Wednesday September 27, 2023
The Best Employers in Sports Survey is Now Open!

The Problems With Lane Kiffin’s NIL ‘Salary Cap’ Idea

  • Ole Miss coach Lane Kiffin suggested salary caps to limit NIL payments like “what happens in professional sports.”
  • Kiffin’s idea isn’t just a misrepresentation of the realities in pro sports — it's potentially illegal.
Dale Zanine-USA TODAY Sports
Front Office Sports Today

Writer’s Strike End a Boon for Sports Networks, Agencies

We delve into the potential long-term impact of the five-month strike.
Listen Now
September 26, 2023 | Podcast
Linkedin
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

At SEC Media Days, Ole Miss coach Lane Kiffin suggested a potential solution to the complaint that NIL has created an unfair advantage for schools in football recruiting: a team-wide “salary cap” on NIL funds managed by the coach — à la professional sports leagues.

In his defense, Kiffin admitted he didn’t have a fleshed-out plan, but there are serious issues with his suggestion — even beyond the fact that it’s based on a problem that NIL didn’t create  (the disparity in college football resources existed before NIL).

The idea itself suggests using NIL as an athlete’s salary — the No.1 thing the NCAA is trying to prevent. 

What’s more, a salary cap in college sports, as it currently stands, might not even be legal.

Kiffin’s idea doesn’t actually represent how pro sports work, as attorney Darren Heitner pointed out on Twitter. The professional equivalent of NIL deals are pro athletes’ off-field endeavors, from businesses to endorsements — and there’s no limit to how much an athlete can make on those activities in any law or league rulebook.

The idea would also imply that NIL payments are salaries for playing on a particular team — which is completely antithetical to what the NCAA wanted them to be. Regardless of whether one is in favor of paying athletes salaries, NIL is supposed to be separate. 

There could be major legal fallout if the NCAA — or any school or conference — tries to limit the amount of money an athlete can make through NIL. 

The Alston decision, while not specifically dealing with NIL, suggested that the governing body has less power to set compensation limits than it previously thought. If it tries to set strict rules, it could be found in violation of antitrust law.

And as attorney Marc Edelman noted, salary caps are only legal in other sports because they have the agreement of a union. NCAA athletes currently don’t even have an official collective bargaining unit. 

Ironically, a more helpful solution would be legalizing paying college athletes salaries and deeming them employees, as attorney Mit Winter suggested

Athletes could form a union and collectively bargain, a governing body could set compensation limits for equity between teams, and NIL payments would no longer necessarily be a requisite for recruitment. 

Linkedin
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Sponsored

NHL’s Chris Foster on Amplifying Content Distribution With Automation

Learn how the NHL is using WSC Sports to increase fan engagement.
Sponsored

How Daktronics Helps Elite Athletic Programs Secure Top Talent

How colleges are utilizing Daktronics' displays to elevate recruiting.

WBD Pursues ‘Different’ Strategy For Sports on Max

Company to place all of its live sports on new streaming tier

Colorado's Epic Victory Sets New ESPN Prime Time Viewership Record

Coach Prime Deion Sanders delivered in prime time on ESPN.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Taylor Swift Takes NFL to New Heights (w/ Andrew Brandt)

0:00
0:00

Featured Today

NFL's Swift Mania Starting To Show Impact Through Merch Sales, Viewership

Taylor Swift stole the NFL's spotlight by attending Sunday's Chiefs game.
First Take vs. FS1
September 26, 2023

Sharpe: 'First Take' Would Still Beat 'Undisputed' Without Stephen A.

Even if Smith leaves, Sharpe said he will still beat Skip Bayless in the ratings.
Rob-Manfred-MLB
September 25, 2023

Oakland-MLB Relationship Devolves Into Next-Level Toxicity

Commissioner, mayor have very different accounts of July meeting
Jacksonville Jaguars Team President Mark Lamping addressed community members at Strings Sports Brewery on Main Street for the first of 14 planned town hall sessions to present the team's plans for the new "stadium of the future" complex and address the public concerns.
September 25, 2023

Jacksonville Jaguars President Walks Back Stadium ‘Threat’

"Viewing those comments as a threat to leave Jacksonville isn't correct."

Careers

Powered By

Careers in Sports

Looking for a new job? Check out these featured listings and search for openings all over the world.
Chicago Cubs
Chicago
Fanatics
New York
Tri Star Sports and Entertainment Group, Inc.
USA - Multiple Locations

Up Next For College Football Playoffs: More Change, Money, And ... Streaming?

Many changes are coming to the CFP when it expands to 12 teams.
Big-12
September 22, 2023

Texas, Oklahoma's Big 12 Exit Could Have Cost $60M More

The school's move to the SEC is costing about $100 million.
Tickets for Colorado’s upcoming road game against Oregon are more expensive than 14 of 16 Week 3 NFL matchups.
September 20, 2023

Deion Sanders' Impact Makes Tickets Pricier Than NFL Games

Colorado-Oregon tickets are pricier than most Week 3 NFL matchups.
Boise State Broncos running back Ashton Jeanty (2) runs the ball against the North Dakota Fighting Hawks during the first half at Albertsons Stadium.
exclusive
September 20, 2023

The First Official Proposal for Promotion-Relegation In College Football

Realignment is forcing Group of 5 schools to rethink their structure.
Renderings of the University of Virginia's new proposed athletic facilities.
September 20, 2023

Virginia Joins The College Facilities Arms Race

UVA plans to upgrade football and Olympic sports facilities.
Michigan State head coach Mel Tucker speaks at post game press conference after 31-7 win over Central Michigan at Spartan Stadium in East Lansing.
September 19, 2023

Mel Tucker Firing Would Prevent $80M Buyout on Historic Contract

Tucker was suspended after a report of alleged sexual harassment.
SMU has raised $100 million from donors before it forgoes media rights payments for the first nine years of its ACC tenure.
September 18, 2023

SMU Raises $100M for ACC Move as Basketball, Football Sales Surge

SMU has raised $100 million ahead of its 2024 move to the ACC.
September 17, 2023

Coach Prime, Unbeaten Colorado Keep Larger-Than-Life Hype Going

Boulder was the epicenter of college football over the weekend.