• Loading stock data...
Wednesday, October 29, 2025
Want a chance to win $250 and free FOS gear? Take our quick reader survey. Take the survey here

Power 5 Players Re-Raise Question of College Athlete Union

  • Experts disagree regarding whether legal precedent exists for college athletes to unionize.
  • If athletes can organize and boycott, they may not need unions to satisfy demands.
Stephen Lew-USA TODAY Sports

On August 11, Pac-12 officials sat on a Zoom press conference explaining that science would prevent them from hosting sports this fall. 

But later that evening, a group of Pac-12 football players released a statement saying that rather than science, it was a lack of leadership, communication and serious planning for player safety that kept the conference from fall sports. 

“The system is broken,” the letter read. “College athletes deserve and need a real voice in the form of a players association.”

The week the Pac-12 and Big Ten decided to postpone fall sports seasons has also brought perhaps the most potent movement for college athletes to unionize since the Northwestern football team’s attempt in 2014. 

Letters from Pac-12 and Big Ten conference football players and graphics circulated on Twitter by Power 5 players raised questions about whether the current climate might finally spawn a college football players union — and whether athletes still need a recognized union to gain power at all.

“In this moment, these student athletes are finding a way to leverage their power and their strengths, which is essentially [that] they are the building blocks of this extraordinarily lucrative financial system,” said Jeremi Duru, a law professor at the American University Washington College of Law. Players will still have plenty of negotiating power for a potential spring season, Duru said, because even a reduced season could still rake in millions for college athletic departments.

On August 2, a group of Pac-12 players published a list of demands under the #WeAreUnited hashtag that demanded their conference offer revenue sharing with players, racial justice initiatives and enhanced safety precautions to prevent the spread of COVID-19. Pac-12 players threatened to boycott the college football season if their demands weren’t met. 

A few days later, Big Ten players released a similar list of demands regarding player safety during COVID-19. Both groups have accused their conference officials of not adequately communicating with players about their plans and said that they genuinely wanted to play this fall but were concerned about safety measures. 

Early on August 10, Clemson quarterback Trevor Lawrence, along with several other players, published a sleek graphic under the title “#WeAreUnited X #WeWantToPlay” on Twitter that represented players across Power 5 conferences, and also demanded a college football player’s association.

It’s a “perfect storm” for college football players to finally be able to create a union, Carla Varriale-Barker, a shareholder at the law firm Segal, McCambridge, Singer, and Mahoney and chair of the firm’s sports, recreation and entertainment practice group, wrote in an email. Duru called the momentum the most he’s seen in a “generation.”

college-sports-sponsors

College Teams And Sponsors Push Digital To Grow Without Sports

Many aspects of the sports industry are struggling to adjust to the…
May 19, 2020

Experts disagree on whether the National Labor Relations Board’s rejection of a 2014 proposal by Northwestern football players to create a union left any possibility for college athletes to receive national union recognition in the future. In order for a union to be recognized, the organized group must be made up of employees. 

At the time, the NLRB only stipulated that allowing Northwestern players to unionize but not other teams in the conference might create “instability,” said Marc Edelman, a law professor at the Zicklin School of Business at Baruch College. 

Varriale-Barker said of the Northwestern decision: “The door may have closed, but it was not slammed shut.”  

Edelman said that there still might be a possibility of an official union given that the NLRB had also voted in favor of recognizing research and teaching assistants as capable of unionizing, meaning precedent could exist for college athletes to be considered employees. 

Duru said that a possibility may lie in a memo released in 2017, in which the NLRB’s general council stated that college athletes in private institutions can be considered university employees, which bodes well for athletes at private colleges who seek national union recognition. Public school athletes, said Duru, could be recognized through state labor relations boards.

On the other hand, Michael LeRoy, a law professor at the University of Illinois, said that the possibility of NLRB-recognized college athlete unions is dead for good.

Forming a union is important for obtaining not just monetary compensation — in the college sports sense, the power to negotiate name, image and likeness deals — but also safe working conditions, said Varriale-Barker. But it may not be necessary for college football players to attain significant bargaining power with NCAA governing bodies. Current unofficial organizing efforts are already yielding results.

Duru cited the example of FSU star Marvin Wilson, who threatened a team boycott after his coach had falsely claimed he had approached athletes individually to reflect on the murder of George Floyd by police and received national attention as a result. Wilson proved that college athletes can single-handedly provoke conversations in their institutions regarding racial justice simply with their Twitter feeds.

