• Loading stock data...
Saturday, May 24, 2025

New Suit Alleges Fanatics ‘Monopoly’ Increased Trading Card Prices 

The suit borrows heavily from an earlier one filed by rival trading card company Panini. Fanatics blasted it as “baseless” and “fundamentally flawed.”

A set of trading cards
Journal Sentinel

A new lawsuit claims Fanatics and its partners in U.S. pro sports illegally monopolized the trading card market, increasing prices for consumers.

Antitrust lawsuits are old hat in sports, and Fanatics is already embroiled in very similar litigation brought by trading card competitor Panini. What makes the latest iteration notable is the breadth of the defendants. The list includes Michael Rubin’s sprawling company as well as the NBA, NHL, and NFL; unions for players in all three leagues; and the group licensing venture OneTeam. 

The suit claims the defendants conspired to drive competitors out of business and raise prices. 

Many, if not most, of the allegations in the 47-page complaint are also found in the Panini lawsuit, which a federal judge recently gave the green light to proceed. Some law firms will piggyback on existing suits and file similar cases after a motion to dismiss fails, which recently happened in the Panini suit.

“This baseless complaint is fundamentally flawed in numerous respects and we look forward to presenting to the court how we continue to elevate and enhance the collecting experience by relentlessly focusing on collectors,” Fanatics said in a statement to Front Office Sports. 

The man who filed the new lawsuit is an Austin resident named Robert Scaturo. Lawyer John Radice, who is representing Scaturo, emailed, “I don’t have anything to add on the record other than what’s in the complaint.”

The core of both lawsuits: In 2021, Fanatics began acquiring trading card licenses from the leagues and union by signing 10- to 20-year contracts, offering equity as an inducement to do the deal.

By 2026, the latest lawsuit alleges, Fanatics will control 100% of the trading card market.

“​​The collective equity stake of the Leagues and players associations (plus NHL and MLS) is worth approximately $5 to $10 billion,” the complaint alleges. “In this way, Fanatics and each of the leagues and each of their player associations agreed to split the monopoly profits caused by the anticompetitive agreements.”

According to the lawsuit, prices for MLB cards from Topps—which Fanatics acquired in 2022—have risen 50% since 2021, while Panini cards remained flat or declined. A chart in the complaint, however, shows Panini prices declining before the Topps acquisition and rising afterward. Fanatics’s rights for NBA cards begin in September.

The new suit claims Fanatics bought the printer company that Panini used for 90% of its cards, and then slowed down deliveries to the competitor. Fanatics is also charged with using its market power to require local card shops to accept minimum price requirements or be cut off from supply, withholding supply to shops that sell trading cards on business-to-business websites, and forcing case breakers onto Fanatics’ new case-breaking platform. (Case-breakers are influencers who stream opening packages of cards.)

“Fanatics has successfully foreclosed one hundred percent of the market for Major U.S. Professional Sports Leagues trading cards for the next decade at least,” the complaint charges. “Rivals have been sidelined due to these exclusive agreements and consumers will suffer.”

The Panini case focuses on alleged moves by Fanatics to oust its Texas-based rival from the marketplace; the new suit, a consumer class-action case, is brought on behalf of all consumers who bought trading cards from one of the defendants starting Jan. 1, 2022, and until the alleged conduct ceases. 

As is typical at this early stage of litigation, the complaint does not include a damages figure, an amount that emerges far closer to trial. The complaint also asks for injunctive relief, meaning the court orders Fanatics to cease its allegedly monopolistic practices.

The complaint, which borrows heavily from the Panini complaint—down to including charges that were dismissed last week—also alleges:

  • Fanatics raided Panini’s staff “using threats and false statements to poach dozens of Panini’s employees. … Fanatics threatened to blacklist Panini employees from ever working in the industry again when Fanatics’ exclusive long-term licenses took effect unless they immediately quit Panini and joined Fanatics.”
  • Fanatics used these raids as an inducement to get the NFL Players Association in 2023 to end its deal with Panini three years early. An arbitrator would later order the union to pay Panini $7 million in damages.
  • “Fanatics strong-armed athletes to refuse agreements with Panini, using a similar combination of payoffs and threats. For example, Fanatics threatened that players would never get an autograph deal when Fanatics’ long-term contracts took effect in the future unless they immediately signed with Fanatics.”
  • Fanatics used its “monopoly” power to cut off sales of worn jerseys to Panini. 

