• Loading stock data...
Sunday, February 25, 2024
Rates for the 2024 Best Venue Awards increase this Sunday at 11:59 p.m. ET

With FSU Infractions Decision, NCAA Attempts the Illusion of Control

  • The NCAA found that an assistant coach facilitated a meeting between a booster and a prospective athlete, who offered an NIL deal.
  • The entire case illustrates how the NCAA wants to create an illusion of power as it increasingly loses control over its members.
Florida State
Melina Myers-USA TODAY Sports

Between a Supreme Court decision and a shift in the court of public opinion, the once-mighty NCAA has begun to lose control over college sports—and its ability to enforce its own rules. But that hasn’t stopped the governing body from plodding forward with infractions cases related to NIL, even as it continuously writes and rewrites NIL rules in order to create the illusion of power over its membership. 

On Thursday, the NCAA’s infractions committee handed down punishments to Florida State in the first-ever case in which the governing body could prove NIL was used as a recruiting inducement.

It found that an assistant coach on the FSU football team arranged a meeting with a prospective transfer and a booster, who offered the athlete a deal with an FSU collective for about $15,000 per month if the athlete transferred to the Seminoles. The coach allegedly lied to the NCAA about his involvement in the meeting. (The coach was offensive coordinator Alex Atkins, and the collective was Rising Spears, according to reports.) 

The actions violated several NCAA rules: using NIL as a recruiting inducement; allowing prohibited contact between a booster and a prospective athlete; and having a coach facilitate a meeting between an athlete and a booster. The list of punishments was long, though none required vacating wins or shutting down the program, nor did they punish the athlete in question, who ultimately didn’t transfer to FSU. Along with several new recruiting restrictions, the NCAA is forcing the booster and the collective to “disassociate” from the Seminoles for a certain period—the first time the NCAA has done so in the NIL era. 

The entire case illustrates how the NCAA, losing control and relevance over teams and conferences, wants to create an illusion of power. 

FSU’s conduct, while in violation of NCAA’s rules, is certainly not rare—it’s an open secret that coaches, boosters, and collectives are making offers to players, who are entering the transfer portal or going on recruiting visits with an expectation of learning how much they could earn. The NCAA clearly wanted to make an example of them in a likely unsuccessful attempt to slow this behavior. 

While considered harsh, the punishments are further proof of the NCAA’s lack of power. 

The 2021 Supreme Court case NCAA v. Alston, in which the NCAA lost 9-0, set a new legal precedent where the NCAA has become fearful of enforcing compensation restrictions or punishments lest it violate federal antitrust law. The NCAA was able to hand down these infractions through a process called a “negotiated resolution,” where FSU agreed to cooperate with the NCAA and agreed to all penalties. This system is used to prevent an antitrust lawsuit—if FSU hadn’t agreed to it, the school could easily sue the NCAA for antitrust violations. To that end, it’s unclear how the NCAA would enforce its disassociation requirement. 

The first case involving NIL was decided in the spring of 2022. The NCAA found recruiting violations in a meeting involving basketball players Haley and Hanna Cavinder and Miami booster John Ruiz, though it couldn’t prove that an NIL deal had been used as a recruiting inducement. The Cavinder twins, for their part, mocked the decision on social media. They then went on to help the Hurricanes with an unprecedented March Madness run.

However, the headache and potential PR incidents related to NCAA infraction decisions are enough to scare some schools. 

“The NCAA is attempting to create precedent to guide schools’ future conduct,” Dan Lust, Moritt Hock and Hamroff sports attorney and New York Law School professor, tells Front Office Sports. “That said, is the NCAA truly ready to open up the floodgates of enforcement, or will this be seen historically as another outlier similar to Miami women’s basketball and the incident with the Cavinder twins? If this is the true dawn of the ‘NIL enforcement era,’ the NCAA has set the bar, and schools must take notice.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Superdome Super Bowl

Superdome Renovations to Finish in Time for Super Bowl LIX

Renovations will total $500 million and have been ongoing for years.
Michigan defensive lineman Kenneth Grant celebrates a sack on Washington quarterback Michael Penix Jr. in the second quarter during the College Football Playoff national championship game against Washington at NRG Stadium in Houston, Texas on Monday, Jan. 8, 2024.

Pay-for-Play Is Here: Federal Judge Says NCAA Cannot Enforce Any NIL Rules

The ruling effectively allows pay-for-play to go forward uninhibited.
NFL salary cap

NFL Salary Cap Sees Historic Spike Ahead of 2024 Season

Each franchise was allotted $255.4M, which is a $30M increase for each team.
Lionel Messi

Copa América Tickets Climb in Latest Lionel Messi Effect

Tickets for Argentina’s game in Miami are pushing five figures.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

How the Negro Leagues Are Staying in the Game

0:00
0:00

Featured Today

Sham Gods: The Rapidly Growing World of Sports Impersonators on X

Fake Schefters and Wojs, fabricated trade demands, and borrowed profile pictures.
Sep 24, 2023; Oakland, California, USA; A general view of the Oakland Athletics dugout after the game against the Detroit Tigers at Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum.
February 24, 2024

Murky Future: Everything You Need to Know About the A’s Move to Las Vegas

Breaking down one of the most drawn-out, multifaceted sagas in sports.
February 18, 2024

Sabrina-Steph Wasn’t the ‘Battle of the Sexes’—But It Was Part of the Bigger War

The competition could play a factor in increasing the WNBA’s media value.
NASCAR Cup Series driver Bubba Wallace (23), in a Star Wars rebel alliance X-wing fighter pilot-inspired race suit, motions to the crowd to get louder during the driver introductions for the Cup Series Championship race at Phoenix Raceway in Avondale on Nov. 5, 2023.
February 17, 2024

Celebrity Owners, International Ambitions, and $7B Media Deals: Welcome to the New NASCAR

NASCAR boldly keeps pace with the increasingly competitive sports and entertainment world.

Careers

Powered By

Careers in Sports

Looking for a new job? Check out these featured listings and search for openings all over the world.
Finance Manager
FanDuel
New York, NY
Senior Technical Artist - Sports Technology
EA Sports
Orlando, FL
Assistant Manager, Affiliate Operations
Adidas
Portland, OR
Caitlin Clark

Big Ten Women’s Tournament Sells Out for First Time

‘Clarkonomics’ has made it to the postseason.
Nick Saban
February 22, 2024

Coaches Aren’t Happy With College Football—Some Are Getting Out While They Can

NIL and the transfer portal have many college football coaches getting new jobs.
February 22, 2024

Making Sense of What More CFP Expansion Would Mean

Leaders of the CFP discussed the potential for a 14- and even 16-team Playoff.
Sponsored

Live Sports Are Now High-Tech Experiences

Oracle is leading the technology revolution happening in stadiums across the world.
February 22, 2024

‘Treated Like Children’: College Football Players Offered $600 to Be in Video Game, No Royalties

Players may be receiving lower than the industry standard with the video game’s return.
EA Sports
February 22, 2024

EA Sports Offers Players $600 To Be In New College Football Game

The deal comes with a free copy of the game but without royalties.
Angel Reese
February 21, 2024

Angel Reese Denied ‘Bayou Barbie’ Trademark

No need to ‘unnecessarily instigate Mattel,’ lawyer says.
colorado
February 20, 2024

New Salary Records for Colorado Football Assistant Coaches

The 10 assistants will make a combined $4.65 million this year, a school record.