• Loading stock data...
Thursday, October 10, 2024
The Best Employers in Sports survey is now open! Take the survey

Is Venu Dead? Disney Still Pushing Forward With Appeal of Injunction

  • After Fubo got a temporary injunction in August that stopped Venu from launching, Venu partners Disney, Fox, and WBD are still pushing forward with an appeal.
  • Experts say Disney is likeliest of the trio to drop the effort, since it’s more focused on higher-priority streaming initiatives.
Jan 8, 2024; Houston, TX, USA; A detail view of an ESPN camera before the 2024 College Football Playoff national championship game between the Michigan Wolverines and the Washington Huskies at NRG Stadium.
Credit: Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

Before a federal judge granted a temporary injunction last month that FuboTV sought against Venu Sports, the three media giants behind Venu warned that such a decision would “terminate the joint venture.”

But in the one month since the injunction was granted, Disney, Fox, and Warner Bros. Discovery have not abandoned Venu. The trio has pushed forward with an appeal and is preparing for a trial as part of the same antitrust case Fubo launched days after the joint venture was first announced (minus a name, pricing structure, or launch date) in February. 

“If they were going to kill it, wouldn’t they have done it already?” says Brandon Ross, a partner at LightShed Partners, who adds that Disney “is the de facto leader of this group since they have the most sports rights.”

DirecTV—which came to an agreement with Disney over the weekend after a two-week carriage dispute—threw its support behind Fubo’s lawsuit. Fubo’s argument is it’s competitively unfair for Disney to license just its sports channels to its own joint venture when it won’t do the same for other pay-TV apps. To offer Fubo subscribers ESPN, Fubo must also take on National Geographic, Toon Disney, and other Disney-owned nonsports channels. 

Meanwhile, streamed sports content exists across disparate platforms due to the fragmented landscape of which companies have which live sports rights. 

“You have to have some kind of bundling,” former Fox Sports exec Patrick Crakes tells Front Office Sports. “Somebody does need to figure it out because, right now, the way the entertainment side balances out [the losses] is cutting spending on producing content. That hasn’t impacted sports yet, but it doesn’t take a lot of scientists to see that it might taper rights fees growth in the future.”

Disney, Fox, and WBD went against the norm by breaking out just their sports content for Venu, which Fubo claimed in a recent filing was done “to exploit the market power of those combined rights as a monopoly product” since Venu would boast “60-80% of US live sports streaming rights.”

DirecTV CMO Vince Torres, speaking at the Goldman Sachs Communacopia summit Thursday, again voiced DirecTV’s support for Fubo’s effort. 

“That’s a genre offering that we believe is good for consumers that we want to offer to [our] consumers,” he said of Venu’s sports content bundling. “I want to be able to do the same. I want to be able to deliver that type of product, whether it’s exactly that or something [similar]. … It’s the genre of sports, how do I serve that to consumers without the obligation to also have to give it to customers that don’t want it? The joint venture doesn’t have that obligation. What makes it anticompetitive is the fact that they’re forcing others to do things that they don’t have to do.”

So what happens next? For how long will Disney, Fox, and WBD dig their heels in, for a legal fight that could drag into 2026. 

According to an appeals court filing from last month, Fox had “127 employees dedicated to Venu” ahead of the planned launch at the end of August. 

“We had anticipated that Venu would launch at the beginning of the NFL and college football season,” lawyers for the joint venture partners wrote in an Aug. 23 motion for an expedited appeal to the injunction. “The preliminary injunction has shattered those expectations and placed our new platform in limbo.”

Disney did not respond to a request for comment for this story. 

While Judge Margaret M. Garnett in the Southern District Court of New York enjoined the launch of Venu with her ruling Aug. 16, there wasn’t a stay issued in the case. (A stay would have paused discovery and other progress in the civil case until the appeal is complete.) Last week, Garnett set an October 2025 trial date; the case will proceed while the joint venture partners seek to get the injunction overturned by the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals. The Venu partners have requested a December hearing in front of the 2nd Circuit, which, if granted, leaves a chance the appeals panel could rule in time for the Super Bowl. 

