• Loading stock data...
Saturday, July 12, 2025

House v. NCAA Settlement Doesn’t Address Biggest Question for Athletes

  • The case puts the NCAA and power conferences on the hook for billions in damages, but it’s not the biggest threat to the NCAA.
  • A settlement in the case would have no bearing on whether athletes should be considered employees.
Petre Thomas-USA TODAY Sports

On Monday night, ESPN reported that parties were making progress with settlement negotiations in the House v. NCAA case over name, image, and likeness—which many in the industry consider to be the most immediate threat to the NCAA’s financial stability, given that the governing body and Power 5 conferences are facing around $5 billion in damages. Front Office Sports can confirm that multiple college industry leaders expected parties to settle. (The main attorney for plaintiffs, Jeffrey Kessler, declined to comment when reached by FOS; the NCAA did not respond to a request for comment.)

Employment Status Unresolved

A settlement could allow players to receive a cut of the billions of dollars generated by television revenue for the first time in NCAA history. But it wouldn’t address college sports’ biggest existential question: athlete employee status. The House case doesn’t deal with employee classification at all; even its revenue-sharing mandates would apply to athletes only in power conference schools. 

The case, first filed in 2020 by named plaintiff Grant House, a former Arizona State swimmer, among others, would facilitate revenue sharing in a creative way. The defendants in the case include the NCAA, as well as the Pac-12, ACC, SEC, Big Ten, and Big 12 conferences. It argues that NIL’s definition should be expanded in multiple directions, most notably to allow athletes to receive a cut of TV revenue that would be considered “broadcast NIL rights.” Judge Claudia Wilken, who also presided over major antitrust cases O’Bannon and Alston, certified three damage classes last fall, hence the multibillion-dollar damages price tag.

Revenue-Sharing Dilemma

A settlement would mandate back-pay to damage classes, as well as force Power 5 conferences into a revenue-sharing framework that could provide $20 million per school to athletes, according to ESPN. But the reforms would stop there. There’s a growing sentiment across the NCAA that rich schools should share revenue with athletes, but the belief isn’t completely altruistic. They hope to pay players but still call them amateurs—that allowing revenue sharing will placate reformers who have been pushing for athletes to be deemed employees. 

The panic around paying damages in the House case has put it at the forefront of industry leaders’ minds. But employment classification is the NCAA’s biggest bogeyman—the real death knell to its amateurism model. Employee status would force schools to not only pay players salaries but also provide employee-related benefits and make schools and the NCAA potentially liable for workers’ compensation (something it has specifically fought against for decades). It would also allow athletes to attempt to formally unionize and collectively bargain with schools, conferences, and the NCAA, just like pro athletes do with their leagues. 

Multiple cases in federal court and at the National Labor Relations Board are already progressing toward at least some group of NCAA athletes being deemed professionals. The Dartmouth men’s basketball team’s unionization effort has perhaps progressed the farthest.

As for long-term consequences, the House case pales in comparison.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Bobbleheads are seen at Vintage Indy Sports, Tuesday, April 29, 2025 in Speedway. The local sports memorabilia store opened recently.

Baseball’s Bobbleheads Are the Center of the Collectibles Universe

Baseball’s most important keepsake drives long lines—and big business.
Cobh Ramblers
exclusive

Ireland’s Ramblers Latest Soccer Club to Gain U.S. Owner

The Ramblers play in the League of Ireland First Division.
Apr 6, 2024; Miami, Florida, USA; The LIV Golf logo is on display along the 10th hole during the second round of LIV Golf Miami golf tournament at Trump National Doral.

LIV Golf’s New Leadership Reapplies for World Ranking Points

The league’s first attempt was denied in 2023.

All-Star Game Returns to Atlanta With Big Plans After 2021 Exit

The league’s jewel event is set to be a global showcase for The Battery.

Featured Today

Rimouski, QC - JUNE 1: Final Game of the 2025 Memorial Cup between the Medicine Hats Tigers and the London Knights on June 1, 2025, at the Colisée Financière Sun Life in Rimouski, Qc.

CHL Is Facing a ‘Pandora’s Box’ of Questions Amid NCAA Talent Departure

As players defect to college, the Canadian Hockey League won’t cede ground.
Jun 28, 2025; Arlington, Texas, USA; Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh (29) bats during the game between the Texas Rangers and the Seattle Mariners at Globe Life Field.
July 9, 2025

The Torpedo Bat Business Is Still Going Strong: ‘Here to Stay’

Demand for the oddly shaped bats has stayed strong across the sport.
July 6, 2025

American Celebs Want to Be Sports Owners. Soccer Is Where They Start

As U.S. team prices climb, investors set their sights abroad.
July 5, 2025

Baseball’s Celebrity Row: Behind MLB’s First-Pitch Ritual

Often planned, sometimes spontaneous, the ritual throw is baseball’s celebrity row.

NCAA: March Madness Expansion to 76 Teams ‘Still Viable’ for 2026

Negotiations continue with media rights holder CBS and TNT Sports.
July 10, 2025

Deion Sanders Rips ‘Bulljunk’ in CFB, Calls for NFL-Style Salary Cap

Coach Prime is frustrated with the new revenue-sharing era.
The Florida State Seminoles hosted the Florida Gators at Doak Campbell Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 30, 2024.
July 10, 2025

Athletic Departments Express Renewed Interest in PE in Wake of House Settlement

Schools now have more expenses—and are looking for creative solutions.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
Apr 4, 2025; Tampa, FL, USA; Connecticut Huskies guard KK Arnold (2)1 dribbles against UCLA Bruins forward Angela Dugalic (32) during the third quarter in a semifinal of the women's 2025 NCAA tournament at Amalie Arena.
July 10, 2025

‘Kind of a Joke’: Frustrations Mount As New NIL Deal Approval Process..

Delays have already led to athletes losing NIL opportunities.
Jul 9, 2025; Frisco, TX, USA; Head coaches Willie Fritz of Houston, Mike Gundy of Oklahoma State, Rich Rodriguez of West Virginia, Lance Leipold of Kansas, Sonny Dykes of TCU, Kyle Whittingham of Utah, Brent Brennan of Arizona and Deion Sanders of Colorado all sit on stage for a Coaches Roundtable during 2025 Big 12 Football Media Days at The Star.
July 9, 2025

Big 12 Commish: Conference Is ‘All In’ on International Expansion

The conference had once planned a large initiative in Mexico.
Sebastian Rivera (R) tf. Danny Coles 6:47 (20-3). Rutgers University Wrestling vs Princeton in Piscataway, NJ on February 18, 2022.
July 9, 2025

The House Settlement Is Being Appealed. It Won’t Stop Revenue-Sharing—for Now

The settlement’s approval on June 6 triggered an appeals process.
July 9, 2025

Big Ten, Big 12 Commissioners Remain Far Apart on CFP’s Future

A decision on expansion must be made by December.