• Loading stock data...
Sunday, May 26, 2024

House v. NCAA Settlement Doesn’t Address Biggest Question for Athletes

  • The case puts the NCAA and power conferences on the hook for billions in damages, but it’s not the biggest threat to the NCAA.
  • A settlement in the case would have no bearing on whether athletes should be considered employees.
Petre Thomas-USA TODAY Sports

On Monday night, ESPN reported that parties were making progress with settlement negotiations in the House v. NCAA case over name, image, and likeness—which many in the industry consider to be the most immediate threat to the NCAA’s financial stability, given that the governing body and Power 5 conferences are facing around $5 billion in damages. Front Office Sports can confirm that multiple college industry leaders expected parties to settle. (The main attorney for plaintiffs, Jeffrey Kessler, declined to comment when reached by FOS; the NCAA did not respond to a request for comment.)

Employment Status Unresolved

A settlement could allow players to receive a cut of the billions of dollars generated by television revenue for the first time in NCAA history. But it wouldn’t address college sports’ biggest existential question: athlete employee status. The House case doesn’t deal with employee classification at all; even its revenue-sharing mandates would apply to athletes only in power conference schools. 

The case, first filed in 2020 by named plaintiff Grant House, a former Arizona State swimmer, among others, would facilitate revenue sharing in a creative way. The defendants in the case include the NCAA, as well as the Pac-12, ACC, SEC, Big Ten, and Big 12 conferences. It argues that NIL’s definition should be expanded in multiple directions, most notably to allow athletes to receive a cut of TV revenue that would be considered “broadcast NIL rights.” Judge Claudia Wilken, who also presided over major antitrust cases O’Bannon and Alston, certified three damage classes last fall, hence the multibillion-dollar damages price tag.

Revenue-Sharing Dilemma

A settlement would mandate back-pay to damage classes, as well as force Power 5 conferences into a revenue-sharing framework that could provide $20 million per school to athletes, according to ESPN. But the reforms would stop there. There’s a growing sentiment across the NCAA that rich schools should share revenue with athletes, but the belief isn’t completely altruistic. They hope to pay players but still call them amateurs—that allowing revenue sharing will placate reformers who have been pushing for athletes to be deemed employees. 

The panic around paying damages in the House case has put it at the forefront of industry leaders’ minds. But employment classification is the NCAA’s biggest bogeyman—the real death knell to its amateurism model. Employee status would force schools to not only pay players salaries but also provide employee-related benefits and make schools and the NCAA potentially liable for workers’ compensation (something it has specifically fought against for decades). It would also allow athletes to attempt to formally unionize and collectively bargain with schools, conferences, and the NCAA, just like pro athletes do with their leagues. 

Multiple cases in federal court and at the National Labor Relations Board are already progressing toward at least some group of NCAA athletes being deemed professionals. The Dartmouth men’s basketball team’s unionization effort has perhaps progressed the farthest.

As for long-term consequences, the House case pales in comparison.

Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Jan 11, 2024; Paris, FRANCE; NBA commissioner Adam Silver speaks before a NBA Game between the Brooklyn Nets and the Cleveland Cavaliers at AccorHotels Arena.

Adam Silver Is the Real Winner in the Battle for the NBA’s Rights Future

For the past decade, the commissioner has been playing chess, not checkers.
NCAA headquarters in Indianapolis. Ncaahall 311477 Jpg

From Revenue-Sharing to Private Equity: Breaking Down the NCAA’s Historic Week

Commercialization of college sports has never been more evident than this week.
May 22, 2024; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Timberwolves guard Anthony Edwards (5) controls the ball against Dallas Mavericks forward Derrick Jones Jr. (55) in the fourth quarter during game one of the western conference finals for the 2024 NBA playoffs at Target Center.

NBA Media-Rights Talks ‘in Fourth Quarter.’ Here’s What We Know

NBA heads into Memorial Day weekend without a new set of deals.

Not Every MLS Team Gets to Strike Gold With a Messi Visit

Lionel Messi won’t play in Saturday’s match against the Whitecaps.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

French Open Marks Transition in Tennis


Featured Today


‘This Is Semi-Pro’: Inside One Arena Football League Team’s Collapse

The collapse of the Georgia Force, as told by the players who lived it.
Michael Block signs autographs on the 18th hole during day three of practice for the PGA Championship at Valhalla Golf Club on Wednesday, May 15, 2024.
May 19, 2024

‘I Prefer It This Way’: How Life Works for PGA Club Pros

Here’s how life works for the qualifiers at golf’s second major.
February 5, 2019; Washington, DC, USA; The grounds of the Capitol Building empty out following the conclusion of President Donald Trump's State of the Union speech on February 5, 2019.
May 18, 2024

‘A Breathtaking Lobbying Campaign’: The NCAA’s Sophisticated Effort to Save Amateurism

Inside the carefully coordinated, multimillion-dollar operation to end the athletes’ rights era.
May 14, 2024

The WNBA Was Forged in Houston. Why Won’t It Go Back There?

Houston’s a perfect fit for expansion. The league isn’t considering it yet.


Powered By

Careers in Sports

Looking for a new job? Check out these featured listings and search for openings all over the world.
EA Sports
Multiple - USA Careers
Multiple - USA Careers
Multiple - USA Careers
Michigan defensive back Mike Sainristil celebrates a play against Washington during the second half of the national championship game at NRG Stadium in Houston on Monday, Jan. 8, 2024.

NCAA, Power Conferences Approve Settlement to Allow for Revenue Sharing

NCAA, power conferences will split $2.7B in damages to thousands of athletes.
May 21, 2024

NIL’s Next Frontier: Players Suing Coaches and Boosters

Florida coach Billy Napier is being sued by Jaden Rashada, a 20-year-old quarterback.
May 22, 2024

Private Equity Set to Enter College Sports for First Time in NCAA History

Collegiate Athletic Solutions could facilitate the first private equity deal into a collegiate athletic department.

Major League Rugby’s Vision for American Rugby

How Major League Rugby is leading the Rugby renaissance in the U.S.
May 21, 2024

Lawsuit: Florida Football Coaches Made False NIL Promises

The quarterback says UF backed out of a $13.85 million NIL agreement.
Inside NCAA Headquarters located in Indianapolis on Friday, March 10, 2023. Ncaa President Charlie Baker
May 21, 2024

Power Conferences, NCAA Mull Historic Settlement to Share Revenue With Players

The agreement would include $2.7 billion over 10 years to former D-I athletes.
May 14, 2024

Pac-12 Finally Inks Football Media Deal With Just Two Members

The two-member ‘conference’ signed one-year deals with Fox Sports and The CW. 
Nov 25, 2023; Pasadena, California, USA; Helmets at the line of scrimmage as UCLA Bruins long snapper Beau Gardner (60) snaps the ball against the California Golden Bears at the Rose Bowl.
May 10, 2024

UCLA Might Have to Pay $10M a Year to Subsidize Cal Athletics

UC Board of Regents will consider approving a proposal for mandated subsidies.