• Loading stock data...
Wednesday, April 2, 2025
Nominations Are Open for Front Office Sports Honors! Submit Now

Can Any League Topple the NCAA?

Over $9 billion dollars is expected to be wagered illegally on March Madness. (Photo via Pexels)

The debate over the NCAA and its power has only intesified. (Photo via Pexels)

Perhaps no sports organization has seen the changes that the NCAA has – originally formed to support and protect student-athletes in football, the NCAA now boasts over $1B in TV revenue.

Consider this quote from the late Professor Judson P. Welch, of Penn State University:

“I believe that the man who needs money to go through college should be allowed to play Summer ball, in just the same manner as he would do anything else for a living.”

These motives have drastically shifted in recent years, where the NCAA has amassed massive power – and participation by an athlete can determine whether or not they earn a spot in a professional league. As such, the NCAA now exerts monopsony power.

Similar to monopolies, monopsony power is characterized by markets in which one large buyer commands the entire market – in the NCAA’s case, young athletes supply their labor.

The NCAA forbids colleges from paying their athletes – effectively fixing prices. Here, the NCAA also acts as a cartel – a market in which competitors agree to fix their prices in the interest of generating monopoly (or monopsony) profits for all parties.


The NCAA’s Influence

In business, we have seen monopolies being toppled by competitors – traditionally via low-end disruption, where smaller, more agile competitors win through product innovations.

In basketball, we have seen evidence of this change – probably spurred by its large talent pool of players, spanning the entire globe.

This has led to many professional leagues across the world, which act as an alternative for high-end draft prospects, as well as a full-fledged development league for the NBA. In recent years, more athletes have been taking advantage of these opportunities – such as the Ball brothers in Vytautas in Lithuania.

Basketball’s international growth has also led to an influx of international scouts – who travel across the globe to watch young players in international professional leagues.

However, the NCAA maintains their outsize influence – largely due to brand and exposure; and for a labor market that is highly commoditized (i.e.: the bulk of athletes fall within the margin of error – meaning that the difference between being drafted and not being drafted can purely come down to luck), the extra visibility can be extremely valuable.

In other words – in exchange for working for free, athletes effectively invest in their future. Given that getting drafted into the NBA is a low probability event, it is likely that athletes experience increasing returns to scale simply by playing in the NCAA.

This leads to the vast majority of promising young athletes opting to play in the NCAA, rather than its competitors (from a labor perspective).

The current market, where there are many commoditized suppliers (athletes), and few buyers (the NCAA), can indeed change – and to date, there have been two legitimate competitors.


The NBA’s G League

The G League stands as a legitimate competitor to the NCAA, due to its affiliation with the NBA. And to be clear, it stands as perhaps the strongest alternative for high school athletes. Though player salaries are capped at $100K, the NBA’s orthogonal strategy, which only includes the G League, means that the G League has no intention of sustaining a standalone league.

In other words, due to the NBA’s core business being the NBA, the G League will continue to have a greater margin for error. Additionally, the influx of cash can come from alternative sources – a chief competitive advantage, relative to the NCAA.

On the other hand, the NBA differs from similar companies in other industries because its revenue in 2017 was only $7.37B (largely coming from the NBA, rather than its associated properties). While profits are not disclosed, we can safely assume that their size limits them from acting as a true orthogonal player – a notable example of this being Google, who famously lose money on many of their businesses.

Meaning – that there is a risk that the NBA does not have the capital to flesh out a true NCAA competitor, lest it grows at an unprecedented rate.


International Leagues

International leagues also stand as a legitimate option for high school players, since it offers both a high level of competition and high salaries. However, and even factoring in the progress in international scouting, there still exist large frictions on all sides.

Players will have to move to a new country at a young age, and more scouts will still be watching American games (greatly reducing the value of international leagues to the marginal player).

As such, international leagues, unless there is a greater talent boom internationally, forcing more scouts to watch international games, will stand as an option for high-profile prospects – rather than one for the common one.


