• Loading stock data...
Saturday, July 12, 2025

One Year of NIL: The Ongoing Battle for Legal Control

  • The first year of the NIL era was governed by several disjointed legal forces.
  • A year has gone by, and there’s still no more clarity, enforcement, or uniformity than there was last July.
Jenna Watson/IndyStar

The first year of the NIL era was governed by several disjointed forces: State laws, school policies, and loose NCAA guidance. Despite the NCAA’s best lobbying efforts, a federal law was absent. So was an enforcement mechanism for any of these rules.

Athletes got paid, and college sports didn’t collapse. 

But a year has gone by, and there’s still no more clarity, enforcement, or uniformity than there was last July. And pending litigation threatens not to just rewrite NIL rules, but kill amateurism altogether.

As a result, everyone from state legislators to NCAA officials are still advocating for alterations. 

At the Federal Level

College sports officials from NCAA President Mark Emmert to SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey have taken trips to Washington to beg Congress for a uniform NIL law. 

Thanks to the Alston case, the NCAA risks exposing itself to lawsuits without one. But it also wants an antitrust exemption, so that it can protect amateurism on its own, Kennyhertz Perry attorney Mit Winter told Front Office Sports.

In the next year, the NCAA probably won’t get what it wants. Anyone who has access to the news knows Congress has other priorities.

It’s also unclear whether a federal standard is necessary for the athletes themselves. It doesn’t matter to them whether there’s a federal law, as long as they’re free to profit.

In the NCAA

On June 30, 2021, the NCAA passed a short list of NIL guidelines. It did little more than try to prohibit pay-for-play and recruiting inducements.

When NIL collectives burst onto the scene, the NCAA published more guidelines. In May, it said boosters and collectives couldn’t talk to recruits or offer deals before an athlete committed. It also said it would investigate and punish violators of the policy — though it wouldn’t take away athletes’ eligibility.

The SEC reportedly has explored setting conference-specific NIL guidance — but that may or may not pass the antitrust sniff test. 

The Division I Transformation Committee will also consider division-specific rules as part of the NCAA’s new constitution process.

West Coast Conference Commissioner Gloria Nevarez, who sits on the committee, told FOS her major focus is “drawing the line” on pay-for-play. She also noted that the guidelines have to be “lived within, and not challenged every step of the way” from a legal or legislative perspective.

In the next year, legal experts believe the NCAA will punish at least one collective or school, but the scope of enforcement remains unclear.

At the State Level

The NCAA is trying to bar NIL from the recruitment process — while many state legislators are repealing or amending state laws to reduce restrictions.

Before the NCAA changed its rules, it behooved states to pass laws to ensure local athletes had NIL rights. But many of those laws had unnecessary prohibitions — like deals with alcohol companies — or barred school officials from helping athletes procure deals directly.

Legislators want to give schools as much latitude as possible to compete in recruiting. Alabama was the first — it killed its NIL law altogether. States from Connecticut to Illinois passed alterations removing certain provisions. South Carolina suspended its law for the 2022-23 fiscal year.

Even in states where NIL laws are strict, there doesn’t seem to be an enforcement mechanism. But it’s better to be safe than sorry.

“The cons far outweigh the pros when it comes to state NIL laws,” Geragos and Geragos attorney Dan Lust told FOS. “If there is no rule, how are you violating anything?”

Year 2 In Court

In the next year, litigation could change everything. 

  • In Johnson v. NCAA, athletes could be awarded collective bargaining rights — which would likely end the NCAA’s business model of amateurism altogether. 
  • It’s also likely a booster or collective could wage a lawsuit against the NCAA if it attempts to bar them from doing deals altogether, experts agree.
  • Athletes could file Title IX cases against schools that don’t offer equal education resources.

The House v. NCAA case could take longer, but its decision could be pivotal. 

Former athletes could claim damages against the governing body because they played in the pre-NIL era. Plus, NIL could be expanded to include the use of athletes’ NIL during televised games — meaning they could get a piece of media rights revenue. 

The most influential forces on the NCAA have been lawsuits, not state or federal laws. That trend will likely continue.

