• Loading stock data...
Thursday, October 23, 2025

How the NCAA Plans to Stop Employment in Its Tracks After Settlement

  • The NCAA will use the House settlement as a tool to end the debate over athlete employment status.
  • If the NCAA does succeed in getting a law passed saying athletes are amateurs, however, other lawyers will likely challenge it.
Jun 4, 2024; Eugene, OR, USA; A NCAA logo flag at Hayward Field.
Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

In May, the NCAA and power conferences agreed to settle the House v. NCAA lawsuit—conceding, for the first time in college sports history, to share revenue between schools and players. But now, the NCAA is hoping to use the settlement to end an even bigger debate: whether athletes should be considered school employees.

House v. NCAA, first filed in 2020, argued athletes who couldn’t capitalize on name, image, and likeness deals deserve backpay, and that power conference schools should share revenue with all athletes going forward. As part of the settlement agreement, power conference schools will begin revenue-sharing up to about $22 million per year with athletes.

Because the settlement doesn’t address the athlete employment question, however, it doesn’t protect the NCAA from the three ongoing cases arguing athletes should be considered employees, co-counsel Steve Berman confirmed to Front Office Sports.

The NCAA hopes to resolve this indirectly. Since 2019, the NCAA and power conferences have waged a multimillion-dollar lobbying campaign in Congress to reverse the athletes’ rights movement by granting an antitrust protection (giving the NCAA the power to enforce compensation rules) and by deeming athletes amateurs. The NCAA hopes Congress will see the House settlement as an earnest attempt to make major reforms to college sports—and that Congress should step in so they wouldn’t have to make more. President Charlie Baker and the power conference commissioners even went so far as to call it a “roadmap” for legislation.

As part of the settlement, plaintiff lawyers have agreed to help the NCAA with that lobbying effort—but they likely won’t go as far as the NCAA would like. Berman says he and fellow counsel Jeffrey Kessler would be willing to argue that Congress should grant a limited antitrust exemption to allow the NCAA to cap revenue sharing, for example. But they won’t help the NCAA in its main goal of getting broad antitrust protections and have not agreed to lobby against athlete employment status.

“If the NCAA asks us to, we will express our views to Congress that they should be free from future lawsuits that raise the same issues that were raised in our litigation,” Berman says. “We will not comment on anything beyond that.”

Even if the NCAA succeeds in codifying amateurism without House lawyers’ help, it could still face future challenges. 

One of the attorneys on the Johnson v. NCAA federal court case over athlete employment status, Paul McDonald, tells FOS that he would challenge a law saying college athletes are not employees. He believes it would be unconstitutional, given that non-athlete students are allowed to be employees.

“Any federal legislation to single out college athletes to be denied the same employee status, rights and hourly pay as fellow students in work study-style programs (e.g., student employees in dining halls, libraries—even selling popcorn at NCAA games) would be unconstitutional on Equal Protection grounds,” he says. That’s also the premise of the Johnson v. NCAA case, which argues that Division I athletes should be classified as employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act, and that they should be entitled to hourly minimum wage.

McDonald notes that other lawyers involved in the space would likely consider challenging a law codifying amateurism. “It’s a bridge to nowhere.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Big 12’s Yormark Defends Slow NIL Go Approvals: ‘That’s Not a Glitch’

Collectives have been starting to pay players without approvals.

Beyond Ohio State, It’s Another Massive Shake-Up in the CFB Top 25

Nine of the top 10 teams changed positions in Week 9.

Florida, Colorado State Firings Push CFB Buyouts Past $100M

Nine FBS head coaches have been fired since the season started.
Jason Belzer

College Sports Is ‘Too Big of an Opportunity’

Panelists at the Asset Class summit agreed college sports is the next frontier.

Featured Today

Christie's

Lou Gehrig’s $4M Jersey and the Exploding Sports Memorabilia Market

An ultra-rare sports collection is about to hit the auction block.
@chef__tezz/Instagram
October 19, 2025

Inside the NFL’s Private Chef Network

Private chefs are the unsung architects of player performance.
October 18, 2025

How Vanderbilt Went From SEC Doormat to Dark Horse CFP Candidate

After beating LSU, Clark Lea said: “Internally, we expect to win.”
May 27, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Indiana Pacers guard T.J. McConnell (9) shoots a three point basket over New York Knicks guard Josh Hart (3) during the third quarter of game four of the eastern conference finals for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Gainbridge Fieldhouse
October 18, 2025

NBA Stars Swap Wine With League Friends and Foes

A wine-exchange tradition emerged from the bubble season’s close quarters.
Tony Vitello

Tony Vitello’s Stunning MLB Jump Comes With $3M Tennessee Buyout

Vitello heads to San Francisco after winning a national championship in 2024.
Tom Izzo
October 22, 2025

Tom Izzo Rips ‘Ridiculous’ NCAA Move Allowing Former G Leaguers

Michigan State didn’t know an eligibility change had been made, he said.
Texas Tech tortillas
October 22, 2025

Texas Tech Is Attempting a Tortilla Crackdown 

Rebellious students are known to smuggle the tortillas in their underwear.
Sponsored

Michelle Wie West: Women’s Sports Doesn’t Need Charity

The LPGA legend on redefining women’s sports and the future of golf.
BYU
October 20, 2025

BYU Lost Its Star QB This Summer. Now It’s One of the..

The Cougars are thriving with a true freshman at quarterback.
Indiana
October 20, 2025

Indiana Is the Center of the Sports World—Again

After successful NBA and WNBA seasons, Indiana’s football teams are thriving.
Sep 20, 2025; Orlando, Florida, USA; North Carolina Tar Heels head coach Bill Belichick walks the sideline during the first quarter against the UCF Knights at the Bounce House Stadium.
October 17, 2025

Belichick’s UNC Saga Now Includes GM Trip to Saudi Arabia

UNC GM Michael Lombardi traveled to Saudi Arabia earlier this year.
Cignetti
October 17, 2025

Curt Cignetti Lands Third Contract in Just 19 Games With Indiana

Cignetti signed a new contract five days after Indiana upset Oregon.