• Loading stock data...
Thursday, April 24, 2025

The NCAA Could Be Willing to Risk Bankruptcy to Control NIL Collectives

  • The NCAA’s lawyer suggested the athlete pay settlement could hinge on whether it can include language to regulate NIL collectives.
  • The Collective Association, an organization representing dozens of collectives, accused the NCAA of trying to “claw back power.”
Sept. 7, 2024; Columbus, Ohio, USA; Ohio State Buckeyes tight end Jelani Thurman (15) signs autographs for fans following an NCAA Division I football game against the Western Michigan Broncos on Saturday at Ohio Stadium.
Barbara J. Perenic/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK

The NCAA has three weeks to decide whether it would be willing to risk bankruptcy to gain control over NIL (name, image, and likeness) collectives. 

In the two-hour-plus virtual hearing Thursday, the NCAA’s attorney, Rakesh Kilaru, made it clear the entire House v. NCAA settlement agreement could hinge on whether the NCAA can maintain language restricting NIL collectives. In exchange for agreeing to billions in damage payments, and even revenue-sharing between schools and players, the NCAA and conferences wanted the power to significantly restrict NIL collectives. The settlement gives a third party, chosen by the NCAA, the ability to block any NIL deal over $600 that it sees as above “fair market value” or “pay-for-play.”

The NCAA is willing to accept that schools pay athletes for playing on their teams, but it is still trying to keep boosters and collectives from doing so.

During the hearing, Northern District of California Judge Claudia Wilken made clear she would not grant preliminary approval to a settlement including these restrictions. While plaintiff attorney Jeffrey Kessler said he was fine with dropping them, Kilaru called the rules a key part of the settlement from the NCAA’s perspective. “Without it, I’m not sure there will be a settlement to submit,” he said. 

The parties now have three weeks to either provide an updated settlement proposal or go to trial. “Last night’s hearing did not go as we had hoped,” NCAA president Charlie Baker said in a letter to schools Friday, the text of which was obtained by Front Office Sports.

For collective operators, who have said since the proposal’s filing that the restrictions were unfair—potentially even illegal—it was a night of gloating and jokes in group chats. 

The Collective Association, an organization representing dozens of collectives across Division I, issued an incisive statement accusing the NCAA of trying to “claw back power.” 

“While we were pleased to see an attempt to provide justice to former athletes, the proposed limitations on third-party booster and collective deals were exposed as another attempt by the NCAA to take back rights from and decrease the overall NIL opportunities for college athletes.” The group added: “Moving forward, we encourage stakeholders in Congress and the media to be leery of both the motives and actions of the NCAA.”

The negotiation over this pivotal part of the deal isn’t really between the NCAA and conference lawyers and the plaintiff attorneys, who appear amenable either way. It’s with Judge Wilken, who is no stranger to the NCAA’s amateurism antics. She has presided over O’Bannon v. NCAA, finding it illegal for companies to profit off athletes’ NIL without compensating them; and Alston v. NCAA, the case that the NCAA lost 9–0 at the U.S. Supreme Court level and that found it was subject to the same strict antitrust scrutiny as any other company.

The NCAA could agree to the settlement without its precious NIL approval process, or potentially negotiate some sort of watered-down language, like inserting its existing NIL policy language into the settlement.

Though, as Kilaru said during the hearing, that may not be enough for a governing body that has struggled to enforce any NIL rules for the past three years. The NCAA has even less power since a federal court issued an injunction preventing the NCAA from enforcing NIL rules, particularly those that prohibit athletes from negotiating with collectives before committing to go to a school. (Curiously, no parties brought up this injunction during the hearing.)

Collectives themselves may have ideas about how to find a happy medium. But up to this point, neither the NCAA nor Power 5 conferences has engaged with The Collective Association in “any meaningful way,” according to James Clawson, cofounder of Tennessee collective The Volunteer Club.

“We’d still love to have more open dialogue with them. … We’d love to be, frankly, taken a little bit more seriously here,” Clawson says. “We would love to have conversations with the conferences, the NCAA—because obviously we touch so many parts of this ecosystem and have so much day-to-day knowledge of how it works.”

There is, of course, a way to exert control over NIL collectives—and the entire college sports compensation landscape. The NCAA could recognize athletes as employees, allow them to unionize, and enter into collective bargaining negotiations. This sort of process is what allows for pro league salary caps and restrictions on extra benefits, in exchange for protections and a voice for the athletes. 

