• Loading stock data...
Friday, May 23, 2025
exclusive
College Sports

The NCAA Appears No Closer to Getting Its Coveted Congressional Wish List

Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle told NIL collective officials, who spent the week in Washington, that the NCAA was unlikely to receive a blanket antitrust exemption.

Jan 20, 2025; Washington, DC, USA; Seats in Rotunda remain empty ahead of the Inauguration of U.S. President-elect Donald Trump at the U.S. Capitol on January 20, 2025 in Washington, DC. Donald Trump takes office for his second term as the 47th president of the United States.
Andrew Harnik-Pool via Imagn Images

As Russell White, who runs an association of dozens of NIL (name, image, and likeness) collectives, was leaving a Senate office meeting in Washington, D.C., earlier this week, he had a somewhat awkward run-in. He came face-to-face with Big Ten representatives, who were awaiting their own rendezvous with lawmakers.

“There were those kind of head nods,” White, the president of The Collective Association (TCA), tells Front Office Sports. “When you recognize each other, you know each other—but maybe you’re not the closest of friends.”

The NCAA and conferences were in Washington to continue to ask Congress to codify the House v. NCAA settlement (which allows for revenue-sharing) and declare athletes amateurs, rather than employees. But the real prize is an antitrust exemption, which would allow them to police the settlement’s terms themselves, and would halt the barrage of lawsuits that have forced them to change to amateurism up to this point. 

TCA met with about 40 offices, both Republican and Democrat, in the House and Senate this week—at the same time as NCAA and power conference administrators were doing the same thing. White described a lack of movement on Capitol Hill toward an NCAA-friendly law, despite the fact that the red wave was expected to help the NCAA’s interests

The majority of congressional offices TCA spoke with appear uninterested in granting the NCAA its coveted antitrust exemption, regardless of their political affiliation.

“What’s radical [to lawmakers] is not that athletes are being paid,” another attendee of the meetings on behalf of collectives tells FOS. “What’s radical is that the traditional members of college sports need an antitrust exemption. … That’s the biggest hang-up.”

Some offices are already on record about how amenable they would be to the NCAA’s requests. Sen. Ted Cruz (R., Texas), now the head of the Senate Commerce Committee, has released discussion drafts that would give the NCAA at least some antitrust immunity, as well as a no-employee clause. Cruz has said that a college sports bill is a priority in his committee during this Congress, but he has also acknowledged that it would have to be bipartisan. 

Democrats are less likely to grant antitrust immunity and a no-employee clause, sources have previously told FOS, given those issues fall on the broader political spectrum (though some, like Sen. Richard Blumenthal [D., Conn.] have said they’re open to the no-employee status idea). But not all of Cruz’s Republican colleagues are on board with antitrust immunity, either, TCA’s meetings revealed—making an NCAA-friendly bill even more difficult to pass.

The lack of consensus is part of the reason a growing number of college sports stakeholders, from football coaches to Olympic sports associations, have all lobbied up in the past several months. They all want to ensure they have input in college sports’ next era.

The Collective Association, for its part, is trying to advocate for what’s best for the players they work with every day, and field questions from legislators regularly on the best way forward, White says. “We talk through pretty much every aspect of the ecosystem.” Sometimes, that means agreeing with the NCAA. Other times, it doesn’t.

Giving the NCAA an antitrust exemption creates an existential threat for collectives. “College football will be just fine if there is no antitrust exemption,” White says. “The ‘sky is falling’ narrative is unreasonable.”

The group isn’t on board with all of the House v. NCAA settlement terms, either.

Collectives continued to lobby this week against a portion of the settlement that would give a third party (the NCAA has chosen Deloitte) the power to block NIL collective deals over $600 that could be seen as “pay-for-play,” rather than offering “fair-market value.” The clearinghouse is bad for collectives because it hinders their operations—but it’s also potentially bad for players because it hinders their paychecks. White calls it “garbage.”

White also said he raised issues with the roster limits that could be imposed as part of the settlement, because they have the ability to decimate the nation’s valuable Olympic pipeline. “I think taking the opportunity away from 20,000 to 30,000 athletes in non-revenue or Olympic sports is always concerning,” he says.