LeRoy said that boycotting remains college athletes’ most effective tool in bartering with the NCAA anyway. And the NCAA did pledge to meet a few of the demands made by the Pac-12 players who threatened to boycott before the conference postponement fiasco began. If players go so far as boycotting a season, whether it be in the fall or the spring, “the NCAA member schools will have to deal with the embarrassment of a college football season featuring primarily replacement players,” Edelman said.

There’s even a historical precedent for college athletes to organize and threaten to boycott a season without “official” union recognition, said LeRoy, as strikes and boycotts have existed much longer than the NLRB itself.

Regardless of whether organized athletes are officially recognized as a union, Duru, LeRoy and Edelman agreed that a league-wide organizing effort among athletes in revenue-generating sports would be most effective. 

The NCAA, of course, has historically opposed college football unions. NCAA representatives spoke out against unionization during the Northwestern case, and Edelman noted that the governing body’s proposal to Congress to gain control of NIL regulations specifically stipulated that college athletes could not be considered employees, and therefore could not unionize. 

But the current player organizing efforts and ripe climate for athletes to unionize may be too forceful for the NCAA to stop, Edelman said. “When the NCAA member colleges and especially the Power 5 colleges showed such extreme indifference on the financial and health well-being of college athletes, they made their bed in a way that seems irreversible.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Sankey

SEC’s Sankey Blasts NCAA Plan to Allow Pro Sports Betting

NCAA athletes can bet on professional sports starting Nov. 1.

SEC Coaches Kiffin, Smart Question LSU’s Firing of Kelly: ‘Ridiculous’ 

Three SEC teams have fired their football coaches midseason.
Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry speaks to an audience at Louisiana Tech University on Aug. 25, 2025.

Why Louisiana’s Governor Was Involved in the Brian Kelly Firing

Jeff Landry reportedly hosted a meeting at the governor’s mansion Sunday.

Featured Today

September 21, 2025; Santa Clara, California, USA; NFL commissioner Roger Goodell before the game between the San Francisco 49ers and the Arizona Cardinals at Levi's Stadium

NFL Fall Meeting: 7 Big Topics Among Team Owners 

Media, facilities, and labor highlight some of the key areas of concern.
Ohio State Buckeyes running back Isaiah West (32) runs the ball in the second half at Camp Randall Stadium on Saturday, Oct. 18, 2025 in Madison, Wisconsin
October 25, 2025

NIL Has Birthed a Third-Party Cottage Industry—and It’s a Mess

There’s no limit to how much players can make from NIL deals.
Christie's
October 21, 2025

Lou Gehrig’s $4M Jersey and the Exploding Sports Memorabilia Market

An ultra-rare sports collection is about to hit the auction block.
@chef__tezz/Instagram
October 19, 2025

Inside the NFL’s Private Chef Network

Private chefs are the unsung architects of player performance.
Brian Kelly

CFB Firings Tracker: LSU Owes Brian Kelly $53 Million

The sum owed Kelly slightly tops James Franklin’s at Penn State. 
October 26, 2025

LSU Ends Brian Kelly Era, $53M Buyout Negotiations Underway

The Tigers fell to 5–3 after losing to Texas A&M.
Tigers Head Coach Brian Kelly, LSU Tigers take on the Texas A&M Aggies. October 25, 2025; Baton Rouge, Louisiana, USA; at Tiger Stadium. Saturday, Oct. 25, 2025.
October 27, 2025

College Football Coach Buyouts Are Not What They Seem

LSU will likely not have to pay Kelly the $53 million he has left on his contract.
Sponsored

Why Alexis Ohanian Is Betting Big on Women’s Sports

Alexis Ohanian reflects on his evolution from Reddit cofounder to one of today’s most dynamic sports investors.
October 26, 2025

Revenue-Sharing Era’s New Powers: Indiana, Georgia Tech, and Vandy

Indiana is the most notable, having ascended to No. 2.
October 26, 2025

Sarkisian, Kiffin Address Rumors As Coaching Carousel Spins Again

Reports are rampant about the coaches taking new jobs.
Azzi Fudd
October 24, 2025

Government Shutdown Moves UConn Season Opener Out of Germany

The shutdown is now on its 24th day.
Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia (2) celebrates following the game between Vanderbilt University and Louisiana State University at FirstBank Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., Saturday, Oct. 18, 2025
exclusive
October 24, 2025

Diego Pavia Is Trying to Kill NCAA JUCO Eligibility Rules for Good

Vandy’s QB is amending his own lawsuit to encompass all NCAA athletes.