Effects of Many Competitors

The ideal outcome is for there to be many competitors to the NCAA – which dilutes its influence. Inefficiency is an outcome of a monopsonistic market, and a greater number of competitors would nudge it towards efficiency.

As it stands, the NCAA still has a large influence – much of this being due to media attention and branding. However, for many years, its competitive advantage also included relatively greater scouting attention, a high level of competition, and access to world-class training facilities – all of which have been chipped at by their competitors.

We’re looking at a long-run outcome here, but there is a good chance that competitors will eventually arise, bringing efficiency to the market and reducing the NCAA’s influence.

Important to note: the NBA’s potential expansion into prospects may not result in a positive long-run outcome for athletes. Though on the demand side, the NBA faces competition from other leagues and sources of revenue, athletes may not fare as well – something we have seen play out in baseball.

Assuming that they act as a profit-maximizing firm, this would grow the NBA’s market power even further, which results in a similar outcome that we see in college basketball today – inefficiency, leading to a less-than-optimal situation for athletes alike.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Mar 26, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Los Angeles Lakers forward LeBron James (23) in the first half Indiana Pacers at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.

The Creator Behind the LeBron ‘Glazing’ Trend Sweeping TikTok

FOS spoke to TikTok user OkaySpade who made the original song.
Laney-Hamilton

WNBA Champion Missing Season Shows Risks and Kinks of Unrivaled

The Liberty have six weeks to make a decision on Betnijah Laney-Hamilton.
Mar 30, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Detroit Pistons center Isaiah Stewart (28) reacts after a fight against the Minnesota Timberwolves during the second quarter at Target Center. Stewart was later ejected from the game.

NBA Lightly Suspends Five Players for Timberwolves-Pistons Brawl

The brawl came in a game where 12 technical fouls were issued.

Featured Today

Seattle Kraken

Samantha Holloway Is Seattle’s NHL Present—and Hopeful NBA Future

Samantha Holloway is steering the Kraken and hoping to revive pro hoops.
Brehanna Daniels
March 31, 2025

NASCAR Pit Crew Member Brehanna Daniels Didn’t Know She’d Be a Trailblazer

The first Black female tire changer didn’t know she’d be a trailblazer.
Columbia, SC - February 16, 2025 - Colonial Life Arena: Rebecca Lobo and Ryan Ruocco during a regular season game.
March 30, 2025

Inside Ryan Ruocco’s Rapid Rise to ESPN’s Top Voice of Women’s Hoops

The top voice became “quickly addicted” to calling the women’s game.
Mar 27, 2025; Newark, NJ, USA; Alabama Crimson Tide guard Chris Youngblood (8) and the Alabama Crimson Tide bench celebrate during the second half against the Brigham Young Cougars during an East Regional semifinal of the 2025 NCAA tournament at Prudential Center.
March 29, 2025

How Alabama Became College Basketball’s Newest Juggernaut

The Crimson Tide have found success rivaling their historic football program.
FIFA

Saudis Awarded 2034 World Cup in Uncontested Vote

Saudi Arabia was the only option after Australia decided not to bid.
May 20, 2024

Top Sports Business Jobs This Week (May 2024)

Each week, our staff combs through the thousands of job listings from…
The stands at the Solheim Cup
September 13, 2024

LPGA Apologizes for Solheim Cup Fan Bus Debacle That Left Stands Half-Empty

The USA-Europe women’s team golf event teed off Friday morning.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
October 3, 2022

Real Madrid President Renews Call for Super League

Real Madrid’s president believes that soccer is losing ground.
August 10, 2022

PGA Tour Touts Projected Earnings to Keep Players

The PGA Tour is asking its players to consider their potential futures.
August 10, 2022

Bayern Munich to Make Growth Push in U.S. Market

Bayern Munich is looking to expand its reach in the U.S.
Nintendo-logo
August 3, 2022

Nintendo Profits Underwhelm, Switch Sales Decline

Nintendo failed to meet expectations in the company’s latest earnings report.