“The problems that we’re seeing now in NIL, they really pale in comparison to the legal obstacles and legal conflicts that are on the horizon,” Lust said. “So it’s certainly going to get worse before it gets better.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Jul 9, 2025; Frisco, TX, USA; Head coaches Willie Fritz of Houston, Mike Gundy of Oklahoma State, Rich Rodriguez of West Virginia, Lance Leipold of Kansas, Sonny Dykes of TCU, Kyle Whittingham of Utah, Brent Brennan of Arizona and Deion Sanders of Colorado all sit on stage for a Coaches Roundtable during 2025 Big 12 Football Media Days at The Star.

Big 12 Commish: Conference Is ‘All In’ on International Expansion

The conference had once planned a large initiative in Mexico.
Paige Bueckers
exclusive

Women’s March Madness Expansion Wouldn’t Yield More ESPN Money

ESPN is not required to pay extra if women’s March Madness expands.
A helmt is seen during the Texas Tech football team's spring game, Saturday, April 19, 2025, at Jones AT&T Stadium.

CFB’s Revenue-Sharing Era Muddles Future of NIL, Adds PE Questions

Athletic departments can pay college athletes a combined $20.5 million this year.
Ohio State

Collectives Funnel $20 Million to College Athletes on Last Day Before Revenue..

Collectives frontloaded payments just before the revenue sharing era begins July 1.

Featured Today

Bobbleheads are seen at Vintage Indy Sports, Tuesday, April 29, 2025 in Speedway. The local sports memorabilia store opened recently.

Baseball’s Bobbleheads Are the Center of the Collectibles Universe

Baseball’s most important keepsake drives long lines—and big business.
Rimouski, QC - JUNE 1: Final Game of the 2025 Memorial Cup between the Medicine Hats Tigers and the London Knights on June 1, 2025, at the Colisée Financière Sun Life in Rimouski, Qc.
July 11, 2025

CHL Is Facing a ‘Pandora’s Box’ of Questions Amid NCAA Talent Departure

As players defect to college, the Canadian Hockey League won’t cede ground.
Jun 28, 2025; Arlington, Texas, USA; Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh (29) bats during the game between the Texas Rangers and the Seattle Mariners at Globe Life Field.
July 9, 2025

The Torpedo Bat Business Is Still Going Strong: ‘Here to Stay’

Demand for the oddly shaped bats has stayed strong across the sport.
July 6, 2025

American Celebs Want to Be Sports Owners. Soccer Is Where They Start

As U.S. team prices climb, investors set their sights abroad.

NCAA: March Madness Expansion to 76 Teams ‘Still Viable’ for 2026

Negotiations continue with media rights holder CBS and TNT Sports.
July 10, 2025

Deion Sanders Rips ‘Bulljunk’ in CFB, Calls for NFL-Style Salary Cap

Coach Prime is frustrated with the new revenue-sharing era.
The Florida State Seminoles hosted the Florida Gators at Doak Campbell Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 30, 2024.
July 10, 2025

Athletic Departments Express Renewed Interest in PE in Wake of House Settlement

Schools now have more expenses—and are looking for creative solutions.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
Apr 4, 2025; Tampa, FL, USA; Connecticut Huskies guard KK Arnold (2)1 dribbles against UCLA Bruins forward Angela Dugalic (32) during the third quarter in a semifinal of the women's 2025 NCAA tournament at Amalie Arena.
July 10, 2025

‘Kind of a Joke’: Frustrations Mount As New NIL Deal Approval Process..

Delays have already led to athletes losing NIL opportunities.
Sebastian Rivera (R) tf. Danny Coles 6:47 (20-3). Rutgers University Wrestling vs Princeton in Piscataway, NJ on February 18, 2022.
July 9, 2025

The House Settlement Is Being Appealed. It Won’t Stop Revenue-Sharing—for Now

The settlement’s approval on June 6 triggered an appeals process.
July 9, 2025

Big Ten, Big 12 Commissioners Remain Far Apart on CFP’s Future

A decision on expansion must be made by December.
TSU Hockey at Bridgestone
July 8, 2025

Tennessee State’s HBCU Hockey Ambitions Delayed at Least a Year

The school will not launch the first-of-its-kind program as intended.