• Loading stock data...
Saturday, May 31, 2025

Judge Says Issues Still Remain With $2.8B House Settlement

The judge didn’t issue a decision on whether to approve the House v. NCAA settlement—but gave lawyers suggestions for what to fix.

Mar 26, 2025; Newark, NJ, USA; An NCAA Wilson official game ball passes thorough a basket in front of an Brigham Young Cougars logo during a practice sessions in preparation for an East Regional semifinal games at Prudential Center
Vincent Carchietta/Imagn Images

After an hourslong hearing in Oakland, Northern District of California judge Claudia Wilken declined to approve the House v. NCAA settlement—a combination of three cases which would, among other things, allow players to get paid by schools for the first time in history—as it is currently written.

She ordered lawyers to amend language in the settlement that binds future athletes not currently represented or in college to its terms, without a chance to challenge them (as the system the settlement sets up continues for at least 10 years). She also indicated she wants changes to parts of the settlement related to roster limits, suggesting a “grandfathering” clause to help athletes who received roster spots before the settlement’s approval that would be rescinded under the settlement. 

Lawyers will get back to Wilken in one week about whether they think they can amend the settlement to her liking. “Maybe some [issues] you can fix, maybe some you can’t but you can give a better explanation,” she said. “Basically, I think it is a good settlement. Don’t quote me.”

(Wilken did this same thing for the early approval process for the settlement back in the fall, but ultimately gave it preliminary approval.)

The settlement would offer $2.8 billion in back-damages to athletes who didn’t get to earn NIL (name, image, and likeness) dollars before the NCAA changed its rules in 2021. It would also allow all Division I schools to share revenue with all players in an athletic department up to a cap that would begin at $20.5 million, and continue for 10 years. The settlement would impose new limits, too, allowing the NCAA to block NIL deals offered by collectives that could be “pay for play,” and imposing roster limits.

Wilken’s main concern was about locking future college athletes into a settlement before they’re even old enough to be recruited, given that the settlement would create a revenue-sharing system and roster/NIL limits for the next 10 years. 

“Can you have a class of future people who aren’t known yet?” Wilken asked one of the lawyers. “Can they be understood to release claims for things that haven’t happened yet? … I’m more interested in the problem of future class members and future claims. They can’t get notice. They can’t object before [the settlement is] approved. What about that?” She called them “iconic 10-year-olds on the asphalt.” 

Michael Hausfeld, the lead attorney in the O’Bannon case over NIL rights who was presenting an objection, said: “I am very concerned about the rights of those yet to be inducted into the college sport arena.” Attorney Andrew Ellis, who represented objectors, said: “The way to remedy it is through separate counsel that is solely devoted to their interests.”  

In response to these concerns, plaintiff attorney Jeff Kessler said that there’s a mechanism in the settlement to revisit the terms annually, which would theoretically allow concerns of future athletes to be considered. “We’re very comfortable with this process,” he said.

Another issue Wilken considered: that the settlement imposes roster limits as a way to control the sports environment after taking away caps on how many scholarships teams can offer. Dozens of athletes, parents, and industry experts have objected to the roster-limit impositions, saying they’ve already lost roster opportunities because schools have rescinded their offers in preparation for the settlement’s implementation. “The written objections are just a fraction of the reality,” Utah swimmer Gannon Flynn said of the breadth of the issue.

Wilken appeared inclined to provide a solution: allow schools to keep the roster spots they’ve already extended to players before the settlement’s approval, and then impose the roster limits for the future. 

LSU gymnast Livvy Dunne, considered one of the most successful beneficiaries of NIL,  appeared over Zoom to criticize the damage claims specifically. “This settlement doesn’t come close to recognizing the value I lost,” she said.

But Judge Wilken has said multiple times, including in this hearing, that she wouldn’t consider gender equity issues as a Title IX case could be brought separately. She’s already made lawyers include a clause in the settlement making it clear that the settlement doesn’t protect the NCAA, conferences, or schools from gender-equity lawsuits in the future. Plus, she said later in the hearing: “The method used to calculate lost NIL opportunities seemed reasonable.”

Ultimately, this and other issues like athlete employment questions aren’t the legal issues that are being adjudicated by the settlement. Collective bargaining “may be a great idea… that just isn’t part of this case,” she said. “Same goes for the minimum wage claim or the fair labor standards claim.”

The only issue at hand: antitrust.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

breaking

Pacers-Thunder Is Lowest-Payroll NBA Finals in Years

Neither team is in the luxury tax, despite rosters with multiple All-Stars.
exclusive

Newly American-Owned Italian Hoops Team Hires Ex-Pelicans Exec as GM

Napoli Basketball is hiring the Pelicans’ former chief of staff as GM.

PSG and the City of Paris Can Join European Soccer’s Elite

What a maiden Champions League title would mean for the French club.

Featured Today

How the Champions League Anthem Took on a Life of Its Own

The composer didn’t know he wrote a timeless hit three decades ago.
May 25, 2025

How Rolex Paved the Way for Luxury’s Love Affair With Tennis

“It’s almost impossible to think about tennis without thinking about Rolex.”
Mar 23, 2025; Miami, FL, USA; Alexandra Eala (PHI) reacts after winning a point against Madison Keys (USA)(not pictured) on day six of the Miami Open at Hard Rock Stadium.
May 24, 2025

Alex Eala Is Defying Her Country’s Odds to Make French Open History

The Philippines native has overcome a unique set of financial odds.
May 24, 2025

Indiana Is the Center of the Basketball Universe—Thanks to Both Pro Teams

The Fever and Pacers are thriving at the same time.
Mar 28, 2025; Atlanta, GA, USA; Mississippi Rebels forward Jaemyn Brakefield (4) rebounds over Michigan State Spartans center Carson Cooper (15) and Mississippi Rebels guard Matthew Murrell (11) in the second half of a South Regional semifinal of the 2025 NCAA tournament at State Farm Arena.

SEC Increases Court Storming Fine to $500K—With Caveat

The SEC used to fine schools $500,000 as a third-time offense.
May 29, 2025

Former Seton Hall Baseball Player Sues Over Sexualized Hazing

The student says the coach knew about the hazing and failed to act.
May 29, 2025

Brett Yormark: Big 12 Puts Private Equity and Naming Rights on Pause

Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark is shifting his conference’s strategy.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

In Episode 7 of Portfolio Players, go inside the boardroom with Avenue Capital CEO and former Milwaukee Bucks co-owner Marc Lasry on Giannis’s future, women’s sports, and upstart leagues like TGL and Unrivaled. 
May 29, 2025

Brian Kelly Pushes for SEC–Big Ten Alliance. Would It Widen the Gap?

A deal, if completed, would further strengthen college football’s two titans.
Mar 16, 2025; Fort Worth, TX, USA; UAB Blazers forward Yaxel Lendeborg (3) drives to the basket as Memphis Tigers forward Nicholas Jourdain (2) defends during the first half at Dickies Arena.
May 28, 2025

Prospects Picking College Over NBA Draft at Record Rate

The 2025 NBA draft has its lowest number of early entrants since 2015.
Tennessee pitcher Brayden Krenzel (34) pitches during a NCAA baseball game between the Tennessee Volunteers and Vanderbilt Commodores at Lindsey Nelson Stadium on May 11, 2025.
May 27, 2025

SEC Stranglehold on College Baseball Continues

SEC schools will host eight of the 16 regionals set to start this weekend.
May 22, 2025

Can Golf Emulate the College World Series Model?

Carlsbad, Calif., is hosting the event through 2028.