• Loading stock data...
Saturday, July 19, 2025

House v. NCAA Settlement Doesn’t Address Biggest Question for Athletes

  • The case puts the NCAA and power conferences on the hook for billions in damages, but it’s not the biggest threat to the NCAA.
  • A settlement in the case would have no bearing on whether athletes should be considered employees.
Petre Thomas-USA TODAY Sports

On Monday night, ESPN reported that parties were making progress with settlement negotiations in the House v. NCAA case over name, image, and likeness—which many in the industry consider to be the most immediate threat to the NCAA’s financial stability, given that the governing body and Power 5 conferences are facing around $5 billion in damages. Front Office Sports can confirm that multiple college industry leaders expected parties to settle. (The main attorney for plaintiffs, Jeffrey Kessler, declined to comment when reached by FOS; the NCAA did not respond to a request for comment.)

Employment Status Unresolved

A settlement could allow players to receive a cut of the billions of dollars generated by television revenue for the first time in NCAA history. But it wouldn’t address college sports’ biggest existential question: athlete employee status. The House case doesn’t deal with employee classification at all; even its revenue-sharing mandates would apply to athletes only in power conference schools. 

The case, first filed in 2020 by named plaintiff Grant House, a former Arizona State swimmer, among others, would facilitate revenue sharing in a creative way. The defendants in the case include the NCAA, as well as the Pac-12, ACC, SEC, Big Ten, and Big 12 conferences. It argues that NIL’s definition should be expanded in multiple directions, most notably to allow athletes to receive a cut of TV revenue that would be considered “broadcast NIL rights.” Judge Claudia Wilken, who also presided over major antitrust cases O’Bannon and Alston, certified three damage classes last fall, hence the multibillion-dollar damages price tag.

Revenue-Sharing Dilemma

A settlement would mandate back-pay to damage classes, as well as force Power 5 conferences into a revenue-sharing framework that could provide $20 million per school to athletes, according to ESPN. But the reforms would stop there. There’s a growing sentiment across the NCAA that rich schools should share revenue with athletes, but the belief isn’t completely altruistic. They hope to pay players but still call them amateurs—that allowing revenue sharing will placate reformers who have been pushing for athletes to be deemed employees. 

The panic around paying damages in the House case has put it at the forefront of industry leaders’ minds. But employment classification is the NCAA’s biggest bogeyman—the real death knell to its amateurism model. Employee status would force schools to not only pay players salaries but also provide employee-related benefits and make schools and the NCAA potentially liable for workers’ compensation (something it has specifically fought against for decades). It would also allow athletes to attempt to formally unionize and collectively bargain with schools, conferences, and the NCAA, just like pro athletes do with their leagues. 

Multiple cases in federal court and at the National Labor Relations Board are already progressing toward at least some group of NCAA athletes being deemed professionals. The Dartmouth men’s basketball team’s unionization effort has perhaps progressed the farthest.

As for long-term consequences, the House case pales in comparison.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Ryan Field Construction
exclusive

First Look Inside Northwestern’s $862 Million New Ryan Field

Five big things FOS learned on our exclusive stadium tour.
(NCL_OSU_11_SUGAR_LAURON 04JAN11) Ohio State Buckeyes quarterback Terrelle Pryor (2) slips around the Arkansas Razorbacks defense during first half of the Sugar Bowl at the Louisiana Superdome in New Orleans, January 4, 2011.

Terrelle Pryor’s Case for NIL Backpay Dismissed in Court

Pryor played seven years in the NFL after leaving OSU amid a scandal.

Golf’s Prize Money Boom Is Slowing Down

There is no purse increase at The Open Championship.

Featured Today

Jul 21, 2024; Ayrshire, SCT; Xander Schauffele celebrates with Claret Jug after winning the Open Championship golf tournament at Royal Troon.

The Boozy History and Traditions of The Open’s Claret Jug

The Open awards the world’s most famous wine decanter.
2025 PDC World Darts Championship Final - Luke Littler vs Michael Van Gerwen
July 16, 2025

A Teen Darts Prodigy Is Becoming Bigger Than the Game Itself

Luke ‘The Nuke’ Littler is cashing in on his devastatingly accurate shot.
May 31, 2025; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Sydney McLaughin-Levrone (USA) reacts before the women's 100m hurdles during the Grand Slam Track Philadelphia at Franklin Field
exclusive
July 13, 2025

Track’s New Money Is Running Into Old Problems

The sport’s big-money era has hit some speed bumps in 2025.
Bobbleheads are seen at Vintage Indy Sports, Tuesday, April 29, 2025 in Speedway. The local sports memorabilia store opened recently.
July 12, 2025

Baseball’s Bobbleheads Are the Center of the Collectibles Universe

Baseball’s most important keepsake drives long lines—and big business.
Mar 21, 2025; Seattle, WA, USA; Memphis Tigers head coach Penny Hardaway walks off the court after losing to Colorado State Rams at Climate Pledge Arena.

Memphis Basketball and Softball Placed on NCAA Probation

Memphis has had multiple NCAA issues since hiring Penny Hardaway.
July 16, 2025

Alabama’s New Era Contends With NIL—and Nick Saban Rumors

Kalen DeBoer is entering his second season as head coach.
Sep 28, 2024; Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA; GOP Presidential candidate Donald Trump waves flanked by former Georgia Bulldogs player Herschel Walker, recording art Kid Rock, professional golfer John Daily, Alabama senators Tommy Tuberville (R) and Katie Britt (R) during the second half of the game between the Alabama Crimson Tide and the Georgia Bulldogs at Bryant-Denny Stadium.
July 16, 2025

President Trump Is Actively Working on an NIL-Related Executive Order

It’s unclear what the executive order would include.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
Texas Head Coach Steve Sarkisian waits to lead his team out of the tunnel ahead of the Longhorns' game against the Baylor Bears, Saturday, Sept. 23 at McLane Stadium in Waco.
July 15, 2025

Is a Texas Takeover About to Hit the SEC, On and Off..

The Longhorns are favored to win the SEC in their second year in the conference.
Georgia takes the field for the first half of the SEC championship game against Texas in Atlanta, on Saturday, Dec. 7, 2024.
July 15, 2025

SEC Lands Starring Role in Netflix College Football Docuseries

Netflix brings its sports storytelling to the heart of SEC football.
May 15, 2025; Washington, DC, USA; United States Capitol seen as People rally outside the Supreme Court before justices hears oral arguments in Trump v. CASA, Inc. At issue in the case is if the Supreme Court should stay the district courts' nationwide preliminary injunctions on the Trump administration’s executive order ending birthright citizenship.
July 15, 2025

Pro-NCAA Bill Takes First Step Toward Being Introduced on House Floor for..

It could be the first bill of its kind to make it to the House floor.