBA’s Best

A rebuild years in the making has OKC in the driver’s seat.
Mar 13, 2020; Augusta, GA, USA; The front entrance at Augusta National Golf Club in Augusta, Ga., Friday morning. The Masters Tournament has been postponed due to coronavirus concerns.
opinion

What’s It Like to Play Augusta? A Day on the World’s Most..

Inside a round at the most exclusive club in the world.
July 9, 2009; Auburn Hills, MI, USA; Detroit Pistons president Joe Dumars during the press conference to introduce their new head coach John Kuester at their practice facility.

Joe Dumars Leaving NBA League Office to Run Pelicans

Joe Dumars was the architect of the 2004 champion Pistons.

Featured Today

Apr 5, 2025; San Antonio, TX, USA; Duke Blue Devils forward Cooper Flagg (2) reacts after a three point basket against the Houston Cougars during the first half in the semifinals of the men's Final Four of the 2025 NCAA Tournament at the Alamodome.

Cooper Flagg’s Timing Is Perfect for the NBA and USA Basketball

The projected No. 1 pick just declared for the draft.
Apr 14, 2025; New York, New York, USA; Paige Bueckers is interviewed by ESPN after being selected with the number one overall pick to the Dallas Wings in the 2025 WNBA Draft at The Shed at Hudson Yards
April 21, 2025

ESPN’s WNBA Coverage Mirrors the League’s Stunning Growth

“I don’t think we stand still in our coverage of women’s sports,” says Rowe.
Dec 9, 2024; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; New York Knicks guard Jalen Brunson (11) watches as center Karl-Anthony Towns (32) celebrates after making a three point basket to clinch a win against the Toronto Raptors near the end of the fourth quarter at Scotiabank Arena
April 19, 2025

Same Owner, New Knicks: New York’s Remarkable Rebound

The franchise’s renaissance didn’t happen overnight.
Masters
April 18, 2025

Why The Masters Quietly Cracked Down on Ticket Resellers

Insiders expect big changes are coming to ticketing at Augusta National.

The House Settlement Is in Jeopardy. Here’s What It Will Take to..

The parties will try to salvage the settlement over the next two weeks.
Dec 27, 2024; Memphis, TN, USA; Arkansas Razorbacks defensive back Miguel Mitchell (16) returns an interception during the forth quarter against the Texas Tech Red Raiders at Simmons Bank Liberty Stadium.
April 23, 2025

NIL Contract Buyouts Are More Common, but Can They Be Enforced?

The Arkansas collective has issued two demand letters to players to pay buyouts.
NC State women's cross country
April 23, 2025

Judge Threatens to Reject $2.8 Billion House v. NCAA Settlement

The NCAA and power conferences could end up at trial.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

This week, Two-time Super Bowl Champion and CBS NFL analyst Logan Ryan joins us to talk the business of sports on our third installment of Portfolio Players.
Flau'jae Johnson
exclusive
April 23, 2025

Flau’jae Johnson Says She Will Return to LSU

The transfer portal closed Wednesday.
Fordham
April 23, 2025

Fordham Hit With Rare NIL Era NCAA Sanctions

The Rams were hit with recruiting violations stemming from a Times Square photo shoot.
Mar 20, 2025; Providence, RI, USA; McNeese State Cowboys guard Quadir Copeland (11) brings the ball up court against Clemson Tigers forward Ian Schieffelin (4) during the second half at Amica Mutual Pavilion.
April 22, 2025

Why College Players Without NCAA Eligibility Are Flooding the Transfer Portal

Athletes nationwide hope legal challenges will win them extra eligibility.
Charlie Baker
April 22, 2025

NCAA Increases Lobbying Spending in First Months of Trump

The governing body spent $450,000 on lobbying during the first quarter.