Trading cards require a license from both the league—for team and league intellectual property—and the players, for NIL (name, image, and likeness) rights. With trading cards, the players’ rights are ceded to the players’ unions for group licensing. Unions for players in the NFL and MLB have used OneTeam in recent years to sell those rights.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Mar 23, 2025; Miami, FL, USA; Alexandra Eala (PHI) reacts after winning a point against Madison Keys (USA)(not pictured) on day six of the Miami Open at Hard Rock Stadium.

Alex Eala Is Defying Her Country’s Odds to Make French Open History

The Philippines native has overcome a unique set of financial odds.
Jaren Jackson

All-NBA Vote Costs Jaren Jackson Jr. $200 Million

Jackson missed out on a five-year, $345 million contract extension. 
Former President Donald Trump leads a campaign rally at Mullett Arena at Arizona State University in Tempe on Oct. 24, 2024.

Sports Owner Tax Perk in Crosshairs As Bill Moves Forward

The provision would eliminate certain tax breaks for pro sports owners.

Featured Today

Around the Horn - October 26, 2020

‘Quirky, Nutty, Bombastic’: 10 ‘Around the Horn’ Faces on Their Top Moments

“A quirky, nutty, bombastic, mostly wrong, sometimes right, crazy sports family.”
AA Mint Cards
May 18, 2025

Young Collectors Are on a High-Stakes Chase for Ultra-Rare Trading Cards

“They just want that excitement of the chase,” says a 23-year-old collector.
Donnie Gobourne JDL
May 17, 2025

U.S. Professional Softball Players Are Flocking to Japan to Get Paid

The Diamond League offers paychecks and amenities that the U.S. can’t beat.
Jun 1996; Seattle, WA USA; FILE PHOTO; Seattle Supersonics guard Gary Payton (20) lays the ball up against the Chicago Bulls during the 1996 NBA Finals at Key Arena.
May 15, 2025

5,000 Pieces of Thunder History Are Hidden in Seattle

Sonics championship banners, trophies, and retired jerseys are all in one place.
Mar 23, 2024; New York, New York, USA; Sneakers worn by New York Knicks guard Jalen Brunson (11) during warmups prior to the game against the Brooklyn Nets at Madison Square Garden.

Nike to Raise Prices on Sneakers Above $100

Kids products and Air Force 1s won’t be affected.
May 15, 2025

20 Hats Per Minute: Merch Madness Hits PGA Championship

Headwear is among the most popular items selling in Charlotte.
Arc'teryx
May 20, 2025

Expensive Outdoor Gear Is Bright Spot Amid Tariff Turmoil

Amer Sports says tariffs will have a “negligible” impact on its results.
Sponsored

Hottest Matchups Following NFL Schedule Release

The NFL released the 2025 regular-season schedule, and anticipation is already building in the ticket marketplace with four months to go.
On-Running
May 14, 2025

On Says It’s Raising Prices—but Not Because of Tariffs

“We want to be the most premium performance sportswear brand,” On’s cofounder said.
Soar
May 12, 2025

Running Is a Bright Spot As Retailers Reel From Trump Tariffs

Sales of running shoes rose 7% in the first quarter.
A'ja Wilson
May 6, 2025

Why Nike Wanted A’ja Wilson’s New Shoe to Sell Out in Minutes

Nike gave fans a taste of the A’Ones with a limited drop.
Michelle Wie West
exclusive
May 6, 2025

Michelle Wie West Is Latest Athlete to Invest in Togethxr

The brand tripled its revenue year over year and is profitable.