But he wanted to set the record straight on one thing: TCA is not lobbying in favor of collective bargaining or athlete-employee status, as some have suggested. “That’s laughable,” he says. “We’re not labor professionals; we’re not people who are up there that are saying, ‘This is how it should be.’” 

His suggestion: Ask the players what they want. “The athletes need to be involved in the system that’s being created that they will be operating under.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Around the Horn - October 26, 2020

‘Quirky, Nutty, Bombastic’: 10 ‘Around the Horn’ Faces on Their Top Moments

“A quirky, nutty, bombastic, mostly wrong, sometimes right, crazy sports family.”

New CFP Seeding Rewards Rankings, Not Titles—Except on the Paycheck

Last season, only conference champions could earn first-round byes.

Featured Today

AA Mint Cards

Young Collectors Are on a High-Stakes Chase for Ultra-Rare Trading Cards

“They just want that excitement of the chase,” says a 23-year-old collector.
Donnie Gobourne JDL
May 17, 2025

U.S. Professional Softball Players Are Flocking to Japan to Get Paid

The Diamond League offers paychecks and amenities that the U.S. can’t beat.
Jun 1996; Seattle, WA USA; FILE PHOTO; Seattle Supersonics guard Gary Payton (20) lays the ball up against the Chicago Bulls during the 1996 NBA Finals at Key Arena.
May 15, 2025

5,000 Pieces of Thunder History Are Hidden in Seattle

Sonics championship banners, trophies, and retired jerseys are all in one place.
Ohio State Buckeyes safety Caleb Downs (2) returns an interception during the second half of the Cotton Bowl Classic College Football Playoff semifinal game against the Texas Longhorns at AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas on Jan. 10, 2025. Ohio State won 28-14.
May 15, 2025

House v. NCAA Settlement to Pay College Athletes: All Your Questions Answered

The yearslong lawsuit over player compensation is in the home stretch.

Can Golf Emulate the College World Series Model?

Carlsbad, Calif., is hosting the event through 2028.
Ziegler
May 21, 2025

Tennessee Guard Sues to Play Fifth Year of College Basketball, Citing NIL..

Zeigler was a four-year player at Tennessee and third-team All-American.
Nov 23, 2024; Austin, Texas, USA; Texas Longhorns running back Quintrevion Wisner (26) is tackled by Kentucky Wildcats defensive back Alex Afari Jr.(3) during the first half at Darrell K Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium.
May 21, 2025

Some Schools Concerned About Memo Binding Them to House Settlement

The memo would attempt to prevent the schools from suing the conferences.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

In Episode 6 of Portfolio Players, dive into the world of sports investment with George Pyne, founder and CEO of Bruin Capital. Discover why owning a sports team is considered recession-proof, how leagues like MLB and UFC have adapted to the new media landscape, & the complexities of NIL.
Mar 8, 2025; Athens, Georgia, USA; Georgia Bulldogs guard Tyrin Lawrence (7) shoots over Vanderbilt Commodores forward Devin McGlockton (99) during the first half at Stegeman Coliseum.
May 20, 2025

Charlie Baker: Power Conferences Will Enforce House Settlement, Not the NCAA

The NCAA will cede enforcement of amateurism to the power conferences.
Mar 30, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Houston Cougars forward J'Wan Roberts (13) dribbles the ball against Tennessee Volunteers forward Felix Okpara (34) in the second half during the Midwest Regional final of the 2025 NCAA tournament at Lucas Oil Stadium.
May 19, 2025

Even If House v. NCAA Settlement Is Denied, State Lawmakers Let Schools..

States are making it illegal for the NCAA to stop schools from paying players.
May 19, 2025

Pac-12 Revenue Topped Big 12 in Final Year of Power 5 Era

The Pac-12 generated $566.6 million in revenue during the 2023–24 fiscal year.
Oct 5, 2024; Fayetteville, Arkansas, USA; Tennessee Volunteers quarte rback Nico Iamaleava (8) scrambles out of the pocket in the second quarter against the Arkansas Razorbacks at Donald W. Reynolds Razorback Stadium.
May 16, 2025

Will the House v. NCAA Settlement Actually End ‘Pay-for-Play’ NIL Deals?

Industry experts are skeptical the clearinghouse will be successful.