With legal costs mounting along with other expenses, could one of the Venu trio blink? Disney, which is preparing to launch its direct-to-consumer ESPN streaming app later this year, looks likeliest. 

LightShed’s Ross points out when Disney, Fox, and WBD first announced the app that would become Venu in February, Disney was dealing with activist investor Nelson Peltz, “and they were trying to do everything to make it look like they had a plan.”

Disney CEO Bob Iger won the proxy fight with Peltz in April, and a month later the billionaire sold his stake in the company. Disney, for now, hasn’t given any indication it will abandon Venu, and neither has WDB or Fox. 

Even if Venu gets the necessary court victories and launches, it will lack half of the NFL Sunday afternoon games (CBS/Paramount+), Thursday Night Football (Amazon), half the NASCAR schedule (NBC/Peacock), and most of the national NBA games beginning in 2025 (NBC/Peacock and Amazon), among other sports properties. 

“To me, as a consumer, it’s sort of an incomplete service,” NBCUniversal Media Group chairman Mark Lazarus said about Venu onstage at last week’s Front Office Sports Tuned In summit in New York. “It doesn’t have all sports. It has three companies’ sports, but that leaves out us, and Paramount, and Amazon, who have major sports portfolios or growing sports portfolios, and multitudes of other places that sports come in.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Cam Newton Joins First Take, Where His Opinions Should Fit Right in

ESPN has hired the 2015 NFL MVP as a contributor to First Take.
Sep 13, 2024; New York, New York, USA; United States men's national team head coach Mauricio Pochettino poses for a photo with chief executive officer and secretary general JT Batson, sporting director Matt Crocker, president Cindy Parlow Cone, and MLS commissioner Don Garber after a press conference introducing him as the new head coach for the United States men's national team at Warner Bros. Discovery Hudson Center.

U.S. Soccer, Flush With Cash, Lays Off Dozens

The nonprofit federation is expecting nine figures in revenue this fiscal year.
Nike

Nike Has Lost Some Mojo. But Not Its Market Share

Nike is in recovery mode but still enjoys a dominant slice of the market.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Patriots Hit Rock Bottom; WNBA Finals Begin

0:00

Featured Today

Duante' Abercrombie News Ch.4 interview

Tennessee State’s Ambitious Plan to Launch an HBCU Hockey Program

TSU has big plans, but the university is facing an existential dilemma.
October 8, 2024

Ryan Smith Sees Salt Lake City As Next Vegas-Like Sports Town

Utah Hockey Club’s owner says all the pieces are falling into place.
October 8, 2024

How the WWE’s Farm Circuit Became a Primetime Draw

NXT produces generational talent—and it occupies a new prime-time network slot.
A DraftKings sign
October 7, 2024

A DraftKings Exec Left for Fanatics. Then the Bitter Legal Battle Began

Mike Hermalyn has been sidelined at Fanatics for nine months now.

College Football’s Most-Hyped Weekend: Networks Set to Cash In

NBC gets No. 2 Ohio State at No. 3 Oregon, while ABC has No. 9 Ole Miss at No. 13 LSU.
October 9, 2024

NFL TV Ratings Strong Despite Dip

Most Week 5 broadcasts had smaller TV audiences than they did in 2023.
October 9, 2024

MLB Asks DSG for Immediate Clarity on 2025 Broadcast Plans

The league seeks answers from the regional sports network operator regarding the 2025 season.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
October 9, 2024

Utah Among NHL Teams Navigating RSN Decline, Rights Negotiations

Comcast declines to carry Utah games, sparking local NHL distribution challenges.
October 8, 2024

More MLB Teams Shift to League Broadcasts Due to DSG Disarray

The Brewers, Guardians, Twins opt to have MLB produce and distribute their local games.
October 8, 2024

MLB Playoff TV Ratings Soar 41%, Fueled by Drama and Ohtani’s Debut

A potent mix of popular teams, Shohei Ohtani, and on-field drama combines to become a powerful attraction to viewers.
NBA commissioner Adam Silver
October 8, 2024

Judge Rejects NBA’s Request to Seal WBD Digital Streaming Deal

The league could still request specific redactions.