• Loading stock data...
Friday, December 13, 2024

NCAA Asks Supreme Court to Review Alston Case

  • The NCAA requested that the Supreme Court review a circuit court ruling that found the NCAA violated antitrust law.
  • The NCAA is currently looking to gain antitrust exemption in Congress.
alston-supreme-court-request
Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports

The NCAA has issued a request to the Supreme Court to review a circuit court ruling in the case Alston v. NCAA. The ruling found that the NCAA violated antitrust law by limiting the amount of education related benefits — like money to cover the cost of computers — that athletes could procure.

The request comes during a busy news week for the Supreme Court, as the Senate Judiciary Committee holds a hearing to confirm Judge Amy Coney Barrett to fill the vacant seat left by the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 

“The [circuit court] ruling blurs the line between student-athletes and professionals, conflicts with prior appellate court decisions, appoints a single court to micromanage collegiate sports, and encourages never-ending litigation following every rule change,” NCAA Chief Legal Officer Donald Remy wrote in a statement. 

The request, filed by the NCAA and reviewed by Front Office Sports, referenced a prior Supreme Court ruling in which the court found that the amateur and student nature of college athletes differentiates it from professional sports, and therefore is essential to college sports.

“The decision below deprives the NCAA of the leeway that sports-governing bodies and joint ventures ordinarily have under antitrust law, leeway that this Court and others have recognized the NCAA needs to administer inter-collegiate athletics,” the petition said. 

One of the lead attorneys for the plaintiffs on the case, Jeffrey Kessler, told Front Office Sports in an email that he does not believe the ruling will be overturned. “We do not believe it likely that the Supreme Court will take this case, as it does not raise any new legal issues or circuit split for the Court to consider,” Kessler said. “In fact, the petition identifies the exact same legal issues previously raised by the NCAA with respect to the prior O’Bannon litigation that the NCAA lost, and the Supreme Court declined to review those issues at that time.” 

Kessler’s comments refer to a previous ruling in which the same circuit court found that the NCAA violated antitrust law when it refused to compensate college athletes for the use of their name, image and likeness in an NCAA video game. 

While it is true that the Supreme Court declines the vast majority of requests to hear cases, it is unsurprising that the NCAA is fighting the circuit court’s ruling in every way possible. Antitrust law has recently haunted the NCAA, as it could threaten the governing body’s ability to keep college athletes like men’s basketball and football players amateurs and not pay them to play sports, despite the millions they rake in each year for athletic departments.

The previous ruling also proves concerning to the governing body given that athletes will soon be allowed to profit off the use of their name, image and likeness. Outside this case, the NCAA is also currently requesting an antitrust exemption from Congress, so that the NCAA might control pending regulations regarding college athlete NIL rights, as well as rule once and for all that athletes are amateurs, and thus can’t be subject to employment law or be able to unionize. 

The original lawsuit was filed as a class action by former West Virginia running back Shawne Alston, and others, in 2014.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Sept 5, 2011; College Park, MD, USA; Maryland Terrapins fans hold up a sign referencing Miami Hurricanes former booster Nevin Shapiro during the first half at Capital One Field at Byrd Stadium.

Biden Commutes Miami Booster’s Ponzi Scheme Sentence

Nevin Shapiro gave Miami athletics millions of dollars in the early 2000s.

The Top-Secret Operation to Create the Army-Navy Football Uniforms

The two-year process includes dozens of employees, NDAs, and military historians.

Army-Navy Is Always Big. This Year’s Game Holds Special Significance

This year’s edition of America’s Game carries extra luster for several reasons.
Notre Dame

College Football Playoff on Campuses Sends Ticket, Travel Prices Soaring

Postseason games are coming to South Bend, State College, Austin, and Columbus.

Featured Today

Nov 2, 2024; Denver, Colorado, USA; Detailed view of a Wilson NBA basketball held by a referee during the second half between the Utah Jazz against the Denver Nuggets at Ball Arena

‘Obvious Weak Point’: Refs Remain an NBA Gambling Concern

A season after Jontay Porter, the biggest risk may not be players.
Nov 2, 2024; Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA; Michigan Wolverines cheerleader runs with a flag before the game against the Oregon Ducks at Michigan Stadium.
opinion
December 7, 2024

College Football’s Billionaire Backer Era Begins

Is this the new normal in CFB recruiting?
LA Galaxy forward Dejan Joveljic (9) celebrates with midfielder Riqui Puig (10) after scoring a goal against Seattle Sounders FC in the second half in the 2024 MLS Cup Western Conference Final match at Dignity Health Sports Park
December 6, 2024

With or Without Messi, Major League Soccer Is Barreling Into the Future

After the Cup final, the league looks to accelerate its growth.
Dec 18, 2022; Lusail, Qatar; FIFA president Gianni Infantino claps during the awards ceremony after the 2022 World Cup final between Argentina and France at Lusail Stadium.
December 2, 2024

FIFA Wants More Matches. Resistance Is Growing Inside the Global Soccer World

Resentment and frustration over expanded schedules is nearing a breaking point.
Georgia defensive lineman Mykel Williams (13) goes in for a sack on Texas quarterback Quinn Ewers (3) during the second half of the SEC championship game against Texas in Atlanta, on Saturday, Dec. 7, 2024.

How the CFP’s On-Campus Guinea Pigs Are Handling Historic December Home Games

The biggest games in school history will be when students are home for break.
December 12, 2024

Belichick Makes UNC Intentions Clear: ‘I Didn’t Come Here to Leave’

North Carolina formally introduced Bill Belichick on Thursday.
Dec 12, 2024; Chapel Hill, NC, USA; North Carolina Tar Heels chancellor Lee Roberts reads a transcript about new head coach Bill Belichicks’ father who served as an assistant coach at New North Carolina Tar Heels new in 1954 at Loudermilk Center for Excellence.
December 12, 2024

Belichick’s UNC Deal Contains Clause That Keeps NFL Speculation Alive

The six-time Super Bowl–winning coach will have a $10 million annual salary.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
December 12, 2024

Florida State, Still Suing ACC, Claims It Never Wanted to Leave

In court documents last December, the Seminoles said they planned to withdraw.
December 11, 2024

Bill Belichick to Take College Plunge at North Carolina

UNC made the official announcement late Wednesday.
December 11, 2024

Mountain West Adds UC Davis, Wants Northern Illinois

The Aggies’ football team will stay in the FCS.
December 10, 2024

Transfer Portal Chaos: Record Moves, Star QBs, and NIL Deals Reshape CFB

There has been unprecedented portal activity this year.