But the NCAA would rather risk going bankrupt than give athletes formal legal negotiating power. The governing body and conferences are facing $4 billion to $5 billion in damages if they lose at trial, a sum they have said could have catastrophic consequences. That’s part of the reason they agreed to settle in the first place. 

While the governing body and conferences contemplate their fate, it’s business as usual for collectives that are more than used to rules that shift and change on a monthly basis. “I don’t think any of us were surprised” by the hearing’s outcome, Marc Spiegel, founder of a Louisville NIL collective called 502 Circle, tells FOS. “I think the full expectation is that the NCAA is going to try to exert whatever control they have left. And the courts continue to strike that down.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

The House Settlement Is in Jeopardy. Here’s What It Will Take to..

The parties will try to salvage the settlement over the next two weeks.
James Harden

Adidas Posts Big Profits in First Quarter Without Yeezy

Profits and sales are up after selling off remaining Yeezys last year.
NC State women's cross country

Judge Threatens to Reject $2.8 Billion House v. NCAA Settlement

The NCAA and power conferences could end up at trial.
Olympic rings

SafeSport Fires CEO Amid Scandal

Ju’Riese Colón was hired in 2019, two years after the agency’s founding.

Featured Today

Apr 5, 2025; San Antonio, TX, USA; Duke Blue Devils forward Cooper Flagg (2) reacts after a three point basket against the Houston Cougars during the first half in the semifinals of the men's Final Four of the 2025 NCAA Tournament at the Alamodome.

Cooper Flagg’s Timing Is Perfect for the NBA and USA Basketball

The projected No. 1 pick just declared for the draft.
Apr 14, 2025; New York, New York, USA; Paige Bueckers is interviewed by ESPN after being selected with the number one overall pick to the Dallas Wings in the 2025 WNBA Draft at The Shed at Hudson Yards
April 21, 2025

ESPN’s WNBA Coverage Mirrors the League’s Stunning Growth

“I don’t think we stand still in our coverage of women’s sports,” says Rowe.
Mar 16, 2025; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Oklahoma City Thunder guard Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (2) celebrates with guard Isaiah Joe (11) after score in the fourth quarter against the Milwaukee Bucks at Fiserv Forum.
April 20, 2025

Unorthodox OKC: The Thunder Redefined Tanking to Become NBA’s Best

A rebuild years in the making has OKC in the driver’s seat.
Mar 13, 2020; Augusta, GA, USA; The front entrance at Augusta National Golf Club in Augusta, Ga., Friday morning. The Masters Tournament has been postponed due to coronavirus concerns.
opinion
April 20, 2025

What’s It Like to Play Augusta? A Day on the World’s Most..

Inside a round at the most exclusive club in the world.
Dec 27, 2024; Memphis, TN, USA; Arkansas Razorbacks defensive back Miguel Mitchell (16) returns an interception during the forth quarter against the Texas Tech Red Raiders at Simmons Bank Liberty Stadium.

NIL Contract Buyouts Are More Common, but Can They Be Enforced?

The Arkansas collective has issued two demand letters to players to pay buyouts.
Fordham
April 23, 2025

Fordham Hit With Rare NIL Era NCAA Sanctions

The Rams were hit with recruiting violations stemming from a Times Square photo shoot.
Flau'jae Johnson
exclusive
April 23, 2025

Flau’jae Johnson Says She Will Return to LSU

The transfer portal closed Wednesday.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

This week, Two-time Super Bowl Champion and CBS NFL analyst Logan Ryan joins us to talk the business of sports on our third installment of Portfolio Players.
Mar 20, 2025; Providence, RI, USA; McNeese State Cowboys guard Quadir Copeland (11) brings the ball up court against Clemson Tigers forward Ian Schieffelin (4) during the second half at Amica Mutual Pavilion.
April 22, 2025

Why College Players Without NCAA Eligibility Are Flooding the Transfer Portal

Athletes nationwide hope legal challenges will win them extra eligibility.
Charlie Baker
April 22, 2025

NCAA Increases Lobbying Spending in First Months of Trump

The governing body spent $450,000 on lobbying during the first quarter.
April 21, 2025

UCLA’s Joey Aguilar Transferring to Tennessee in Quarterback Swap

UCLA quarterback Joey Aguilar will trade places with Tennessee’s Nico Iamaleava.
Dec 30, 2022; Glendale AZ, USA; The College Football Playoff logo on the field at State Farm Stadium, the site of the 2022 CFP Semifinal between the TCU Horned Frogs and the Michigan Wolverines and Super Bowl 57 (LVII).
April 21, 2025

CFP Format Questions Loom Over Spring Meetings

The CFP management committee is meeting in Dallas this week.