• Loading stock data...
Sunday, September 7, 2025
Fox Analyst and Media Entrepreneur Greg Olsen to Speak at Tuned In Get your ticket now!
Law

How Congress, the Courts, or the NLRB Could Kill Amateurism

  • Johnson v. NCAA is just one of three major legal and political processes in motion that could ultimately kill amateurism.
  • The National Labor Relations Board, and eventually Congress, could be next.
Fans cheer on players during match-up between Georgia and Michigan during 2021 Orange Bowl at Hard Rock Stadium
Rhona Wise-USA TODAY Sports

In a packed courtroom on Wednesday in Philadelphia, three federal judges considered a scenario heralded as the NCAA’s worst nightmare: whether college athletes could be considered university employees. The case before the judges was Johnson v. NCAA, which alleges athletes are entitled to minimum wage.

Johnson is just one of three major legal and political processes in motion that could ultimately kill amateurism. The NCAA has never battled as many legitimate challenges to its core business model of amateurism as it is right now.

For years, the very core of the NCAA’s business model has been that athletes aren’t entitled to employment status — they can’t unionize, receive wages, or claim other U.S. labor protections like workers’ compensation. 

But now, the Johnson case, the National Labor Relations Board and, potentially, Congress could change that.

Johnson: The Right to Minimum Wage

Johnson v. NCAA, which was originally filed in 2019 by several Division I athletes, alleges that the NCAA and schools have misclassified them as amateurs and that they should receive minimum wage under the Fair Labor Standards Act.

It’s a common argument that Division I football and basketball players should get paid because of the billions of dollars they generate for the NCAA and schools. But the plaintiffs in Johnson argued that it was the control schools exert over athletes — from how many hours they practice to what classes they can take — that mimics an employer-employee relationship.

Despite winding through the court system for three years, the case hasn’t even reached the discovery phase. The NCAA and schools have made every attempt to get the case dismissed. 

On Wednesday, the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals heard arguments related to an intermediary appeal: again, whether athletes could possibly be employees. The judges attacked the NCAA’s position that players are amateurs, sometimes poking fun at the NCAA and eliciting laughter from the courtroom.

One judge referred to the NCAA and schools as “regimes.” Another asked point-blank how athletes could not be considered employees. 

If the tenor of the judges was any indication, the athletes will likely win the appeal. While in the short term, that only means that the case will proceed to discovery, it could ultimately end in a verdict that athletes should, in fact, receive a minimum wage — in addition to all their other benefits.

But we may have to wait years before for a final verdict.

NLRB: The Right to Unionize

While an athlete win in the Johnson case would make Division I athletes employees under the FLSA, it wouldn’t immediately grant them other rights — like the ability to collectively bargain. 

The National Labor Relations Board is handling that issue. It’s agreed to prosecute a complaint filed on behalf of USC football and basketball players. Filed by the National College Players Association and executive director Ramogi Huma, the complaint alleges the school, the Pac-12, and the NCAA are joint employers who have mistakenly called athletes amateurs. 

“This kind of misclassification deprives these players of their statutory right to organize and to join together to improve their working/playing conditions if they wish to do so,” NLRB General Counsel Jennifer Abruzzo previously said in a statement to FOS. “Our aim is to ensure that these players can fully and freely exercise their rights.”

The NLRB only has jurisdiction of the private sector, and in 2014 ruled that it would be too complicated to allow private school athletes to unionize while public school athletes can’t. 

But this case has a workaround. If players win, they would earn the right for all D-I basketball and football players to unionize. Athletes at public schools could do so also, given that conferences and the NCAA would be considered their employers under the “joint employer doctrine.”

Legal experts have told FOS that while the NLRB case and the Johnson case are different, they could impact one another. But even if athletes are deemed employees, only the NLRB could decide if they can unionize.

The case will likely take at least a year, assuming the party that loses will appeal.

Congress: The Wild Card

Of all the pathways, Congress is the biggest wild card.

Federal lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have introduced a wide range of bills on the issue. Some would grant employment status, while others would prohibit it for good. One bill, from Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.), lands somewhere in the middle: It asks for revenue-sharing between players and schools, rather than wages.

It’s unclear whether Congress will have the momentum to pass any legislation related to college sports. 

The body is clearly busy with more pressing matters. In 2021, Congress held multiple hearings on athlete compensation issues — but has since lost steam. 

