• Loading stock data...
Monday, November 4, 2024
The Best Employers in Sports survey is open through Nov. 6 Learn More

The Biggest Takeaways from The 10th Congressional NIL Hearing

  • After 10 hearings, there are still divisions over what stakeholders want an NIL bill to include.
  • However, officials are still trying to codify the NCAA’s business model of amateurism.
The Senate Judiciary Committee hosted the 10th Congressional hearing on NIL since 2020.
Jack Gruber-USA TODAY

On Tuesday, the Senate Judiciary held the 10th Congressional hearing on name, image, and likeness (NIL) rules in college sports. 

Seven witnesses — including NCAA President Charlie Baker, Big Ten Commissioner Tony Petitti, and Notre Dame athletic director Jack Swarbrick — convened on a panel for a two-and-a-half-hour session that covered topics ranging from NIL and athlete employment to the Israel-Hamas war.

Here are the three biggest takeaways from the hearing.

Lack of Consensus on NIL Bill

As has been the case since 2020, there appeared to be no consensus on the details of an NIL bill — beyond that most appear in favor of a uniform national standard. 

Multiple bills have put forth largely uncontroversial ideas, like the concept of a registration process for agents. But there was no agreement from the panel about the role of NIL collectives, how to enforce a prohibition on pay-for-play, or whether to legislate separate but related issues like the transfer portal.

In fact, there was more consensus around Congress passing laws related to athlete health and safety than the nuts and bolts of an NIL bill.

Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) asked if any panelists opposed Congress passing laws creating medical trust funds; guaranteeing scholarships of athletes who suffered career-ending injuries; enforcing health and safety standards; and requiring high-revenue schools to support covering insurance and medical costs. None of the panelists raised objections.

Protecting Amateurism

Multiple panelists reiterated the NCAA’s longstanding request for Congress to pass a law protecting the concept of amateurism — the idea that athletes are not considered employees under federal labor law. 

This request is more important for supporters of amateurism than ever, as this could be the last chance for Congress to pass a law that would clarify the status of athletes before courts and the NLRB decide for themselves. 

In addition to the two NLRB cases — both of which will have had hearings by the end of the year — there’s also a federal court case called Johnson v. NCAA over athlete employment status. 

Petitti, for example, said the conference would support a bill that would “codify benefits for student-athletes … without the need to classify student-athletes as employees.” 

Possibility of a Union?

Perhaps the biggest surprise: NCAA President Charlie Baker did not outwardly oppose the idea of a form of a college athlete union, despite being opposed to athlete employment status.

Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.), asked Baker flat-out if he would support an athlete union to have a greater say on multiple topics, including NIL and athlete compensation.

Baker noted that he wouldn’t speak to the two NLRB cases currently pending relating to athletes’ rights to unionize. He did note that he had concerns about “creating a system where you have one brush” to paint all athletes as employees (a requisite for a union.) 

However, he did not say he was against the idea of athlete unionization.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

New Era, New Chaos? New CFP Team Rankings Explained

The new College Football Playoff system’s complexities might confuse some college football fans.
Apr 1, 2024; Portland, OR, USA; USC Trojans guard JuJu Watkins (12) drives to the basket during the second half against UConn Huskies guard Paige Bueckers (5) in the finals of the Portland Regional of the NCAA Tournament at the Moda Center.

Women’s College Basketball Begins Its Star-Studded Post–Caitlin Clark Era

Women outdrew the men in the championship with 18.9 million viewers.
Sep 28, 2024; Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA; GOP Presidential candidate Donald Trump waves flanked by former Georgia Bulldogs player Herschel Walker, recording art Kid Rock, professional golfer John Daily, Alabama senators Tommy Tuberville (R) and Katie Britt (R) during the second half of the game between the Alabama Crimson Tide and the Georgia Bulldogs at Bryant-Denny Stadium.

Mission Swing State: College Football’s Political Advertising Battle

Trump, Harris, and the PACs that support them are utilizing the sport.
Eastern New Mexico forward Jose Murillo (33) passes the ball between Grand Canyon University forward Sammie Yeanay (23) and guard Makaih Williams (2) during an exhibition game at Global Credit Union Arena in Phoenix on Oct. 29, 2024.

Grand Canyon University to Join Mountain West in 2026

The Mountain West has added three new schools after the Pac-12 poached five from the conference.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Surprising Start to MLB’s Offseason

0:00

Featured Today

Vanderbilt Commodores fans head to the south end zone as the goal post is taken down by exuberant fans after beating No. 1 Alabama 40-35 at Vanderbilt Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., Saturday, Oct. 5, 2024.
opinion

Something New in College Football This Year: Parity

Upsets, surprises. CFB is more fun on the field than the NFL.
October 31, 2024

The Untapped Revenue ‘Powder Keg’ of Women’s NFL Fandom

There’s a “boatload” of money at stake for brands and the league.
Donald Trump holding a basketball in the White House
October 30, 2024

Mavericks Owner’s $100 Million Trump Donation Dwarfs All Other Sports Owner Political Giving

Dr. Miriam Adelson is one of the most powerful donors in U.S. politics.
Oct 19, 2024; Gainesville, Florida, USA; Florida Gators quarterback DJ Lagway (2) shakes hands while entering the locker room after a game against the Kentucky Wildcats at Ben Hill Griffin Stadium.
October 28, 2024

NIL Director Is the Trendy New Job in College Sports. But the Role Is Chaos

Athletic departments nationwide are hiring for what’s become their most important position.
Oct 4, 2024; Durham, NC, USA; Duke Blue Devils guard Cooper Flagg (2) is introduced to the fans during Countdown to Craziness at Cameron Indoor Stadium.

All Eyes on Cooper Flagg As College Basketball Tips Off

He makes his NCAA debut with Duke on Monday.
November 1, 2024

Olympic Sport College Coaches Hire Lobbyists Amid NCAA Upheaval

The NCAA and power conferences have spent millions on an effort to preserve amateurism.
Donald Trump
November 4, 2024

ESPN Will Drop First 12-Team CFP Rankings in Heart of Election Night

The network traditionally hasn’t shied away from going up against election coverage.
Sponsored

World Series Delivers High-Demand Marquee Matchup

The hype around the World Series matchup drove ticket prices to record levels—but the Dodgers’ dominance quickly quieted the fervor.
The Fox Big Noon Kickoff crew broadcasts from the endzone prior to the NCAA football game between the Ohio State Buckeyes and the Nebraska Cornhuskers at Ohio Stadium in Columbus on Saturday, Oct. 26, 2024.
October 31, 2024

ESPN-Fox Pregame Battle in Focus at Ohio State–Penn State

Fox has the game broadcast at noon ET.
October 28, 2024

College Football Playoff Expansion Already Heating Up Off-Field Drama

ESPN’s and Fox’s rival pregame shows will broadcast from the same campus.
October 25, 2024

College Coaching Legends Say Their Players Are Professionals

More and more coaches admit they see their players as pros.
Oct 19, 2024; Piscataway, New Jersey, USA; Rutgers Scarlet Knights quarterback Athan Kaliakmanis (16) throws the ball during the second half against the UCLA Bruins at SHI Stadium.
October 24, 2024

CFB Fans Can Thank Fox, World Series for 11 p.m. Rutgers Game

Fox has aired five Friday night college football games so far this season.