And it will have a hard time passing legislation with a Republican-controlled House and Democrat-controlled Senate. After all, it took multiple days for the House to elect a Speaker.

The NCAA’s No. 1 priority is lobbying in Washington. It hopes to not only reclaim Congress’ attention, but also convince it to issue antitrust protections, and to outright codify that athletes aren’t employees.

To carry out that mission, the governing body hired a politician as its next president: former Massachusetts governor Charlie Baker. Typically the president lives in Indianapolis, the home of the NCAA headquarters. But Baker will reportedly keep his current residence with the plan to spend most of his time traveling — and lobbying in Washington.

If the NCAA is successful, it will get lawmakers to define athletes as amateurs once and for all. But if it’s not, the courts or the NLRB could wind up getting the last word.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Arch Manning

NIL Go Says It Has Cleared $80 Million in NIL Deals So..

NIL collectives, however, say the majority of their deals are in limbo.
Aug 30, 2025; Nashville, Tennessee, USA; Vanderbilt Commodores linebacker Langston Patterson (10) looks over the defense against the Charleston Southern Buccaneers during the first half at FirstBank Stadium.

Latest Class Action Eligibility Lawsuit Challenges NCAA’s ‘Redshirt’ Rule

It’s the latest lawsuit challenging the NCAA’s core eligibility requirements.

Less Belichick Hype Could Mean Bad News for CFB Stakeholders

UNC had never begun a football season with so much hype.

Featured Today

Aug 23, 2025; Tampa, Florida, USA; Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen (17) leads the team onto the field for warm ups before a game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Raymond James Stadium.

Slow Burn: The NFL’s Private-Equity Era So Far

Three deals have been struck to date. But the league is bullish.
Tennis
September 5, 2025

The US Open Is Groaning Under the Weight of Its Own Success

New York’s tennis major is more popular than ever.
Dec 21, 2024; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15) gets ready to take the field prior to a game against the Houston Texans at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium.
September 5, 2025

How Brazil Game Fits Into NFL’s Plans for World Domination

Friday night’s Chiefs-Chargers game in São Paulo is big by design.
Oct 13, 2024; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts (1) and wide receiver A.J. Brown (11) celebrate their touchdown pass during the second quarter against the Cleveland Browns at Lincoln Financial Field.
September 2, 2025

TV Ratings Just Changed Again. The NFL Will Be the Big Winner

Nielsen’s new viewership system will have a big impact on sports.
Blue Jays
exclusive

MLBPA, DraftKings Agree to Settle NIL Suit

MLBPA said DraftKings and other sportsbooks improperly used players’ NIL.
Feb 2, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Los Angeles Clippers head coach Tyronn Lue scratches his head after calling a time out as forward Kawhi Leonard (2) walks past in the first half against the Toronto Raptors at Scotiabank Arena.
September 4, 2025

Kawhi Leonard’s Alleged ‘No Show’ Job Is Latest in Complex Clippers Relationship

Leonard’s high-profile 2019 recruitment continues to generate headlines years later.
Nov 9, 2024; Avondale, Arizona, USA; 23XI Racing team owner Michael Jordan during qualifying for the Cup Series championship race at Phoenix Raceway.
September 4, 2025

Jordan Can’t Bar Charter Sales Because NASCAR Agreed Not to Sell Charters

The contentious antitrust suit is slated to go to trial this December.
Sponsored

Trailblazer Cal Calamia Is Racing for ‘Advocacy, Storytelling, and Performance’

The marathoner wants excellence—not just inclusion—to be the goal for non-binary athletes.
Megan Romano
September 4, 2025

The $800 Million Enhanced Games Lawsuit Could Have Legs

Antitrust experts say the case could have some merit.
Oct 15, 2012; Dallas, TX, USA; A view of the Fox Sports Southwest logo during the game between the Dallas Mavericks and the Houston Rockets at the American Airlines Center. The Mavericks defeated the Rockets 123-104.
September 3, 2025

Fox, Hairstylist Settle Bombshell Sexual Harassment Lawsuit

Skip Bayless, Charlie Dixon, and Joy Taylor all denied claims of wrongdoing.
Michael Jordan
August 29, 2025

Texts From Michael Jordan, NASCAR Bosses Aired Out in Court: ‘I Have..

Jordan said he plans on “going down with fire” against NASCAR.
Barstool
August 29, 2025

Barstool Sues for Millions Over Failed Sponsorship Deal 

The media company says it was stiffed to the tune of $4.2 million.